Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er [Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er

07-11-2014 , 11:41 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ZomgHax
Does anyone have any reasons for thinking Redd is a villager?
I think there's much better targets. I tried to explain earlier why I like him as a villa. Basically his attitude so far is mostly village-redd.

If you're set on it now, I hope he comes in and is able to change your mind.
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:44 PM
That EOD is going to have a lot of payoff IMO. Off memory X and Batman stood out in a bad way there. I also think that if Batman flips scum that now psuedo-confirms Tzu as town since bats is the only one who was willing to CFD with me anywhere that I went.
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ZomgHax
Does anyone have any reasons for thinking Redd is a villager?

Speak now before I use my 1-shot vig on him.
Any reason to think he isn't a villager that make sense?
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:45 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by monstrman
Unless the wolves are the ones calling me a villager that would be lol

But then it would probably just be redd idk.
I think I'm missing something. Are you a sucker for people who town-read you?
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:47 PM
Every time I see a gamer dude post my heart swells.

Red
Darthe
Gamer
Monstr

The village Gotham deserves.
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:50 PM
No. Maybe. I don't know.

I'm pretty sure that the wolves are going to either a) try to get me mislynched

Or b)kill me

Because there are probanly enough players itt correctly reading me for them to kill them off to leave only those leaning wolf on me alive and I am also going to remain obvious and an annoyingly loud thorn in the side of everyone all game so they might just kill me because aids.

Unless of course the wolves are the ones clearing me. That just probably makes the mislynch ing me scenario even more likely.
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:51 PM
For clarification:

Them1 = wolves

Them2 = potential villagers clearing me
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:51 PM
ok, I'm seriously going to need someone to even explain the eod argument to me. Here's my perspective of what went on:

-I already had my vote on my preferred lynch
-Nobody really had an argument against it other than "zomg he's town wtf are you doing"
-I was around to hear the counterarguments that weren't there
-I decided the best use of my time would be to investigate the counterwagon and see if there was something I was missing
-Somehow, people think this is indicative of a wolf even though a wolf could make up an explanation just as plausible as most other people voting for the mislynch

Like, we can argue about whether my play was bad, but I literally don't even get the argument for it being wolf. Similarly, I don't get why you think a wolf would just be silent at eod (but clearly being willing to answer questions) instead of, you know, actually come up with a rationalization to make the vote he wants and then make that vote. Walk me through my master plan here. Was it to out both myself and a teammate in exchange for one mislynch that would have happened anyway? Using a wagon I started myself? wtf are you people even accusing me of doing?
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:52 PM
monstr buddy you're tinfoiling a bit much here. And you talking to yourself is beginning to creep me out.

Get some rest or something and we'll talk about the logistics tomorrow when day begins.
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:53 PM
I'd bet everyone here is a villager and the wolves don't post much/at all before the nk shows up
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ZomgHax
Yea Gamer, BATM is a likely waffle.

Wilv/BATM/Redd wins it 7% of the time.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ZomgHax
Meant to put 17% of the time.

This math is based on no logic. So don't try to solve the equation Sun.
too many variables anyway

Spoiler:
wilv = 30%
BATM = 79%
redd = 72%
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:53 PM
Am doc <3 will protect

[spoiler][spoiler]not really[/spoiler]

really[/spoiler]
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:54 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xhad
ok, I'm seriously going to need someone to even explain the eod argument to me. Here's my perspective of what went on:

-I already had my vote on my preferred lynch
-Nobody really had an argument against it other than "zomg he's town wtf are you doing"
-I was around to hear the counterarguments that weren't there
-I decided the best use of my time would be to investigate the counterwagon and see if there was something I was missing
-Somehow, people think this is indicative of a wolf even though a wolf could make up an explanation just as plausible as most other people voting for the mislynch

Like, we can argue about whether my play was bad, but I literally don't even get the argument for it being wolf. Similarly, I don't get why you think a wolf would just be silent at eod (but clearly being willing to answer questions) instead of, you know, actually come up with a rationalization to make the vote he wants and then make that vote. Walk me through my master plan here. Was it to out both myself and a teammate in exchange for one mislynch that would have happened anyway? Using a wagon I started myself? wtf are you people even accusing me of doing?
You were essentially lurking and then tried to snipe a vote against the lynch you'd been advocating for a long while.
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:54 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xhad
ok, I'm seriously going to need someone to even explain the eod argument to me. Here's my perspective of what went on:

