Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
3v3 Codenames 3v3 Codenames

03-10-2024 , 12:41 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nicholasp27
if cap was assassin then I’d just clue waitress 3 before sun 2 so that there wasn’t a chance we had cap left over as an n-1 word
Haha sure, then you’ll just bold whatever the next word on your waitress list was.

This isn’t about cap, this is about words being regarded as makeup words even when there are no words to be made up.
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-10-2024 , 12:45 PM
Ah; perhaps a good line to take is to make it up if other team wins if we pass but if they only have 2-3 words like this game then just pass if you got all the words

The problem is we spurs a lot; so no line is perfect, which is why I default to the non-agreement deduction-based n-1 guess

But I see the merit in ignoring n-1 if other team is far behind (point of n-1 is you we lose if pass so you guess next word) and the makeup word is likely not ours since we likely got all the obvious ones for prior clue and didn’t spurs anything
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-10-2024 , 12:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nicholasp27
N-1 so cap tho not sure why not sun - 4 last turn then
It’s about this. It’s the assumption that you knew the list better than I did. Rather than acknowledging that I had clued the words I had intended to clue for, an endgame convention we use superseded my clue and made cap an auto-bold.

I’m arguing that is not an optimal play.

But I’m not interested in getting into an n-1 debate. I don’t need to be convinced if it’s merit. I’d just like to know how to keep my team from guessing an extra word when no makeups are needed. Changing the order of clues is convenient on paper, but there have been plenty of times where the discussion goes “yeah, these two are locks, but let’s list another word or two just because we should have a list.” How tf is a spymaster supposed to plan for those often peripheral, sometimes completely random list words?
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-10-2024 , 12:51 PM
Sorry, long-winded x-post
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-10-2024 , 12:52 PM
Yeah there is no perfect answer that works for everything

All I can say is I’ll consider passing here in the future if other team only has 3 and doesn’t have obvious path to catch up in one turn
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-10-2024 , 12:52 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nicholasp27
Ah; perhaps a good line to take is to make it up if other team wins if we pass but if they only have 2-3 words like this game then just pass if you got all the words

The problem is we spurs a lot; so no line is perfect, which is why I default to the non-agreement deduction-based n-1 guess

But I see the merit in ignoring n-1 if other team is far behind (point of n-1 is you we lose if pass so you guess next word) and the makeup word is likely not ours since we likely got all the obvious ones for prior clue and didn’t spurs anything
I like this
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-10-2024 , 01:31 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TBobLP
Not sure why we thought it might be an illegal clue?
I didn't know it was a word in an English dictionary.

Never heard of the instrument. Was worth a shot. Tough board, gg.
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-10-2024 , 01:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by eyebooger
I didn't know it was a word in an English dictionary.

Never heard of the instrument. Was worth a shot. Tough board, gg.

Interestingly merriam-webster.com has cajón listed, but the drum is not one of the definitions. I was good with it.
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-11-2024 , 12:55 PM
Looks like this round is nich/eb
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-13-2024 , 08:06 AM
bump
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-13-2024 , 10:43 PM
Apple
Back
Bell
Bermuda
Boot
Canada
Compound
Contract
Fighter
Film
Genius
Grace
Hood
Ice cream
Log
Maple
Marble
Mug
Queen
Skyscraper
Switch
Torch
Turkey
Van
Web
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-13-2024 , 10:43 PM
if even i'm red
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-13-2024 , 10:43 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nicholasp27
if even i'm red

i'm up
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-13-2024 , 10:48 PM
Toronto - 3
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-13-2024 , 10:51 PM
Lots of potential there

Canada obv

Skyscraper, queen, maple after that, not sure what I like better
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-13-2024 , 10:51 PM
Film, too
Lots of movies made here, and nich would know that
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-14-2024 , 11:00 PM
Bump
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-15-2024 , 06:27 PM
Bump for IBD
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-15-2024 , 06:29 PM
Canada (obv)
Maple (Leafs)
Skyscraper (CN Tower)

Would be mine I think. Queen as backup is fine. I get movie, and yeah Toronto stands in for a lot of other cities in film. But it’s a distant 5th for me.
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-15-2024 , 06:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nicholasp27
Bump for IBD

Sorry, at Expo West this week
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-15-2024 , 06:31 PM
Yeah, I didn't think of the maple leafs connection (somehow? Wtf?), but that is a good tiebreaker over queen I think
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-15-2024 , 06:43 PM
Canada
Maple
Skyscraper
Pass

Queen
Film
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-15-2024 , 07:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IBeDrummin
Sorry, at Expo West this week


No prob

Just realized I hadn’t said your name in first bump and you may not have realized it’s on you
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-15-2024 , 07:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zurvan
Canada
Maple
Skyscraper
Pass

Queen
Film


Red x3
3v3 Codenames Quote
03-15-2024 , 09:42 PM
Toronto - 3

Apple
Back
Bell
Bermuda
Boot
Compound
Contract
Fighter
Film
Genius
Grace
Hood
Ice cream
Log
Marble
Mug
Queen
Switch
Torch
Turkey
Van
Web

Canada
Maple
Skyscraper
3v3 Codenames Quote

      
m