Quote:
Originally Posted by monstrman
FINE
I ACCEPT THAT I WAS RIGHT AT THE BEGINNING
DARTHE/GRANT/REDD/MONSTR VILLAGERS
YOU WIN REDD
A couple of problems though.
Who's scum? Redd is clear. I'm clear (to me at least). The rest of you are just reads.
Best way to do this IMO is list everyone in order, town to scum. If everyone will make one of these lists they pay off a lot later. Include yourself and no two people can share a line, meaning you have to choose. Put gaps in big differences in read strength if you want to.
Darthe
Redd
Monstr
Gamer
Grant
Xhad
Wilv
WN
Afterwards I recommend making one liners about tinfoils and general concerns. Typically no more than a sentence or two per person. The format is concise and discerning.
Redd claimed vig. No reason to not trust that and he has been my top townie this game.
Monstr I had a bit of a tinfoil on for a while but it would have required that he openly work with other teammates who also appeared town and would have gained them little. + EOD
Gamer I have liked all of the posts of that I recall. Off the top of my head I almost forgot to include him tbh, something that concerned me for a sec.
Grant probably should be where gamer is, they would be on the same line if I could put them on one. Such incredibly solid posting.
Xhad, if I am wrong about a strong lean it is here or gamer. His slot has been all over the place in my game and im not going hard at him only because he was essentially the only reason tzu died which makes little sense as a scum bus at that time unless they were w/w and he was a PR. Concerns me.
Wilv nothing good and nothing bad. The only reason he isn't scum is because he has been a mislynch twice I think.
WN i don't remember him but the case red made on his EoD makes him look terrible so atm he is bottom rung. Also, to mark this point, I don't remember him in any way from the past 120 pages. Not a good sign ever.