Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot

10-03-2018 , 06:16 PM
3rd Pass:

France
Port
Teacher
Water
Wave

I'm totally guessing here but the only thing that could make sense is France. If the flintlock gun originated in France then it would be a slam dunk. In the olden days Napoleon fought in a lot of wars, so it's possible.

Revolution could be the 3rd red word for the Communist connection. I don't like France to be the 3rd red word because of Tokyo still being on the board
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-03-2018 , 06:19 PM
If it was up to me I'd go France but I'm not just going to swoop in after 2 days of absence and ruin all your hard work.

Someone else tell me a possible reason to go quite so specific as flintlock and you've got my attention, but I'm not seeing it.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-03-2018 , 06:21 PM
I'm ok with France over Racket.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-03-2018 , 06:24 PM
I can see racket as a slight fit but surely:

1). you'd go musket or cannon or gunpowder over "flintlock"
2). you'd try to fit racket in with cricket if you were able to fit stick in there
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-03-2018 , 06:35 PM
Racket may have been the real cricket answer.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-03-2018 , 07:55 PM
I don't know that bayonet is a French invention but it sure does sound French. And it would have the same equity as flintlock if they're both French.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 12:08 PM
We've been quiet for a couple of days here. I'll give my team til later tonight to make some progress. Absent of that I'm going to guess France, which seems to be the closest to a consensus and end this game one way or the other.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 12:29 PM
I'm against racket, fine with arm, ok with France, and still on team torch.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 12:31 PM
I think we're committed to France at this point?
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 01:49 PM
I'm using my one-time on this.

france

one time!
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 02:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bolt2112
I'm using my one-time on this.

france

one time!
neutral
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 02:17 PM
street - 3
fly - 6
animal - 4
crust - 3
cricket - 4
tongs - 3
Iran - 0
classics - 3
red - 3
mountie - unlimited
flintlock - 3


Arm
Lawyer
Ninja
Oil
Port
Racket
Saturn
Teacher
Telescope
Tokyo
Torch
Water
Wave

Cat
Fighter
Kangaroo
Mouse
Shark
Block
Field
India
Stadium
Hollywood
Stick
Dwarf
State
Model
Pistol
Revolution


Bat
Parachute
Robin
Spider
Court
Ice
Moon
Pie
Lab
Olympus
Shakespeare
Canada
Horseshoe


Limousine
Ghost
Bar
Pass
Beijing
School
Belt
France
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 02:23 PM
If our last word is torch I'm gonna have a lot of egg on my face.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 02:33 PM
I'll mostly regret if it's arm
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 05:28 PM
educator - 1
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 05:40 PM
Teacher

Then ninja and arm?
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 05:42 PM
Teacher is blue
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 05:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Carl_Spackler
() = overlap, underline = to possibly be picked

I guess this works?

Fly 6

bat
parachute
robin
spider
moon
arm

Crust 3

pie
(moon)
ice

Tongs 3

lab
Ninja
(arm)

Classics 3

Olympus
Skakespeare
Model

Mountie

Canada
Horseshoe
this is where Carl last had us.....
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 05:52 PM
I like Ninja because we picked it before (it was never ruled on) and he never moved us off it, but I think we should figure out what they missed before we pick arm..

Question 2 would give us teacher and arm, would it not (Edit nah....lawyer is on there)???
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 06:08 PM
Looking back at their Flintlock 3 they picked pistol and revolution and they were good. They spent quite a bit of time making cases for and against arm, france and racket.

We should normally be worried about arm, but spurs gave us a educator 1 clue (teacher), with no new hints as to what our last two picks should be. That should leave us with picking Ninja and arm. I cant think of any good reason to give a 1 clue for 3 words except that he didn't want to throw in a 2 clue that might confuse us?

Is there any chance that spurs is doing anything other than saying pick the two underlined words on Carl's list.. Ninja and arm..??

That said, are there some obvious teacher/arm or teacher/Ninja clues out there?
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 06:26 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ArcticKnight
That said, are there some obvious teacher/arm or teacher/Ninja clues out there?
Definitely sensei for the latter.

But if spurs didn't want us to say ninja/arm here, giving a 1 clue was really bad. It feels so obvious that I almost bolded them with teacher.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 06:29 PM
Yeah, EB, I think we are on the same page re spurs' thinking. I am good with Ninja and arm if Carl and e_holle are...
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 07:43 PM
Ninja/ arm makes sense. Give me just a couple of minutes to look back
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 07:48 PM
He should be expecting us to say ninja and arm here, so I expect they are good.
We had brought up the idea of teacher as a classics word and kind of forgot about it, so it all falls into place.

I think we can probably just bold 'em
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 07:58 PM
Ninja
arm
pop bottles
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote

      
m