Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread 4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread

05-09-2013 , 09:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by well named
was not framing legend, i thought hoya was seer

can't chat now, but I'll asplain later
Forgot I even thought of this last night.

Quote:
Originally Posted by legend42
Btw I've been thinking wn would be too smart to not kill me, he actually might be too (currently) dumb to kill me. <snip>

I've been assuming it's wolves who are level 0/1 hunting, it could be wn leading the kill saying "legend would NEVER fps as seer". And wn *might* think Hoya could FPS as seer last night.
One correct post in an ocean of wrong reads.
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 09:43 PM
I don't know how to fix this emerging flaw in my villaging, where I have a hard time believing someone blatantly going afk all the time and posting "wolfy" as hell is a sign that they're actually a wolf because no one who wanted to win would resort to that.

I mean, just policy lynch all the damn time and rand gonna rand?
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 09:45 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bhuber2010
I woulda voted your ass if I was on for EOD that night charry

I knew you was woofun (you did have some awkward posts that I think I called you out for even before the whole "tarp" level)!
you'd probably call me out on some posts regardless of what my role is

u did have a pretty good game tho

that tarp post was amazing.. I was grinning the entire time typing it and reading the responses.. it was hilarious.
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 09:46 PM
Just do what I do

Push everyone
Vote for the worst responses
Profit?
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 09:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by legend42
Forgot I even thought of this last night.



One correct post in an ocean of wrong reads.
there was actually quite a few posts this game that were bang on accurate.. but it'd be like finding a needle in a haystack..

fack it.. I'll try and find the beauts
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 09:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Charry
you'd probably call me out on some posts regardless of what my role is

u did have a pretty good game tho

that tarp post was amazing.. I was grinning the entire time typing it and reading the responses.. it was hilarious.
I could easily either clear u with meta or call u wolfy whenever I wanted lol.. even after I tried clearing u for so long.
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 09:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Charry
there was actually quite a few posts this game that were bang on accurate.. but it'd be like finding a needle in a haystack..

fack it.. I'll try and find the beauts
You don't need to bother. White knighting remedys on d1 and beyond, tone-clearing VR late, and choosing wn over bhuber are the only things I'm really proud of. I got super lucky to dodge the NKs as seer, and my peeks weren't optimal. I guess I knew mets was a villager too, but meh.
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 09:54 PM
No peeking me was great, everyone 's lynching me
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 09:58 PM
I peeked you vix because I did read mets as villa and sometimes his soulreads are good. I would have called like 100 of your posts wolfy if I didn't know. Your meta is near impeccable.
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 10:08 PM
I thought vix's tone was perfect all game. The only time I really even began to suspect him was when Hoya was flipped villa and realized that the only people that had anything to gain from it were Legend and Vix.

(except that WN actually thought hoya was the seer)
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 10:08 PM
Then legend outted as seer and that theory was all shot to hell
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 10:11 PM
Oh, thanks for modding Noah!
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 10:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by remedys
Oh, thanks for modding Noah!
+1

Def one advantage of playing on 2+2, mods are spot on

Thanks noah!
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 10:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by legend42
I peeked you vix because I did read mets as villa and sometimes his soulreads are good. I would have called like 100 of your posts wolfy if I didn't know. Your meta is near impeccable.
Mets always thinks I'm a wolf
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 10:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CPHoya
I don't know how to fix this emerging flaw in my villaging, where I have a hard time believing someone blatantly going afk all the time and posting "wolfy" as hell is a sign that they're actually a wolf because no one who wanted to win would resort to that.

I mean, just policy lynch all the damn time and rand gonna rand?
I don't think I get this, Hoya. It seems either hypocritical or nonsensical. Explain please.
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 10:33 PM
VR was really villagery the last game day

and vix owned

gj vix
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 10:33 PM
legend, let me explain my read of you and why I couldn't give you a good answer on that
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 10:34 PM
Nice posting bhuber
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 10:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sun Tzu
let's see

when I peek a wolf n0, I sure as **** don't talk about it on d1

if I feel reasonably confident I can live a few days, I might not even push them

if I decide to push them, I'm going to do it for the wolfy things they do and make sure to cite my reasons
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sun Tzu
the question is whether the play makes sense as a villager?

