Quote:
Originally Posted by Nicholasp27
Worst Smell: Rotting Corpse
I’ll quote some things that people who have smelled this say about it later but I don’t wanna mention yet potential future draft picks that will be just one component of how bad this smells.
Quote:
Originally Posted by CrimsonFox
sure i'll judge your smells.
buyer beware if i can't reproduce the smell...
Quote:
Originally Posted by CrimsonFox
rebuttal...
There is a chance I will have smelled your submission previously in life even tho I can't recreate it now. SO I'll have some data stored for those too.
If I've never smelled it. Well I can imagine ...but you'll likely not podium
you can ask me if you want
I thought about taking a corpse over my choice, rotten meat.
One could argue that a corpse is nothing but a big pile of rotten meat, but I'm willing enough to let the pick stand as different enough.
However, unless Crimson has smelled one in this life or a former one it seems corpse takes a bit of a penalty. I'd suggest other judges use Crimson's criteria. It's the reason I didn't take corpse myself.