-I already had my vote on my preferred lynch
-Nobody really had an argument against it other than "zomg he's town wtf are you doing"
-I was around to hear the counterarguments that weren't there
-I decided the best use of my time would be to investigate the counterwagon and see if there was something I was missing
-Somehow, people think this is indicative of a wolf even though a wolf could make up an explanation just as plausible as most other people voting for the mislynch

Like, we can argue about whether my play was bad, but I literally don't even get the argument for it being wolf. Similarly, I don't get why you think a wolf would just be silent at eod (but clearly being willing to answer questions) instead of, you know, actually come up with a rationalization to make the vote he wants and then make that vote. Walk me through my master plan here. Was it to out both myself and a teammate in exchange for one mislynch that would have happened anyway? Using a wagon I started myself? wtf are you people even accusing me of doing?
relax, man

you're fine
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by monstrman
No. Maybe. I don't know.

I'm pretty sure that the wolves are going to either a) try to get me mislynched

Or b)kill me

Because there are probanly enough players itt correctly reading me for them to kill them off to leave only those leaning wolf on me alive and I am also going to remain obvious and an annoyingly loud thorn in the side of everyone all game so they might just kill me because aids.

Unless of course the wolves are the ones clearing me. That just probably makes the mislynch ing me scenario even more likely.
I find it hard to believe you believe this.
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gamer Dude
You were essentially lurking and then tried to snipe a vote against the lynch you'd been advocating for a long while.
Which, to be fair, is bad play regardless of alignment. It in and of itself may not be alignment indicative but since we have no meta on him we have to take it at universal value.
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:56 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sun Tzu
I find it hard to believe you believe this.
I feel like I know monstr better than you already.
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by monstrman
I had a tinfoil that Darthe/grant were w/w based on their interaction itt earlier.

But it was probably wrong.
can you explain this anyway

no one will hold it against you if it's stupid
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Darthe
Every time I see a gamer dude post my heart swells.

Red
Darthe
Gamer
Monstr

The village Gotham deserves.
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Darthe
Which, to be fair, is bad play regardless of alignment. It in and of itself may not be alignment indicative but since we have no meta on him we have to take it at universal value.
right

it's like, I think my switchvote was bad play 100%

but as bad as it was as villa it is like 1000% worse as wolf. My switch was a bad village play, but it's not even remotely logical bad play from a wolf. Note Gamer just repeated the accusation without explaining why a wolf would actually do it, even though that was literally the only question I asked.

(hint: Gamer pretty much has to frame me to not look like obvscum if wilv is scum)
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-11-2014 , 11:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Darthe
I feel like I know monstr better than you already.
that's not hard since I don't know him from adam
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-12-2014 , 12:00 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sun Tzu
can you explain this anyway

no one will hold it against you if it's stupid
It started with darthe's "grant has gone down to my muddled pile" which read like a wolf preparing to potentially bus his partner

Then grant was like "k I'm more comfortable there" which just read weird

Then they both kinds just said "whatever" and walked away from the conversation
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-12-2014 , 12:02 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xhad
right

it's like, I think my switchvote was bad play 100%

but as bad as it was as villa it is like 1000% worse as wolf. My switch was a bad village play, but it's not even remotely logical bad play from a wolf. Note Gamer just repeated the accusation without explaining why a wolf would actually do it, even though that was literally the only question I asked.

(hint: Gamer pretty much has to frame me to not look like obvscum if wilv is scum)
I can see that I just don't think it scummy of him. Not yet anyways. If he was to harp on this endlessly and without reason I would get it. If he tried to lynch you for it I would get it being scummy. Eh, atm it's just a point against you.
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-12-2014 , 12:03 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xhad
right

it's like, I think my switchvote was bad play 100%

but as bad as it was as villa it is like 1000% worse as wolf. My switch was a bad village play, but it's not even remotely logical bad play from a wolf. Note Gamer just repeated the accusation without explaining why a wolf would actually do it, even though that was literally the only question I asked.

(hint: Gamer pretty much has to frame me to not look like obvscum if wilv is scum)
To preserve your wolf bro. Pretty I mentioned this.

Voting like that isn't condemning and doesn't out you if you're a wolf.

Your vote wasn't even that bad. It's the fact you basically lurked EOD, said you wanted wilv lynched then last second tried to get Quarrr lynched.

Had you participated actively during EOD, because we all know you were here, and then voted Quarr last second (while also not advocating how strongly you thought wilv was a wolf)

Then this conversation would not be happening
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote
07-12-2014 , 12:04 AM
It's not the vote itself it's the collection of things leading up to the vote that make it as bad as it was.
[Game Thread] 7/10 V+ C9++ Setup 13er Quote

      
m