I just love this guy!

I'm interested in the reason for your good read on soah.

btw, what is it that you'd love to follow me on? Gnawazan is the one I'm voting right now and you aren't showing a lot of enthusiasm for that vote, so I don't understand what you might be referring to.

oh lol nolemon asked the same thing

oops

I think this is the first post from you that I've liked. Not that I disliked all of the others, but I've been getting a neutral tone and non-alignment indicative thoughts/questions vibe from most of them.

Ah, okay. Lol, I just mentioned Spruce and Phoenicks there because they had the second and third highest post counts in this thread at the time.

I don't really post reads at the start of the game. That's just kinda my thing. Half of them end up flipping by the end of the day anyway so I'd rather just try to get them right the first time around.

yo

Anyone around

phone posting and havrnt readup

Let me know of there is something i needto look at or respond, ill catch up propely when i get home

What is this supposed to say? I think there are a bunch of words missing and I can't parse it.

i was looking at some things and i noticed that spruce is townreading ashersky but is also voting him?

what's up with that

Above the slash or below?

Above the slash is just a reordering of the tally.
To me, the stuff below seems complete? But it could totally be me phrasing stuff weirdly.

I see scum i vote scum, doesnt make sense to me if you think im wolfy to not be happy with votes on me

Fair enough if you think the votrs themself our suspiscious i suppose
Yep i definjtely said that. Day is Only about half ocer thouhh, soyou'll definitely see mote posts from me tonifht. I wqs expectinf more activity and mayelbe someone loke banks to bounce off

But acticity levels are a bit low and especially for me today

Apologies for awful spelling and punc btw

I think the missing word is more/less

I got more of a conflicted read from spruce about ash.

Ah! Yeah "bother me more than they should".

The vote on Phoenick here was intended to just be in italics, I think, right?

So what you want to say there is that his vote bothers you but you think you might be overreacting to it?

ok literally every time i try to open someone's filter i get told to wait 15 seconds

trying to do this from a phone is actually tilting

still wanted to do a bigger post before i go to sleep since there's a decent probability that i wouldn't be able to tomorrow, so it's going to have to be completely from memory

town -> mafia
phoenicks
nolemonplease

kawamii
notquitethere
soah

jrdrylie
mashi
no lynches

ashersky
gnaw
lissa
spruce

no order within tiers

i've said a lot about phoenicks already, i've also gotten a decent feel from his later posts. if i did association reads his interaction with gnaw might also be good for him if gnaw is mafia. i liked nolemon's reaction to the early scumlean from no lynches a while ago, agree with most of the observations they've made, and he/she is like the only person town reading me which isn't actually cool but it is cool for nolemon

don't really have much to say about the second group except that i haven't really seen anything that would make me think they could be mafia. kawamii mostly on carefreeness, i've liked a lot of the ways that soah has poked at people and he isn't higher mostly out of fear or something like that. notquitethere had some decent points on jrdrylie, his read on me seemed genuine

jrdrylie's entire playstyle is strange to me and i don't think i could tell whether it's just that or if it's because he's mafia at this point. mashi's one big post was ok, didn't agree with some of her reads. no lynches' contribution had been underwhelming by the standard that he set for himself, haven't agreed with some of his reads either.

i've already said what i thought about lissa's interaction with jrdrylie, her other contributions have also been underwhelming when i was expecting her to be one of the more active posters judging from her bio. ashersky's flip on no lynches was bad, i also remember not liking his other reads. gnaw's case on phoenicks was bad, he hasn't really done anything else

spruce is a big question mark for me.

would be most ok with voting any of the bottom four at this point

i'm not sure if his weird semi-roleplaying posting style is influencing me on this but i haven't liked a number of his posts, he's apparently voting a townread, and his handling of soah was weird

Right. I'm hesitant to mark it as a strong minus because I think it might be a bit of culture differences? It's been a decent ping to note when I play on BGG, but I'm wondering if in this case it's a difference in voting behavior of our usual villages. Thinking so at the moment, because it felt like it was a natural thing for him to help run a player up and then move on.

it was a pretty strange read yeah, but he does have actual mafia reads that he isn't voting first

Okay I've thought about it and I've decided on my vote.

I don't think it'll change
ashersky

I tried to be kinda patient with notquitethere because I sorta liked the way that he was questioning Jrdrylie, but I think we're at the point where he just needs to be on my wolf list. His focus is just way too narrow, giving very little comment on any other players. And his back-and-forth with Jrdrylie just seems so dry. At first it was nice to see the questioning but then it just drags out without really seeming to go anywhere.

Even disregarding his posting style, he just seems way out of sync with the thread.

Eventually he posts a list of some thoughts on other players, and to be fair to him he never pretended that it was anything more than "some impressions", but nonetheless it was just some surface-level observations which demonstrate very little thought on his part about the people's roles.

I still think the fact that some people have literally said they think someone is good but voted for them is really suspicious but that would just be way to obvious from my point of view. It still makes no sense to me though