Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
POG Politics Thread Version 3 POG Politics Thread Version 3

06-22-2021 , 08:52 AM
I hear some vaccine reactions/heart problems in kids. Real or fake?!
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-22-2021 , 10:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by pwnsall
I hear some vaccine reactions/heart problems in kids. Real or fake?!
probably real but it will get buried
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-22-2021 , 12:25 PM
There's at least reason to be cautious I think.

Plus considerations of how high the ethical standards should be for medical treatments.
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-22-2021 , 01:29 PM
duterte says you should go to jail if you don't get vaccinated
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-22-2021 , 02:44 PM
Put all the unvaccinated people together!
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-22-2021 , 10:14 PM


wow
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-22-2021 , 11:20 PM
elected? no way she's a real socialist.


must be an op.
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-23-2021 , 12:43 AM
idk about her, but i hope she's legit. i want to believe!


it's looking she won. 99% of the precincts reporting. i'm not sure how big her lead is. but i think she won
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-23-2021 , 08:08 AM
What even is a socialist anyway
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-23-2021 , 10:39 PM
lol this is pretty great

POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-23-2021 , 11:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by pwnsall
What even is a socialist anyway
you mean, officially?
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-23-2021 , 11:27 PM
I’m willing to chip in to the Move filthy to Buffalo fund.
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-24-2021 , 12:10 AM
not enough poker and bikini models in buffalo

lol socialism when it comes down to it
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-24-2021 , 12:10 AM
But there IS a big casino there!
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-24-2021 , 08:27 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by iamnotawerewolf
you mean, officially?
Nah ironically. Or maybe someone who socializes. Like how materialist means different things.
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-24-2021 , 12:16 PM
The differences between a socialist and a socialite, by pwnsall
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-24-2021 , 12:21 PM
They're the same thing!
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-24-2021 , 04:42 PM
For Mark k and filthy.


POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-24-2021 , 05:04 PM
if only it were as good as them just doing "nothing"
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-24-2021 , 05:49 PM
Given the silence of the community at large on this matter, I have no choice but to assume the community is cool with people that defend Stalin.

That's really, really sad. I get it, though; he mostly killed people from the Soviet Union and who gives a **** about them, right?

BTW, if Sun Tzu made that exact same post (the one I am quoting below) and swapped "Stalin" and "Hitler" he would have been (rightfully) submerged by angry posts.

Yet the only difference between these genocidal maniacs is that Hitler has a higher body count. Birdman can keep saying this is Nazi apologia if he wants.

Quote:
Originally Posted by UncleDynamite
This is a terrible argument, since choosing (or having to) live in a country does not constitute an endorsement of its laws and the actions of their governments, both past and present.

Furthermore, is whataboutism the best you can do while trying to defend North Korea?
Quote:
Originally Posted by UncleDynamite
You can try and defend an ideology without going to bat for someone that has killed millions of its own people.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sun Tzu
what do you mean millions?

Stalin killed gazillions with his bare hands and he ate all the grain in the country and paid the clouds not to rain
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-24-2021 , 05:51 PM
And now, let's see how Birdman tries to weasel out from some of his terrible opinions (which, granted are not as terrible as his Stalin apologia).

Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman10687
it takes some audacity to live in America and criticize another country's prison system
Here, Birdman infers that people living in a country with unjust laws should not get to complain about other states' laws.

An interesting way to defend North Korea, to be sure, since North Korea cannot be defended on its own merits.

After I called him out on this:

Quote:
Originally Posted by UncleDynamite
This is a terrible argument, since choosing (or having to) live in a country does not constitute an endorsement of its laws and the actions of their governments, both past and present.

