Revealing My Tinfoil Hat Theory
(I no longer believe this theory, but there was a bit of time where I believed it yesterday. This is me posting the theory I had thought)
Quote:
Originally Posted by LuckayLuck
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
Quote:
Originally Posted by LuckayLuck
Quote:
Originally Posted by G0tGame?
Why is that and what has changed for you?
Quote:
Originally Posted by LuckayLuck
I acknowledge that luckbox isn't the right vote today
Enough time has elapsed without an angel counter claim
I told them not to.
I think they should
So originally, it was straightforward that luckbox wasn't the right vote because nobody had counterclaimed them. Then, Luckbox just said "I told them not to counterclaim," I went with a "I think they should" and then right after said...
Quote:
Originally Posted by LuckayLuck
Wait a second...
The reason I said this is because I remembered this is the second time Luckbox has basically told the angel not to claim. So I looked back on Luckbox's posts and found
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
Anyway this game should be about solveable on Poe at this point.
Sun is a villager
Tbob is a villager
I'm a villager
Irtm is villager
Housenuts is a villager
That makes everyone else a wolf.
I found this outlandish because I didn't know why sun or tbob could be read as villagers.
Then I realized, AHA!! Luckbox placed Sun & TBob above himself, this must be a signal TO THE ANGEL that Luckbox is actually the watcher or tracker and he had somehow hit exactly the angel targetting someone and having them not die. A combination of Sun/Tbob would be the actual angel, and Luckbox saw the angel in Sun/Tbob target Sun/Tbob.
After a reading of Luckbox's posts and seeing how he only "hoped" that Sun was village yet had an unknown reason for Tbob being village, I figured Tbob was the actual angel. So, I set out to establish a secret message to Luckbox and TBob that "I had understood that Luckbox was not actually the angel but was actually the watcher or tracker, and I understood this, and that they understood that they could stay hidden and that trusting Luckbox was still fine here"
Quote:
Originally Posted by LuckayLuck
Hey everyone, I'm in less despair mode now that we got a wolf, I also like having secret information so that's nice
Quote:
Originally Posted by LuckayLuck
I think you're village, this line of thinking makes more sense on just Luckay is a villager, thinks we lost, and weird self votes imo
I didn't leave also
Also what may be surprising is I didn't actually follow what I said I was doing which may be good for me
This theory would actually only work if it were a REALLY SPECIFIC world where luckbox had somehow found the angel hitting someone. I didn't want to clue the wolves in so I tried to be as subtle as possible.
When Tbob asked me:
Quote:
Originally Posted by TBobLP
Luckay, is it LB's claim that changes your read of him?
I took this as confirmation that I was right - that Tbob was the angel - and that he was considering counterclaiming LB if I only read Luckbox as village because he was claiming angel, so I gave him
Quote:
Originally Posted by LuckayLuck
Originally I didn't believe in the angel claim but now I don't care if it's real or not
Yesterday, I was a lot more blatant because I realized my theory was almost certainly wrong
Quote:
Originally Posted by LuckayLuck
Yes I'll share it later, I just wanted to first say I no longer believe in a theory that would have had to be incredibly specific because if I give my theory and it's actually right then that would be lol
Because the only way it would work is if Luckbox were the watcher since that's the role that would have gotten the information. But VR had claimed the watcher. I didn't actually study up too much on if it were the tracker or watcher who got the result on the odd day so I had worked under the assumption that Luckbox were the tracker, which is why I was thinking that Sun Tzu was a wolf who claimed as the tracker and that we could hide that read for later and get him later.
Anyways, it was a completely nonsensical world but I figured I'd reveal it for your amusement