Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! 4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread!

04-28-2013 , 05:33 AM
derm

what do you think of soah?
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 05:34 AM
Who cares who I would peek, I just remembered who I would kill. Lets not let UFO live
Regardless of role, he will bore us to death regardless of role.
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 05:35 AM
ITT I can't defend myself or post anything meaningful without being called boring or having a bunch of people openly stating they won't read me.

nice way to keep me out of POG.
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 05:40 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by hardcoreUFO
derm

what do you think of soah?
no idea, i barely have any history with soah and i dont expect that i can read him on d1.
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 05:46 AM
hardcore has constructed a wonderful artificial dynamic in which it is wolfy of me to not have a strong enough case to justify going after him, but also wolfy of me each time I add to it. (like, if I didn't know any better it would almost look as if I commented on some posts that drew my attention and then continued to do research on it to determine my stance, or something)

I wonder how it would look if we applied that type of logic to all of his posts about RoundGuy

(see what I did there?)
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 05:48 AM
As a non sequitur,

McAvoy
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 05:50 AM
roundguy hasn't even defended himself from what I pointed out so far fwiw. your arguments are so bad you have to rearrange what I respond to you to make them slightly justifiable, or just ignore and move to something equally irrelevant and hope I take longer than 2 hours to respond.
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 05:52 AM
what did I rearrange?
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 05:53 AM
Good morning thread.

Anything interesting happen yet?
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 05:54 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by McAvoy
Who cares who I would peek, I just remembered who I would kill. Lets not let UFO live
Regardless of role, he will bore us to death regardless of role.
I don't think villa mac writes that btw.

soah: you just tried rearranging what I responded to you in this very page for people not interested in reading a handful of small paragraphs that you're calling an 'essay' so that you both avoid responding in any way to what I pointed out are big flaws in your agument, and to make sure you have some weak form of last word and make it look like you have some kind of case on me (you clearly don't and should've dropped this ages ago).
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 05:55 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bremen
Good morning thread.

Anything interesting happen yet?
hardcore seems really mad that I've caught him for the wrong reasons
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 05:57 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by hardcoreUFO
I don't think villa mac writes that btw.

soah: you just tried rearranging what I responded to you in this very page for people not interested in reading a handful of small paragraphs that you're calling an 'essay' so that you both avoid responding in any way to what I pointed out are big flaws in your agument, and to make sure you have some weak form of last word and make it look like you have some kind of case on me (you clearly don't and should've dropped this ages ago).
Nothing in this post is an answer to my question.
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 05:57 AM
lol another terrible argument
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 06:00 AM
Votes from post 1 to post 488
Night in 16:00:58

---
VotesLynchVoters
4 McAvoy soah (43), Sun Tzu (28), Anarchist (13), well named (33)
2 derm LeonardoDicaprio (114), McAvoy (13)
1 soah hardcoreUFO (73)
1 hardcoreUFO RoundGuy (25)
1 well named bhuber2010 (25)
1 bhuber2010 LKJ (69)
1 unvote derm (43)
2 not voting Bremen (1), outdrawed (0)
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 06:00 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by soah
hardcore seems really mad that I've caught him for the wrong reasons
Interesting that you are so sure the wrong reasons give the right answer. Seems tunnely.
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 06:01 AM
that's not tunnel vision.

he is setting me up here.
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 06:03 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bremen
Interesting that you are so sure the wrong reasons give the right answer. Seems tunnely.
doublefacepalm.jpeg
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 06:05 AM
mac/soah/xxxx sounds good for a wolfteam.
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 06:05 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by hardcoreUFO
that's not tunnel vision.

he is setting me up here.
How do you know he is a wolf and not a misguided villager?

I expect new players to respond to getting pushed by saying omg he must be a wolf... you're not new.

ie so far

soah - villa

hardcoreUFO - wolfy
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 06:07 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bremen
How do you know he is a wolf and not a misguided villager?

I expect new players to respond to getting pushed by saying omg he must be a wolf... you're not new.

ie so far

soah - villa

hardcoreUFO - wolfy
you have to read everything in my back and forth with soah to get a picture of why I'm feeling so strong about this. I assume you didn't so far. nothing in my argument even remotely assumes that soah is a wolf simply for pushing me. it's the way he is doing it and the forced arguments he is using.
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 06:14 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by soah
Why is this only analyzing the scenario in which bhuber is a wolf?

Also, what does our history have to do with anything related to my posts? Almost all of my posts were before you even showed up.
Quote:
Originally Posted by soah
Seems like circular reasoning going on here? Quote a guy calling me a villager and say it's wolfy because he doesn't seem suspicious of me?

I see an accusation of using wrong reasoning, but with a wolf accusation attached to it which doesn't work.
Quote:
Originally Posted by soah
sounds like your posts about me
Quote:
Originally Posted by hardcoreUFO
I'm really suspicious of superficially-sounding logic that doesn't hold any true at all to a careful observer. saying my post about bhuber sounds like circular reasoning only makes sense if you don't know what circular reasoning means. then not following that up but rather completely changing the argument to push me for giving too much weight to thin stuff when I blatantly didn't do that looks a whole lot like a wolf setting up a scenario where a villager gets mislynched. your push is nonsensical and weak. it's also lacking a follow up as it was before with bhuber (which is why I said your push is only good if bhuber is a wolf). I don't like any of this and you sound pretty wolfy to me.

soah
yes, your reaction was not at all completely bizarre and out of proportion to my questions about your posts
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 06:27 AM
oh why are you not quoting all my answers previously to that post? :|

my reaction was simply an evaluation of your role based on what you wrote to me. your objections were dull and fully answered to, I have no reason to be 'mad' at those :P
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 06:33 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LeonardoDicaprio
whatcha think about well named on this page?
I really like this post.

It crossed my mind while reading that well named was just fluffing, non-peeks soah being on a caffeine high etc

Quote:
Originally Posted by well named
I have to read all of the hardcore posts again sometime when I have a longer attention span and see what the hell soah is on about. Until then I don't really have an opinion on either of them
or not giving reads


Quote:
Originally Posted by well named
Maybe I haven't read closely enough, but I would say the odds that bhuber is a wolf here are like 1%, maybe?

Quote:
Originally Posted by well named
first wolf lean: mcavoy
or giving reads with no justification at all

add well named to the wolfy list

leo gets a villager lean too
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 06:33 AM
soah is thinking of another angle to push me for now.

I suggest going after the fact that I said you/mac/xxx make a good wolf team after saying on p2 you were less likely to push wolfbr0s on d1.

it works better as a case than anything you said so far at least
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote
04-28-2013 , 06:35 AM
bremen, I would just like to point out WN can get really un-explainy as a villager. he doesn't really avoid that kind of stuff as a wolf. in fact I believe he would at least make an attempt of explaining his read on mac as a wolf everytime here.
4/27 Vanilla 13er Game Thread! Quote

      
m