Quote:
Originally Posted by iraisetoomuch
You:
association and interaction with the other people that I think are wolves.
The other 3:
I've put them into the thread multiple times already.
ooookay..
nice discourse we're having here..
Well, let me explain my village reads on them then.
Manasi - first off, let me say, she isn't an easy read unless you've played with her at least a couple of times. You can't read her in the traditional 'what are her reads' manner that you can for alot of people (at least, not early in the game) cause she mostly plays to interact and joke around with people that she likes and knows well.
So she comes into day 1, pals around with me (and joke votes adam) and is basically saying 'hi' to everyone, and pretty much ignoring any attempts from people to get her to actually do **** in the game.
That is PURE manasi villa game.
Wolf!manasi feels obligated to her team to make a pretense at having reads, and her tone always feels disengaged/like she's not having fun.
the fact that she didn't even make a reads list till almost EoD day 1 was probably the most villagery thing she's done (that and she omitted me from her villa reads list, which she could have just slid me on there and no one would have questioned it if she was a wolf) cause she didn't feel like she HAD to.
Adam - first off, adam is one of the only other people ITG (the other being Jon Paul) who knows manasi from DM. The fact that adam and I have such similar reads on manasi makes me feel that we are coming from the same villagery place.
I think wolf!adam could easily push manasi this game and get away with it, and that feels pretty villagery.
I've also liked that he's been here and engaged for EoD's, and I like that he bought a yolo gun day 1 (i'm assuming that was real, cause batman could have outed him otherwise) cause thats something that I associate with villa!adam (doing yolo **** cause why not)
also, while I hate where his read on me is coming from (don't really want to talk about it) I think he believes it more here than he has in past games, which is villagery of him.
Gabe - I like how consistant he's being with the mechanical posts (yes I know I shouldn't villa read him for mech posts, but he has no obligation to make a post like he did today as a wolf, specially talking about the stuff like the cathedral) and I agree with virtually all of it.
Also I like that he really seems to care about the game, and seems like he's really enjoying it and feels engaged (which I don't think he would feel that way if he randed wolf in his first game in FOREVER).
So its essentially a tonal read.