role neutral tho lol

gambit you are one of the most hardheaded people i've ever seen in a ww game

you seriously still think it was wolfy for him to agree with a reads post with blank names listed? like, what should he have done if he agreed with the people with reads listed next to them? should he have said "i agree with the people that have reads noted but not the blank names"?

meh, i could see the reasoning for it. i obv didn't agree tho

he was probably generically wolfy, but nothing like his first game, which most people here didn't know about

I'll consider it

and to answer your question zdye, more

Probably true, and I basically needed filler for a wolf-team of five.

You could still be wolfing of course, but I'm leaning against it aorn

Very well then.

Another question: would you say you were posting enthusiastically yesterday, particularly in the afternoon?

Maybe I am hardheaded but when something pings me, I tend to stick with my read until I am convinced that I was wrong. And to answer your question, yes I still think that whole situation was wolfy. Sorry if that bothers you, but that is my opinion.

Sometime around mid-afternoon I forgot why I was voting for him.

honestly though other than some weird phrasing/the jmakin post zdye you have been pretty good

and this is why gambit is a wolf - he keeps making the same weak push to different people, even though I've responded in full and others have acknowledged that his case is empty

he doesn't care about reevaluating, he just wants to push me

the inclusion of this statement looks like zdye is trying to cover his tracks

wat

i would never describe my posting as enthusiastic, unless maybe i know i've caught a wolf or something

What about the situation exactly?

That's one way to look at it. Another would be that I'm keeping an open mind towards jonny (and everyone in the game), which should be fairly obvious at this point.

1. I am not pushing anything. Everytime I have talked about you today was in response to someone asking me.

2. I am not a wolf.

zdye whos your wolf team now

I didn't think so either. I was trying to wrap my head around this read from vader but instead of asking him I figured asking you would be better.

-They way you just said "I agree with this post"

-The odds of every read in that post being exactly your reads too

-having no reads on exactly all the other players left blank

-The way you responded to me when I questioned you about it

it should be fairly obvious at every point. so much so that saying it should be superfluous.

Is there anyone you're not keeping an "open mind" towards?

hmmm

well i still think he has been villagery

ianaww
never - really villagery this morning imo
kruze

charry
vader
zdye - much better poasting today

kinda AIDS that i don't have any really strong wolf reads, just a huge group of blah

I think it depends greatly on whether or not mac is a wolf. I've been thinking of him as a villager pretty much the whole game now, so a lot of my thoughts are wrapped around that premise.

I'm very confident vader is a wolf. If that's the case, I think one of IANAWW and fnord is a wolf as well, given the way the three of them hopped around together last night. I'd be shocked if all three are wolves, though, and IANAWW's posting has gotten weaker today+fnord has popped up as a semi-consensus wolf.

Beyond those three, there might be a wolf in the low-posters, happy and smiglet. Happy not posting at all actually has me more worried than I was yesterday that he's actually villaging. I've seen SMIGLET go very low content as a villager twice now, his post voting chris last night was bad from a results-oriented standpoint but encouraging that he's contributing content. But then it becomes a game of levels.

In summation: I don't feel confident in my wolf reads beyond vader, but knowing his and mac's affiliation will clear a lot up imo

and zdye, did you have a limit on what you could post last night?... because i was ready to come into the thread and call you a wolf since it was very uninspiring