I don't think so

not unless he's trying to emulate anarchist's game back when anarchist sucked
so my first response to this "I peeked you wolf" thing is to think it's strange

I get peeked wolf d1 of every game but not by people like legend

so I'm thinking "this doesn't seem like something village legend would do"

Quote:
Originally Posted by well named
the question of whether or not the play makes sense is quite distinct from the question of whether or not it's something legend is going to do as a wolf

also sun tzu is now a lock villager
then WN immediately posts this and I totally agree with it

so it doesn't make sense for legend to do that as a villager

and it doesn't really make sense for him to do that as a wolf

so something clicks in my mind and I remember a play I used to make sometimes in turbos which is to claim seer d2 with a wolf peek if a wolf was lynched d1

the idea behind this was of course to lynch someone who might be a wolf and get another peek if I'm wrong

this worked the first time or 2 but then someone just went ahead and night-killed me and I realized I can't really make that play as seer if I don't do it as a villager

so I had to choose between doing that as a villager or giving up doing it as seer

so anyway, I'm probably the first person who's ever been fake-peeked wolf as a villager and read that person as seer
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 10:42 PM
Thanks for the game Noah, fun theme

I'm assuming Spencer Reid was the seer?
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 10:52 PM
Sun, I considered that you read me as seer. Especially when you posted "I was half-hoping you were NKed to teach you a lesson" or similar. But I also thought you could have made that post as wolf. The way I kept wavering on you was honest, but when you became a d2 wagon I thought it was best to keep pushing on you. If you flip wolf, we have 2 in 2 days and village is in great shape even if I'm NKed (plus vix=v, so essentially 3 peeks in 2 days). If you flip villa, I look like I'm never the seer.
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 10:54 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sun Tzu
I have a bold and unlikely prediction that I don't want to make for reasons I can't explain right now but I think those abbreviation codes are stupid and can be faked anyway so I'm just making this post instead so tomorrow I can quote it and say "I told you so"
this was my d1 post talking about it without talking about it

I was kind of hoping legend would get night-killed and flip seer just so I could quote this the next day and talk about my sick read before getting mislynched and flipping villager as a "peeked wolf"

that would have been the best game ever no matter how it ended but WN sucks at seer-hunting
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 10:56 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by legend42
Sun, I considered that you read me as seer. Especially when you posted "I was half-hoping you were NKed to teach you a lesson" or similar. But I also thought you could have made that post as wolf. The way I kept wavering on you was honest, but when you became a d2 wagon I thought it was best to keep pushing on you. If you flip wolf, we have 2 in 2 days and village is in great shape even if I'm NKed (plus vix=v, so essentially 3 peeks in 2 days). If you flip villa, I look like I'm never the seer.
I don't even mind

the thing I think you shouldn't have done though was harp on me about my read of you

nothing good can come of that

it's like you were indirectly seerhunting yourself by trying to force me to say I thought you might be the seer
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 11:01 PM
The reason I harped on that a bit is that I thought you could be a wolf who read me as seer who didn't peek you. So you were waiting for me to retract. Which is one reason why I didn't.

Honestly, I wish I hadn't missed this post from you near eod2:

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sun Tzu
so you can get me mislynched

does that fill you with pride?
It was botp, and only saw it on re-read, but it's exactly the kind of post I might have cleared you for. So my bad on that. But we win anyway!
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote
05-09-2013 , 11:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Charry
Thanks for the game Noah, fun theme

I'm assuming Spencer Reid was the seer?
Garcia was the seer

I had a list of roles and randed them to people at reveal time, just had Garcia fixed for the seer, although yeah, Reid would have been good for that
4/30 Criminal Minds Vanilla WW Slow Game Thread Quote

      
m