Quote:
Originally Posted by Achromatic
This has also probably been pointed out but he went from having dorian super villager to leaving him completely off his list of villagers later in the day.
I feel like several more experienced people have argued that scum are more likely to not forget their previous reads on teammates and thus not likely to suddenly forget to include them in their lists. I actually had this exact same point in my 3 pages of notes as making me look better, but it got cut in the condensing, cause that was more a case about others than a defense of me.
I see now that Riki agreed with me a few posts back.
Quote:
Originally Posted by bhuber2010
I think my tone is probably enough to clear me but thats probably a bit biased Needless to say, correctly lynching mafia yesterday bought us a little more time (in terms of our ability to mislynch twice now). So I'd probably go dorian/bhuber2010/banks in any order (and yes I included myself) and just re-evaluate everyone at lylo if it comes to that.
I kind of agree with this, but the problem with it is that we reach lylo after mislynching 2. So one of us 3 is still alive at lylo. I'm not sure I want it to be me. I'd much rather be right about Banks.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Riki
banks and achro were his two fakepeeks
Well, yes, but at the time he posted that, I assume he was already planning to drop his fake cover and had started "thinking" Banks was scum. I dunno. Maybe it's just more of a slip by road in emulating town thought-process than actually saying anything about Banks.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Slendy
Oh right, meant to answer this: " I haven't played this format enough to know what scum does more often, but both stick out to me." Yeah I'd say your first impression is correct; much more typical for Scum to avoid grouping their Buddies together.
Ok, but is it also unusual to put a teammate as top townread for so long? I mean, road did, but also used the fakepeek as reason for it. My noob logic says that, hey, I've already seen one mafia do it, that makes it more possible that another mafia did it.