4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread
05-07-2013
, 12:24 PM
05-07-2013
, 12:58 PM
Sometimes I feel like I can either not post, or post and have my posts ridiculed. I've received some constructive critisism and I'm trying to take it in but it's hard to in the middle of a game. Also, some things are just my nature and so are hard (but possible) to change. That said, ridicule if you must.
After Sun was lynched and before Mets was nked I reread the thread from post 1 to ~post 900. (at which point I lost steam and stopped). Here are some things that I noticed:
This seems quite villagery. I was feeling (and quoted below) the exact same way about WN, and I'm [also] a noob villa. Here's a similar post by me:
I find it pretty strange that Hoya actually liked something I wrote very early in the game. Also, currently Hoya is saying that my EOD1 is my only villagery trait. Clearly he's thought I had more villagery traits than just that:
Legend, Sun, and Hoya agreeing on a UAW read here kinda stood out to me as bad for UAW:
Vix has had me as a wolf all game. Here's his first negative post about me:
Here he's against me for sponging a read on VR. As a noob I trust all of your reads much more than my own, and so I am likely to sponge sometimes.
A very villagery Bhuber post:
This list seems quite accurate, maybe part of the reason J.D. was nked:
I wonder if this list is too accurate:
VR had me as a wolf until today. As she said she was just rereading from the start of the thread today, I'm not sure why she changed her opinion of me. Here's an early VR post saying I seem wolfy:
Not lookin too great Hoya, this actually looks villagery though. It also makes me think UAW may be a wolf:
Pretty much everyone has said that Pitch is a good bus candidate, except Mets:
Warning: this paragraph may offend, feel free to skip: I wonder if Mets was on to something. Maybe Pitch is a great bus candidate for a strong wolf team, but Mets thought that the wolf team was weak or wouldn't want to bus him. Also, it struck me when Mets said if we lynch Sun we'll lose. I wonder if we're heading in the wrong direction and we need to take more stock of Mets' reads. He was right about Sun. Also, FYI I actually expected the Mets nk. Not so sure what that means though.
Bussing a typical bus candidate would make you lock clear, Hoya? And lol at you not voting him in the end and still claiming lock clear.
That ends my reread. I focused on Bhuber a bit because yesterday I had him as maybe a wolf, but rereading him made me think he's more likely villa. I do think he looks worse on later days though (ie saying he'd WIM then not, etc). Regardless, I find him v now.
Hoya may well be a villa. I really want to vote him at least for today, for Sun's sake and for my own reads. If it seems important (ie close wagons, or maybe if Hoya isn't a wagon at eod) I may change my vote :/.
Brief feelings from yesterday:
Legend keeping up the good work yesterday.
WN doing ok.
UAW missing.
VR doing ~ok.
Charry not so good.
Bhuber ok.
Vix I'm pretty suspicious of.
I'm sure some people won't like these brief lists, but perhaps others will find it useful to see how I'm viewing them.
After Sun was lynched and before Mets was nked I reread the thread from post 1 to ~post 900. (at which point I lost steam and stopped). Here are some things that I noticed:
Quote:
well named my top wolf read aorn. A lot of fluff from him, and he doesn't seem to be helping the village much. Like, the Sun read is ok, but isn't it just a wolf making an easy read? Also, I don't like all the mind games he's playing. First he says he's a wolf, then seer, now he's going with "it's easier if you just take my word for it though." I mean, he's just making himself seem very muddy, which isn't helping the village imo. Maybe this is just his typical game though?
Here he's against me for sponging a read on VR. As a noob I trust all of your reads much more than my own, and so I am likely to sponge sometimes.
A very villagery Bhuber post:
Quote:
You may have to click on the blue tab to see what posts he was quoting (legends post is #188) but I would like to expand on this point a little bit.
I find it kind of weird that it appears that I was UAWs first wolf lean, but then he switches his vote (seemingly randomly as legend has pointed out) to vixt whom I was voting for at the time.
