LOL, Kami.

Nope, perfectly reasonable. This was the response/convo I wanted when I first asked what I felt was a reasonable question (and not an attack).

(Yes, I mentioned auto-lynch. I was giving you context for why I was asking at all. It was clearly needed, in retrospect, but I must have failed in explaining.)

What is so funny

you played with him in baldur's gate right? how does it compare

I decided that I have enough doubt about him that I'd prefer to push Gnawazan.

That's not to say that I actually read him as good. At least at this juncture.

And I'd also sorta prefer Gnawazan just because he's not ****ing here and hasn't done anything all game day not related to Phoenicks. At least if ash is a villager we'll potentially have an opportunity to figure it out in the next day or so.

same question to spruce about no lynches

I think Gnaw is townie tbh, I think his post was reasonable he just needs more.

Okay I apologize for the misunderstanding.

I read the question as a rhetorical device. Still don't really see how it was productive, though.

Your response in #537:

You don't need to do paragraphs-long walls, but like a sentence or two of explanation with votes would be nice at least.

well the first reason is that they're both there individually, i don't really try to look too deeply into interactions on d1 or before the first mafia flip

also i haven't actually seen that much of spruce pushing that line, unless that happened today and i haven't read it yet. i did think that spruce voting ashersky while kind of townreading him was weird and might indicate scum/town if spruce is scum (obviously means nothing if spruce is town) but yea i didn't really look into that much either

Replace "soah" with "asher" in my post because that's what I really meant, apologies.

I'll be sure to in the future

Just retread Gnaw...there is really not much there. At all. What was the odd thing about pming the mod and not posting?

He didn't understand that this was not a majority-lynch game.

o

well i don't actually remember spruce pushing that line either so uh

A fair mistake if he didn't read the OPs...which isn't great, but whatever.

Not posting since seems like sour grapes from scum.

Votes from post 8 to post 567
Night in 1:59:56
---

Votes	Lynch	Voters
2	Phoenicks	Jrdrylie (33), Gnawazan (19)
2	Mashiii	No Lynches (59), spruce (70)
2	Gnawazan	soah (69), Riki (60)
2	Jrdrylie	Lissa2 (29), nolemonplease (47)
1	spruce	Mashiii (17)
1	ashersky	notquitethere (13)
1	soah	ashersky (41)
1	Lissa2	Kawamii (42)
1	unvote	Phoenicks (50)

why would you make association cases on day 1 in the first place

The answer was posted in the thread a long time ago so I'm assuming his absence is for other reasons, but who knows.

I don't know what to make of it so I'm just ignoring it and focusing on his gameplay from while he was playing.

Hey, I could always be wrong, but I made up my mind about No Lynches in the first posts of the game and I've seen nothing to dissuade me from that.

Someone brought up earlier that one of the advantages and, I don't know, even purposes of the championship series has been to avoid meta-reads on players from other games. It it really matters, you ask anyone on my home site and they'll always say, "spruce? Who knows", which kind of surprises me a bit 'cause I've always thought myself a pretty easy read.

In the baldur game (my only other game here - to get a pre-game feel of things), it was immediately noted (by wolves, btw) that my posting style seemed more serious than my lighthearted posts in the what, championship sign-up or check-in thread. Here, I'm said to be all fluff and nothing else, where that simply has not been true. I just like to enjoy a game that's a game and try to make it fun for others - championship or no. Do we really take ourselves so seriously?

lolz

In all seriousness, this feels like a pretty exaggerated paraphrase to me. It's also kind of a loaded question.

It's helpful to figure out that one of your suspects can't actually be a wolf with any of your other suspects.

And, more generally, it helps you to realize that you're doing something very wrong if you can't get any set from your suspect pool to fit together as a coherent team.

Has gnaw really not posted since that thing about whether there were majority lynches? I thought he had, like last night. I guess I should check.

I believe in you spruce senpai