OK I'm actually trying to quote Herbie's most villagery posts here. This is really the crux of my case, that these are the MOST villagery posts that Herbie made and he's a really villagery villager.
Quote:
Originally Posted by HerbieGRD
I was confused about the Duck village lean as well
I should probably be more skeptical of him giving me a village lean, but it's that whole I trust people who trust me thing
Quote:
Originally Posted by HerbieGRD
That's actually a pretty wolfy post from Duck now that I think about it
Didn't love the Duck stuff in conjunction with his "don't wanna lynch Duck" later. It's the thing he does as a wolf where he lets the village fail and tries to keep his hands clean of mislynches and then bitches that he didn't get his way.
Quote:
Originally Posted by HerbieGRD
Mr Gatito
Quote:
Originally Posted by HerbieGRD
Hated his opener, and hated that he didn't post anything more than that, fits in line with how I think he'd play once he finally gets randed wolf
Obviously early, subject to change, etc etc
Important question - do you actually think anything you've said or done so far is clearing for you in any way?
This is his only wolf case from yesterday and it's a joke.
Quote:
Originally Posted by HerbieGRD
Meh, you haven't done anything yet that you can't do as a wolf I don't think
It doesn't matter though, I'm confident that I'll be able to figure out your role at some point. Your willingness to interact with me is a point in your favor, but only a small one because I think you know you'd have to as a wolf
I get a small village point for interacting when this really has nothing do with reading me because I'm an interactive wolf and Herbie knows it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by YouKnowWho
Silman shows up and in about 8 minutes proves to be a wolf. Must be some kind of a record?
Quote:
Originally Posted by HerbieGRD
I think this is villagery even though I don't agree with it at all, perhaps because I don't agree with it at all
Quote:
Originally Posted by HerbieGRD
Silman,
It's not so much that his read is different, it's the way he phrased it and the fact that I can't understand how anyone could possibly think that. Which means it's likely that he's a villager and really does think that.
This logic is kinda weird to me and it's actually one of Herbie's most villagery posts yesterday
Quote:
Originally Posted by HerbieGRD
FWIW I have trouble buying the idea that Dean thinks he can read me after 3 hours of day 1
Overconfidence is my village tell so I don't know why he would believe this.
Quote:
Originally Posted by HerbieGRD
Dean is not a villager imo
My end of day wasn't good but it was villagery
Quote:
Originally Posted by HerbieGRD
Dean,
Your entirely bizarre "I don't really love lynching Duckburg but FFS nobody vote anybody else because I say so" was so bad it's what inspired my post at the end of yesterday. I was completely convinced as it was happening that Duck was a villager, and was prepared to eat serious crow today if he was a wolf, but he wasn't obv. You also spent half the day talking about me in ways that I don't think you believe, and I don't think you would believe I'm a wolf here, but I'll admit that I could be biased here, and it's possible that your (to my mind) strange and baseless suspicion of me from yesterday is clouding my read wrt your role.
His description has nothing to do with how I act as a wolf
Quote:
Originally Posted by HerbieGRD
So my guess at the wolf team is
Gatito
Sun Tzu
One of XXS/Dean
One of Zomg/MilkReggae
UTR
UTR
Somebody pushing him
UTR
There's nothing connecting anybody. He's not trying to figure stuff out. He's making a reasonable looking list of people that nobody wants to clear and everyone says "eh, makes sense."
So I just don't see the villager inside Herbie. That is all.