Here's where I am at after the reskim, little bit more filled out.
Bowens
Charry
Christophersen - 310 puke. OK, I really don't like
Fnord_too
gambit8888 - 28 seems...weird. Like the whole dialog was making idle chat for idle chat's sake. Meh, last video game played was Tekken 3, that makes it a bit less weird. Goes on this mad cross examination thing. This is kind of a mixed bag: on the one hand, it is pro villa to post hard and force responses; on the other, it seemed arbitrary and over the top and ended with gambit kind of backing off. Overall +w.
Happy_Fish - activish, but leaving no impression. +w
iamnotawerewolf - lean villa through 217: active, content posts that make sense.
Insanity
Jmakinmecrzy
jonnyd
Kruze - I don't think I have seen him wolf, but this looks a lot like his village game (and I don't think it is something that is easy to replicate)
McAvoy -
NeVeR - "fair enough", followed by flaunting the saying (latter worse imo)
Officedog
SMIGLET
TehVader - HAMing it up early
TheNothing - Villa demeanor
Vaya - comes in with a list of reads. seems kind of legit, +v.
vixticator
Zdye724 - opening seems bleh. I think 3 posts through 143 and all of them seemed like canned nothing. Couple more nothing / narrative posts. Just continues with posts that don't really say anything thgouth 214. Through 418 - are we reading the same game? 501 - first thing I agree with. 502 - nice soft push of jmakin