Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot

10-05-2018 , 08:01 PM
Excite
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 08:08 PM
both blue, gg all.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 08:09 PM
Notes:

fly - 6 I had 4 locks, 1 I thought you'd get there, and then 1 more that 2 blues had some equity for

Bat
Parachute
Robin
Spider - another insect, and he eats flies
Moon - fly me to the moon
ninja - flies through the air doing ninja ****
horseshoe - isn't there a game where you throw a horseshoe?

tongs - 3 So I'm actually vaguely aware of the gang reference but it didn't click until e-hole mentioned it. At least it inadvertently veered you to ninja.

Arm - tongs have arms
Lab - they are used mainly in two contexts afaik, one is in a lab (and I know there are science teachers present)
Horseshoe - the other main use for tongs imo is blacksmiths/metalworkers, making horseshoes and other cool stuff.

classics - 3 This is a a school subject and thing by itself. Getting rid of the plural, and getting to car model was a step further than staying with the actual meaning of the given word imo. I was banking on you guys reviewing this after, so didn't steer away from model.

Olympus
Shakespeare - A bit of a stretch imo but well done picking it up.
Teacher - A flip between this and school for you guys, and one was neutral so you should get it on the next turn. This is spurs' spymastering 101.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Carl_Spackler
We can't possibly have school and teacher, or he just says classics 4 I think. If it is one of them, he'd pretty much be hoping we guess lucky. The other would have to be neutral I'd imagine.
I think I misunderstood the logic in your flip. You are either choosing model... OR... choosing school in order to pick teacher next go if school is neutral. This dilemma can probably be solved by basic statistics but I've been drinking so I won't attempt it right now

mountie - unlimited

Canada
Horseshoe

Obvious enough^


These games are time consuming and I just started a masters. I'm not sure I can commit to them any more even though I do enjoy them. Maybe we could try a different one of the suggested iterations that has less words but is a fresh challenge?
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 08:16 PM
I just forgot about teacher until after we guessed last round.

I was planning on bringing it up again, but educator made it obvious

Last edited by Carl_Spackler; 10-05-2018 at 08:21 PM.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 08:20 PM
So what was our last word???
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 08:21 PM
gg all.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 08:22 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rtspurs
I think I misunderstood the logic in your flip. You are either choosing model... OR... choosing school in order to pick teacher next go if school is neutral. This dilemma can probably be solved by basic statistics but I've been drinking so I won't attempt it right now
Good job spurs

I get your logic. Carl was correct that it was not teacher and school, but that did not mean it couldn't be model. In fact, with two similar probables (teacher and school), one could argue that the situation makes model more likely than either teacher or school.

You did a great job, spurs..... we be 4-0.....

As far as us playing another game, it makes no matter to me, as I am not spymaster.... I think Carl is up so he can decide... Not sure who has not spied for Foxtrot. But, I am ok with stopping here or playing game 5..

Let's hear what Foxtrot has to say??
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 08:26 PM
Clue giving us the only thing that is time consuming. I try to limit myself to like ten minutes and not go crazy.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 08:27 PM
I'll spymaster if the majority wants to continue, but I don't mind stopping either.

Team echo has been in a long list game since August 7th.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 08:31 PM
Yay!

GG all.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 08:38 PM
Well done, team mates and opponents.

If there is a desire to play the 5th game, I'm in, but I certainly don't mind if we stop. Lot of codenames and similar games lately, and I won't mind a rest. Of course, I'm a sucker for games, and like a rat with an orgasm button, I'll probably keep pushing it until I starve to death.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 08:40 PM
And if we play more, I'll try to keep unusual meanings for words to myself.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 09:01 PM
Model
India
Stadium
Stick
Revolution
Kangaroo
Dwarf
Cat
Racket
Field
Pistol
Mouse
Fighter
Block
State
Hollywood
Shark

Pie
Spider
Arm
Moon
Teacher
Parachute
Horseshoe
Ice
Ninja
Court
Canada
Robin
Lab
Shakespeare
Olympus
Bat
Wave
Beijing
Torch
Limousine
Telescope
Belt
Pass
Bar
School
Lawyer
Tokyo
Port
Saturn
France
Ghost
Oil
Water
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 09:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JMurder3
So what was our last word???
racket
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 09:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by e_holle
And if we play more, I'll try to keep unusual meanings for words to myself.
Do not
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 09:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rtspurs
racket
Quote:
Originally Posted by JMurder3
If not arm, it could be racket, they're loud af I think, & we could have spurs'd stick & nails might have been going racket for cricket? Either because of sports connection or because they're loud?
Quote:
Originally Posted by JMurder3
After pistol, I think we always have to go revolution.

Then it's a matter of Arm, France or Racket (imo). Arm could be one of their tongs words, & I think nails clues something different if he's only trying to get us away from oil? I would also argue that if he was only trying to get us away from oil, he's better off giving us a usable clue & just taking the hit if oil is an assassin & we guess it. I think he ought to be trying to get us away from 2 words there.

I like racket a bit better than France due to the potential cricket crossover, & I think flintlock weapons are probably really loud due to the firing mechanism & that might be what led him to choose that over a musket or something? I'm sure muskets are super loud too, though.
Boom
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 09:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by e_holle
And if we play more, I'll try to keep unusual meanings for words to myself.
Quote:
Originally Posted by rtspurs
Do not
Yeah, it's a promise I probably couldn't keep.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-05-2018 , 09:58 PM
Racket must have been the real answer for cricket then, not stick
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-06-2018 , 12:40 AM
GG all, and great effort, Foxtrot teammates. We almost got there.

My recap:

With 50 words, there are so many blockers in the long game; it was tough to find clues that wouldn’t lead to at least one wrong guess.

Street 3 (block/fighter/model) – this was a terrible clue. Not just that “street model” is an outdated phrase; I simply didn’t consider all of the alternative possibilities. I knew limousine was a potentially wrong guess (and your first one, as it turns out), but never considered court and pass, let alone oil.

Animal 4 (cat/kangaroo/mouse/shark) – after blue unblocked bat, robin, and spider, it opened the door for this clue. You guys nailed those four plus fighter before missing with court.

Cricket 4 (field/stadium/India/stick) – with bat off the board, I thought I could clue for stick along with the other three. If you went racket instead, that would have been fine, too. You got the first three, then missed with pass.

Iran 0 – it was clear from your discussion that your next guesses were going to be arm for cricket (blue) and oil for street (dark orchid). I thought it was more important to steer you away from those than give any other clue. You guys got stick and spursed into Hollywood, which had the added benefit of seemingly satisfying the street clue (a good thing, since there was nowhere to go there).

Red 3 (dwarf/state/revolution) – I knew revolution wasn’t the same relationship to red as the other two, and I almost went “Reds” instead, but I thought that might get you away from dwarf and state. Belt was the most likely miss, and so it went after you got the first two…

Flintlock 3 (pistol/revolution/racket) – I think I got a bit too cute here. Clues get parsed very deeply in this game, especially with so many players, so I hesitated to go with musket because it’s a rifle, not a pistol. But I should have gone with it anyway, because the gun connection with pistol is obvious. I thought flintlock would definitely get pistol and revolution, and hoped you’d go racket by POE.

I have no opinion on continuing -- will happily play on if that's what the group wants, but am OK with ending it here if that's the majority opinion.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-06-2018 , 12:51 AM
Yeah, good job, I should have fought for it harder. Blech. GG.
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote
10-06-2018 , 12:52 AM
Yeah! Geez!
Codenames Long-List best 3 of 5: Team Echo vs Foxtrot Quote

      
m