Quote:
Originally Posted by filthyvermin
this could basically all be said by a german in ww2 about germans who support the military
It could be. But incorrectly.
There's a lot of grey in modern warfare. A country torturing and butchering twelve million of its own citizens while invading its peaceful neighbors is about as black and white as it gets.
At some point, you have to decide that not cooperating is worth a court martial and imprisonment. BUT I'm not unsympathetic to the people who didn't. Psychology has taught us that it doesn't take a lot of pressure from someone in authority to get people to do things that they fervently believe are wrong.
I mean, filthy, you don't kill anybody, and good for you. But when you play poker you could be taking somebody's rent money. You could be taking food out of somebody's kid's mouth. You could be the reason a family is homeless and desperate. If they do end up living in their car, because you called their bluff when they were trying to win enough to pay their landlord their back rent, do you regret your occupation? Or is it just what you do?
Soldiers are trained by very thorough people to take orders and kill. If they kill someone in Afghanistan who is trying to kill them, they are not a murderer. But the person who ordered them there may be. It depends upon the decisionmaker and their motivations, just like circumstance and motivations (should) matter when a court of law is trying to determine if a killing is murder.
And the decision maker does not have to bear the aftermath of their decision either. They don't have to look their fellow human being in the eyes and see the spark leave them. That is borne by the soldier on the ground. I think there is a lot to sympathize with there.