Seems kind of random that you would vote for the person that your wolf lean is voting for (its not like vix was even in the thread at the time and they were joking back and forth).
Then vixt comes in later and says that UAW is his top villa lean? Wuttt?
Plausible scenarios in my mind:
[ ] UAW/vixt is w/w
[x] UAW/vixt is w/v and UAW wasnt paying much attention to what he was saying/posting at the time
[x] UAW/vixt/legend is w/v/w and legend was jumping on something that UAW did that was wolfy to earn some sweet villager points if UAW flips wolf later
[x] There all v/v/v and Im dumb and overthinking things
[x] any number of possibilities that I am not addressing
But yeah,
TLDR; =
I think legend makes a good point here (perhaps someone with meta could clarify if it within is wolf range to beat on other wolves early on to gain cred).
I find it kind of weird that it appears that I was UAWs first wolf lean, but then he switches his vote (seemingly randomly as legend has pointed out) to vixt whom I was voting for at the time.
Seems kind of random that you would vote for the person that your wolf lean is voting for (its not like vix was even in the thread at the time and they were joking back and forth).
Then vixt comes in later and says that UAW is his top villa lean? Wuttt?
Plausible scenarios in my mind:
[ ] UAW/vixt is w/w
[x] UAW/vixt is w/v and UAW wasnt paying much attention to what he was saying/posting at the time
[x] UAW/vixt/legend is w/v/w and legend was jumping on something that UAW did that was wolfy to earn some sweet villager points if UAW flips wolf later
[x] There all v/v/v and Im dumb and overthinking things
[x] any number of possibilities that I am not addressing
But yeah,
TLDR; =
I think legend makes a good point here (perhaps someone with meta could clarify if it within is wolf range to beat on other wolves early on to gain cred).
I wonder if this list is too accurate:
Quote:
People that have called me a villager (ranked alphabetically):
bhuber
legend
mets
remedys
wellnamed
People that have retracted for a crappy reason since I said that it seemed I was getting cleared too lightly (
mets):
bhuber
remedys
So far I still like my vote. I'm going to reread from the beginning now, unless anyone has anything they'd particularly like me to answer right away. I'll keep refreshing in this window.
bhuber
legend
mets
remedys
wellnamed
People that have retracted for a crappy reason since I said that it seemed I was getting cleared too lightly (
mets):bhuber
remedys
So far I still like my vote. I'm going to reread from the beginning now, unless anyone has anything they'd particularly like me to answer right away. I'll keep refreshing in this window.
Warning: this paragraph may offend, feel free to skip: I wonder if Mets was on to something. Maybe Pitch is a great bus candidate for a strong wolf team, but Mets thought that the wolf team was weak or wouldn't want to bus him. Also, it struck me when Mets said if we lynch Sun we'll lose. I wonder if we're heading in the wrong direction and we need to take more stock of Mets' reads. He was right about Sun. Also, FYI I actually expected the Mets nk. Not so sure what that means though.
Bussing a typical bus candidate would make you lock clear, Hoya? And lol at you not voting him in the end and still claiming lock clear.
Hoya may well be a villa. I really want to vote him at least for today, for Sun's sake and for my own reads. If it seems important (ie close wagons, or maybe if Hoya isn't a wagon at eod) I may change my vote :/.
Brief feelings from yesterday:
Legend keeping up the good work yesterday.
WN doing ok.
UAW missing.
VR doing ~ok.
Charry not so good.
Bhuber ok.
Vix I'm pretty suspicious of.
I'm sure some people won't like these brief lists, but perhaps others will find it useful to see how I'm viewing them.
05-07-2013
, 12:59 PM
05-07-2013
, 01:04 PM
05-07-2013
, 02:44 PM
05-07-2013
, 03:36 PM
It started so early and just continues.
Early day 1, red my exact sentiments.
. i'm gonna take a break but i'll answer your questions later (@legend and vr)
05-07-2013
, 03:54 PM
05-07-2013
, 03:56 PM
05-07-2013
, 03:58 PM
05-07-2013
, 04:02 PM