If it's demonstrably false then it should be trivial for you show as much, no?

This is also a fair point

its really weird that AMI was hanging out and posting in the main thread when EOD was called early any never voted

It would be pretty trivial if now were the time to do so, yes

What I can offer now is that you actually read my posts

Whoever killed Tokyo I thank you much

Yes it is

Although it makes me think more that the early nightfall was a master production that perhaps wasn’t as well planned as it could have been lol

13er

Villagers

Uglydelicious
Birdman10687
AriesRam
HerbieGRD
Gadarene
EADGBE
Ladd

Unknown

Montecore
LKJ
Luckbox Inc
Sun Tzu

Wolves

Biggerboat - minion
Bsball8806 - has to be either the torturer or the alchemist


AriesRam (3): Gadarene (61), Luckbox Inc (68), Birdman10687 (99)
Notes: 2 villagers, 1 unknown

EADGBE (3): biggerboat (18), Montecore (54), bsball8806 (23)
Notes: 2 wolves, 1 unknown

bsball8806 (2): LKJ (18), Sun Tzu (50)
Notes: 2 unknowns

Uglydelicious (1): AriesRam (33)
Notes: 1 villager

biggerboat (1): EADGBE (17)
Notes: 1 villager

Not voting (3): Ladd (0), HerbieGRD (48), Uglydelicious (27)
Notes: 3 villagers



Main Thread

Villagers

Aaronk56
Fanmail
KingWiggles
Iraisetoomuch
Zurvan
Tedxtr
SGT RJ
shortline99

Unknown

aao
Carolinacoder
Filthyvermin
Crackedquads
Eric
Treep
Traz
Fnord_too
Nicholasp27

Wolves

A missread issue - minion
Chocolatte - minion
Tokyo!! - minion
Master3004 - dark sorcerer


Fanmail (2): master3004, filthy
Notes: 1 wolf, 1 unknown

Master3004 (2): SGT RJ, fanmail
Notes: 2 villagers

Treep (2): crackedquads, Zurvan
Notes: 1 villager, 1 unknown

Aaronk56 (1): Treep
Notes: 1 unknown

Crackedquads (1): Tokyo!!
Notes: 1 wolf

SGT RJ (1): aao
Notes: 1 unknown

Tokyo!! (1): tedxtr
Notes: 1 villager

Aao (1): Eric
Notes: 1 unknown

Not voting (8): A misread issue, aaronk56, carolinacoder, fnord_too, iraisetoomuch, Nicholasp27, shortline99, traz
Notes: 1 wolf, 3 villager, 4 unknowns



Analysis

EADGBE must be locked clear since bsball and bigger were both on him

If we assume that there were no vote shenanigans in the main thread, then the triple voter must be one of the following: Luckbox, fnord_too, Nicholasp27, traz, carolinacoder

At this point in the game only one wolf had died, meaning 8 remain. I have listed 6 of them here, which means we are looking for two more in the unknowns.

The split in the 13er is 7v/4u/2w
The split in the main thread is 8v/9u/4w

Fanmail being very insistent on killing filthy could be relevant

Votes from post 3995 to post 4607
Night in 5:59:40
---

Votes	Lynch	Voters
9	bsball8806	Sun Tzu (26), Montecore (57), filthyvermin (16), Eric (4), LKJ (9), carolinacoder (32), Nicholasp27 (5), Treep (2), crackedquads (15)
4	traz	shortline99 (8), EADGBE (13), HerbieGRD (141), SGT RJ (43)
1	Eric	Luckbox Inc (49)
1	filthyvermin	Zurvan (29)
1	unvote	fanmail (30)
4	not voting	aao (0), bsball8806 (7), fnord_too (0), traz (0)
1	Error	Birdman10687 (92)

yeah i mean tokyo was also sitting on CQ and could easily have moved

i feel like master was just being a cowboy

*EAD is lock clear of being a wolf, birdman, but yes, I agree

That list of possible triple voters seems right

how is herbie mechanically clear?

if we assume, and I am totally making a wild ass assumption based on the idea that bigger jumped into the 13er the help bsball but no other wolves were in the 13er, then the remaining wolves are going to be found in here

aao
Carolinacoder
Filthyvermin
Crackedquads
Eric
Treep
Traz
Fnord_too
Nicholasp27

and the triple voter would have to be one of these four people

Nicholasp27
traz
fnord_too
carolinacoder

i'll let herbie field this one if he wants to since i got in trouble for discussing it

No, you got in trouble for asking me to discuss it, which you just did again lol

You can answer this one

This is kind of dumb to say, but if we land on the theory that master just pulled the trigger without coordinating, then you should take me off the clear list. I am only clear on the assumption that I'm not dumb enough to screw up the wolf plan; if master wasn't working with the team and just yolo'd it, then he could have missed my vote change easily enough whether I were a wolf or a villager.

First rule of Herbie being clear is don't talk about it.

we can just figure it out today by having the wagons be 1 vote apart at EOD

if you're saying he's clear for claiming a peek on shortline, your logic is flawed

he peeked shortline villager

he could in theory do that as a wolf but it seems like a poor play if so

what's the logic for him being a wolf there?

how many wolves are left? 3?

Correct - Torturer, Alchemist, Triple Voter

I'm not saying I think herbie's a wolf or anything but I don't see why it would necessarily be a poor play.