Catching up after dinner out.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DocEspana
If everyone's argument is that I'm a busy doctor, it's totally non game related targeting and also not gonna net you a wolf. Since no one has any game related arguments against me (especially after I got more in the groove of stuff later in day 1s cycle ) I'd hope some of th3 suspicion would come off of me.
My argument, which I admit wasn't strong, cause hey, mid-day 1, was that the little content you did have time to post was odd to me. Your first set of reads only listed like 1 townread (Banks), and a whole bunch of varying levels of scumreads on people. The mild scumread on me you backpedaled to neutral when I called you out on it. Having a bunch of scumreads early and 1 townread is so not typical of how I play as town, or most people in my experience. Would you say it's typical for you or others in your experience?
Quote:
Originally Posted by DocEspana
Want me to vote for Achromatic? So do I. But you're gonna have ti make much stronger arguments for either their suspicion or your innocence when you're my wolf suspicion de jour. It's almost true that the same arguments would hold more water from someone else. Almost.
I'm still definitely not sold on Ratchet as mafia, but if he is, this totally reads to me as "Hey, scumbuddy. I want to vote with you, but I can't justify it based on the suspicion you have and the case you made. Make a better case so I can justify the vote."
Quote:
I didn't like how Dorian said Ratchet was in his top 3 mafia and was the only one he didn't do a read of.
Hence, he got on my list.
Again, not fool proof but enough to make me wonder and go "huh?"
Good grief. Riki's already addressed it, but it only came out that way because I'm a slow poster and you kept impatiently complaining that I didn't give you a 3x3. I started my rundown by saying I was starting with the easy reads (which implies I'm saving the tough ones for last), I said which I'd shoot and save as I went along, the answer at the end was the same as the answer in the middle, and the only reason you got the condensed list with Ratchet in it before the post about Ratchet was because you kept complaining you hadn't gotten it for real and I knew I didn't have time to make the Ratchet post before work commitments. Pretend it happened the other way. Like Riki said, this is a weird thing to get hung up on compared to any of the actual content I posted, especially since you profess to have several similar reads to me.
Quote:
So in essence, and again, not fool proof, but Dorian listed Ratchet as top 3 mafia like he wanted us to know that Ratchet was mafia but didn't know how to say why. If you are ACTUALLY thinking Ratchet is top 3 mafia, you have reasons. If he is neutral and you are unsure, he goes in the "not being listed because they are neutral" pile.
I found it....odd.
Did you find the reasons I posted when I finally had time to post them not sufficient? Yeah, Ratchet was close to neutral territory, but if I only have 2 scumreads and you ask for 3 to shoot, I have to pick the worst of the neutrals, and that was a hard call, cause I don't mathematically line all my reads up in a perfect line from most town to least town.
Quote:
Originally Posted by TehBankertin
Oh if ratchet is scum and MSU thinks he is going down today for sure then busing makes a lot of sense. I am not sure I see that connection based on the EoD voting.
Are you saying that if they're both scum, that MSU bussing Ratchet today makes sense, or bussing Ratchet in last night's vote makes sense? Cause I agree with the first, but quite a bit less with the second.
Quote:
Originally Posted by fontisian
As a general note, I think I'm the only woman in this game, so whenever someone uses "her" or "she" to refer to someone else, it's very confusing. Stop that.
...is Riki not a she? If not, I sincerely apologize for calling him "she" all game. I don't know where I got the wrong impression.