You are a lock villager my man. I have zero qualms about saying that.

i'm just gonna say it.

one of the wolves is doing a pretty good job of acting villagery.

herbie your current method of reading me is disingenuous.

quote the posts that i don't make as a villager

Dear Dean

This one.

Love,
Silman

i just made that post as a villager, silman.

and you don't have the dean reading meta that herbie does. he's full of ****.

btw this dean/herbie fight is incredibly pro-village imo.

(I'm pretty sure I'll be confident of both of their roles by eod.)

also when sixfour gets here I want to know what this is about.

Dean,
Your entirely bizarre "I don't really love lynching Duckburg but FFS nobody vote anybody else because I say so" was so bad it's what inspired my post at the end of yesterday. I was completely convinced as it was happening that Duck was a villager, and was prepared to eat serious crow today if he was a wolf, but he wasn't obv. You also spent half the day talking about me in ways that I don't think you believe, and I don't think you would believe I'm a wolf here, but I'll admit that I could be biased here, and it's possible that your (to my mind) strange and baseless suspicion of me from yesterday is clouding my read wrt your role.

neutral

neutral, perhaps slightly wolfy because of the whole "what can I do for the village" mentality rather than a "let's find wolves" mentality, but pretty thin.

not amazing but not wolfy

Fairly villagery

kinda concerning that he says >rand to be wolf considering that was my last read of mets and at some point I used those words?

I think this is fairly villagery, duck was the main other wagon at the time iirc?

self preservation, neutral.

overall seems just slightly >rand villa to me. Anyone else want to offer thoughts?

I said I was OK with telc or duck. Didn't want to lynch Gat because there wasn't a real case and you were on him. Didn't want to lynch donkdonk because he seemed to be getting pressured for things that get him mislynched as a villager. Perdition was ok-ish, but he seemed to be doing his thing where he doesn't give a **** because he's a villager.

So yes, I'm going to push a meh wagon ahead of a wagon that I hate.

What convinced you duck is villa anyway? You said he was wolfy and then flipped for no reason.

p.s. sun tzu better do some serious work today.

This. Is. So. Bad.

Nothing tilts me more than people who don't try to lynch me, call me a wolf, and then proceed to not just ignore my reads but actively work against them because of it.

So really if you're going to do this then I want to lynch you and I don't care if you're a villager or not because you're acting as a de facto wolf by doing this

But here's the thing, I really don't feel like trying to lynch you today, because it wouldn't likely do any good, and I still think there are other people I want to lynch more than you.

Of course I say all this, and part of what convinced me that Duck was a villager was the completely nonsensical way you were pushing him, so I guess I did it too to some extent. the difference is that now I learn that I was correct to do it.

Who do you want to lynch more than me?

FWIW I'm not totally in "would never vote with Herbie" mode nor would I ever be. If I thought you were kinda wolfy but put together a case on somebody who was straight howling I would gladly vote with you. But your case on Gat was a non-case, and I likely wouldn't sponge even if you were a villager. I think Gat is a clearable player so I'm not lynching him d1 for an entry post that hints pretty much nothing at his role.

OK here's the hard question for everybody- who are the wolves among the people with 10+ posts?

I just typed out a really long post and I'm trying to decide whether I actually believe it or not before I post it, because I'm not sure that I do

probably mets

possibly you

I think that's it actually

Oh yeah I also tend to clear sooted too light

I don't think he's a wolf but he def still could be

I just looked at the actual list

Perdition apparently has > 10 posts too, so he could be a wolf, idk

imo me, Nutjob, Silman, donkdonk, sixfour, chrja all village

There were some things mets did yesterday that I didn't like. His perdi fakepeek, his early village lean to you, the fact that he's not lolobv villa yet.

But I still think he's more villagery than not, and his role should become obvious as the day progresses.

I really hope Silman's not a wolf because it would be too much effort to re-read him.

Also hope nutjob's not a wolf because his tone is villagery but I have erroneously cleared him on tone as a wolf in a turbo.

If you're villa I'm a tish worried about s00ted. I'm actually a bit alarmed that you're not worried about him because he didn't make any posts that were particularly difficult to make as a wolf yesterday.

Chrja might be a wolf. i can't say i read him all that well, but he never clears duck when they are v/v and i don't see anything else about his posts from yesterday that scream villa.

Perdition's dicking around is somewhat villagery I guess, not clearing him though.

Actually looking at that post count list is enlightening in a number of ways

Makes me think sooted is more likely to be a wolf than I thought previously

lol xpost about sooted

I don't get what was so villagery about chrja.

Summary of d1:
-donk is villagery for asking me about his role
-duck is villagery for saying he peeked a wolf
-telc is wolfy for being afk

After rereading a little I think I've changed my mind about Mets. He was more villagery yesterday than I thought he was

I don't know if he's been objectively villagery or w/e, I just think this seems different from his wolf games that I've seen recently. I suppose I could actually look to see whether that's true or not, but that sounds like a lot of effort at 1:15 in the morning