Innocent III - 4
eyebooger
iraisetoomuch
xander biscuits
aaronk56
ACES:
Pope Gregory VII - Aaronk56's Son John Paul II - Booker Wolfbox gregory 12 - DarkMagus Paul - derwipok Pope Gregory the Great - eleanor60 Pius 12 - Gamer Dude Pope Innocent - JMurder3 Urban II - rtspurs John - sixfour Gregory - True North
Please let me know if you think I should group something in previous question.
I think Gregory and Gregory the Great is most debatable one bc you could make an argument that both meant Gregory I, but Gregory is just too wide answer imo to count it as Gregory I.