Quote:
Originally Posted by metsandfinsfan
when my girlfriend died in 2005, her autopsy said she died of a case of viral meningitis and/or encephylitis,, but I know her disease is why she didnt recover
so how we report is always difficult.
I think it is obvious China has lied a lot
I am no expert on how much we have lied either way. I do agree with chim that we may have delayed testing to make our numbers look good, which is appalling. I dont see a lot of evidence that some of the other claims are true, but I am not dismissing them. All governments lie and fudge facts, and trump is absolutely not beyond reproach when it comes to this.
i dont think its helpful to play the blame game. we can only look forward.
i do feel the democrats delayed the relief bill too long, and now i feel a republican is trying to hold it up
just pass the ****ing thing and then fight for those other things after
Good post.
It's not just delaying testing (although that is part of it). There simply isn't bandwith or resources to test it all. People die, and stats are being counted elsewhere (like your gf, sorry to hear that, it sucks to deal with and it sucks to not get closure on real cause of death, I'm sorry you had to deal with that). I'd also note -- I'm not sure delayed testing was intentionally done by the administration to make numbers look good (although possible) or if it was hubris to assume we could do things better than the rest of the world (we can't). I have no idea what the motivation was, just what the facts are.
I'm just mad and sad. Public health is my field, my expertise. I'm not saying anything I got from the media or other sources. I am in regular contact with docs and nurses on the front lines who note even today people are dying and aren't being attributed to COVID. Again, to clarify, I'm not even saying this is some intentional suppression, but they are told to not bother spending time or resources testing those who are dead or about to die. We are suppressing our numbers, no matter the intent. I'm in regular contact with other public health experts and epidemiologists about how they are trying to deal with this, and how we are going to educate future students about this process. I'm sad I have people on the front lines who are going to be infected and possibly die because of mismanagement. I'm thankful my career shifted to Academia rather than in the field, because it's horrible right now. I'm thankful I can work from home and isolate myself.
I'm thankful those opportunities allow me to protect my pregnant wife. I'm upset how mismanagement is going to lead to death. Many stories will come out in the coming years about how the process is on the front lines. It's horrific. Your average person has no idea how bad it is.
I'm mad at our government because it's close and personal to me. People I know are involved and either being ignored or being put at risk. Americans are going to die directly due to the actions of the CDC and the administration. People already blew off expert advice due to messaging from the White House. It pisses me off.
We blew it. Plain and simple.
My main takeaway is please please please don't think that due to the fact we aren't testing everyone it means that fatality rates are lower than being advertised. We have no idea because we are not trying to, or have the capability to, have accurate numbers. No one I've talked to think there's evidence to think it is less deadly than experts suggest. We are under-reporting test cases, but also under-reporting deaths. The denominator and numerator in our cases are incorrect, so we have no idea what infection or fatality rates are. Everyone trying to guess that means it is less or more lethal are doing simply that - guessing.