Honestly I am not really following this question either.

I think I might have it broken down for myself but I would still like to hear your explanation behind it as well.

Genie.

Phone posting so quoting is problematic.

Selective highlighting of my quote. Try adding another 12 words in red.

Manipulative. Lean scum on the genie.

I was thinking the "if I'm town" accusation from Genie was pretty weak, but then he admits as much himself. It becomes much more interesting when you see the reaction to it.

Magicziggy

Voted for an overly defensive reaction to a reasonable line of reasoning.

Ziggy,

Just by throwing scum leans on everybody is not helping us to clear you in anyway.

The game object is to hang all mafia and evildoers, it is a lot easier to do while you are clearing villagers.

I highlighted the part which causes conflicts because as a townie whose first language is English I do not think you would set your phrase in "what if I'm" manner.

In general I do not feel any way of you calling me scummy, I feel free to interact with anybody and every townie should have the same mindset.

In case that is the Mafia-Spite what's popping out then keep it up yo' we like when Mafia outs themselves quickly.

Genie.

You've never seen stupid scum before?

Aside from that, I'm generally leaning more town on Arcbell right now. If he is scum, he would have been acting alone I believe, which does happen.

Good evening. I've just come back from an extremely successful evening of bridge while on high strength prescription pain killers. An (awful) Black Eyed Peas song comes to mind Or at least "comfortably numb".

Really? What is it that side of the ditch, 8 pm?

Only calling it the way I see it. I'm guessing most people like to have their words correctly represented. I'm supposed to allow genie to paint three words red as if I I'm suggesting that i might not be town. In fact I'm suggesting that it's a possibility I'm town who would lie about a role. In fact I wouldn't lie about a town role but I've read that it's not uncommon here.

I really don't care what peoples reads on me are.

"throwing scum leans on everybody"

Really?

More misrepresentation to back up your non existent case. Not really looking good for you Sherlock.

I've skimmed games 1 and 2 and seen town lose. Scum as a collective rarely if ever make dumb day 1 moves.

And we know this isn't a double-keyed code with two solutions because...?

It's not that against the spirit of the game; all it does is theoretically restrict people's actions, which theoretically benefits the village who have less need of deception. Not like it forces wolves into revealing, or even gives a lead. It doesn't help much if the wolves aren't planning hard claims though, and it only gives the appearance of surety. It most strongly benefits those who knew it was coming, with the time to bring out "one I prepared earlier".

I'll subscribe to your newsletter if you show how it avoids the possibility of double-keying, mind you. I'm a bigger fan of village co-operation to force the wolves into inaction/poor play, than I am of selfish strategies like "walking the line" and such.

Standing firm.

Peace, Genie.

If you do you get policy lynched. No questions asked.

Thanks for the history lesson. I'll not be using meta analysis though.

-------------

How many of you guys have played together before? If any. . .

Just trying to accommodate different cultures. Where I'm from its lynch all liars. Here I've read the bios. People lie as town. True story.

This is a terrible observation. Arcbell's plan is pretty good in my opinion, as long as people are careful not to make their claim breakable.

The plan is completely independent of Arcbell's alignment. Both factions can easily create this plan. Mafia doesn't have to co-ordinate to come up with a plan, hell if Arcbell is mafia he may not even have told his team about the plan he was going to propose.

Yes, he came up with it by himself. That doesn't say anything about his alignment.

Based on what?

PSA: Explain your reads. Always.

WTF is this poop? I thought this was a "champions" game... I feel like I'm in a game with 30 Jack D's

I am going to say that he's one of those players who thinks his juvenile logic separates him from the field so much, that he is the self-appointed "turn the game into a calamity" guy.

Look at me care about other cultures.

If you lie, you die.

I think its worthwhile establishing that at the outset. As a baseline it's pretty clear cut.

The reason you can't get anyone to do it on your site is more likely becasue herp derp derp

The weather is a talking point. I'm sitting on the toilet getting ready for work, and reading through the first few pages of this. It's absolutely laughable that anyone is making absolute statements or reads at this point.

Does it "appear" that way, or is this just rudimentary narrative?

No it's not. There is nothing to discuss, if anyone is ever found guilty of lying we lynch him, automatically.

Also, you threw out like 2 reads for no good reason earlier. If you don't back up your ideas with reasons, I need to kill you. There is no way for me to determine your alignment from insightful posts like "X is mafia"

This goes to everyone. Whatever meta you're used to from your previous site, drop it right now. Here, no one knows you well enough to understand the motivation behind your suspicions without you explicitly stating them.

The only people whose best interest is in not explaining things are mafia. Just like the idea behind the role codes, if we force everyone to always explain why they have certain reads, it is harder to backtrack, because you have to provide new reasons as to why your old reasons don't apply anymore. This is very easy to do as town as it's natural, but really hard to fabricate as mafia.

Lean scum on mills because s/he? is asking about first language even though she acknowledged my posts in the sign up as being an Aussie. Although that's not an indication of first language I still I found it a little contrived.

Lean scum on genie because self appointed Sherlock is (from my pov) fabricating evidence and manipulating opinion.

There's something about this post that I don't love.

I don't understand the 50-50 odds, there is no information in the OP about the number of each role, so it's entirely possible we have 4 medics and no other power roles. The 50-50 thing is just meh

In addition this is the least committal stance you could possibly have taken on the whole issue.

I agree with SB's post here: http://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/sh...3&postcount=99

Based on what?

Anyway, here's my code/claim:

10361253 p3 b1