Furthermore, is whataboutism the best you can do while trying to defend North Korea?
He tries to

i) Pretend not to know what I said he was arguing about, which was plain as day and
ii) Deflect attention from his terrible argument by trying to argue about the supposed actual meaning on a word I used (i.e. engaging in a rhetorical, rather than factual discussion - this will be relevant later)
https://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/s...postcount=9300

A brief exchange about rethoric follows, which I will link for completeness' sake:
https://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/s...postcount=9303
https://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/s...postcount=9309
https://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/s...postcount=9312

After the exhange has been completed, I attempt to get back to the topic at hand:

Quote:
Originally Posted by UncleDynamite
Now let’s get back to my argument: why do you think that people that live in the US should not get to criticize other peoples’ prison systems? Do you it is logical to assume they all (or even mostly) approve of it? If not, why should they not get to criticize other countries’ prison systems?
I, of course, do not get an answer to this. Instead, Birdman tries to bring the topic again to the meaning of the word "whataboutism" rather than addressing the fact that he thinks that people living in the US should not get to criticize the prison systems of other countries:

Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman10687
why is someone is the US criticizing the DPRK not whataboutism?
Quote:
Originally Posted by UncleDynamite
It would have been if you made an argument about US prison being bad earlier today (or so) and someone else said “but things are worse than North Korea” as a counterargument.
The finishing touch is Birdman having the gall to say that I was the one hung on rethorical question, which is what he was actually doing by bringing up the definition of the word "whataboutism" rather to address the fact that he thinks that people that live in a country with unjust laws should not get to criticize other countries.

Cliffs: do not engage Birdman and expect an honest discussion.

Spoiler:
If he could have defended North Korea on its merits, he would have done so
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-24-2021 , 05:55 PM
UD,
Stalin simply doesn't have the same sort of cultural salience in the US as Hitler does. Hitler is someone basically universally vilified whereas Stalin is more of an afterthought. People assume he was pretty bad but no one who hasn't studied Russian history actually knows anything or has any opinions on the matter.
But there isn't any reason why we here can't learn either.
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-24-2021 , 05:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Crossnerd
I can’t help but feel that this is because Hitler’s campaign to globally murder all the Jews is not really comparable to Stalin’s failed communism, and the comparison itself is fairly offensive, no??
TIL that over 9 million dead Soviet people are just "failed communism". Are you simply a victim of an American exceptionalist educational system that does not teach anything interesting about other countries, or do you simply think that since we're a bunch of drunken, vodka-drinking, balalaika-playing, ushanka-wearing bear huggers, that our lives are worth classifying under a label of failed communism.

Do you understand how easy it is to hide atrocities under labels?

This mother****er purged almost 700K Soviets in under three years, and there wasn't even a war involved. He did this to his own people. There is nothing worse than being a traitor. Nothing. There is a reason traitors inhabit Dante's Ninth Circle of Hell.

Quote:
The fact is this is the second time UD specifically has explicitly wished death on other poggers, and each time he has made it a point to emphasize that he is sober and means it and feels no remorse. So there really is no narrative here that it’s anyone else’s fault but UD’s. He has officially made this a habit, and that’s a huge problem in a community like this.
Lack of regrets confirmed.

I am not going to stay silent when I see Sun Tzu trolling me for saying something about Stalin. Again, if he said what he said about Hitler, the community would have rightfully lambasted him, and I don't care how offended that makes you, but they are on the same ****ing level.

I hope you enjoy playing with mets in next years Anniversary, Crossword. I am sure he definitely will not ruin the game for anyone (not to speak of what he did in a couple of recent games, which I frankly hope does not happen to you, because no one deserves that).

You will never admit I was right on him, but I was, and he deserved what I told him.

While I definitely had fun being part of this community for over 8 years and will miss some folks over there, I cannot justify being part of a group of people that is OK with Stalin apologists.

This is a complete dealbreaker, and while I could keep telling these *******s they should get cancer or whatever, I think I'd rather stop posting on POG, since if that's all I have left to offer, it means I have nothing left to offer.

I just need to complete the two games I am still running, of course, but I am too shocked (and frankly, heartbroken) by what happened to put more than a token effort in them anymore.

If anyone wants to talk with me, they can probably find me on discord or MU, but I also will also stop facilitating WW games on this site. There are a lot of qualified WW-mods now anyway, so I am sure POG WW will survive.


Last edited by UncleDynamite; 06-24-2021 at 06:22 PM.
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-24-2021 , 06:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by UncleDynamite
Given the silence of the community at large on this matter, I have no choice but to assume the community is cool with people that defend Stalin
by your own logic, you are a stalin defender
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote
06-24-2021 , 06:13 PM
it's not a coincidence that UD refuses to cite a source for his 9 million number
POG Politics Thread Version 3 Quote

      
m