Care to explain?

That's because i do not know their alignments. VE has not given enough for me to make me think he is town/scum, i dunno how Well known plays, but i do not like him saying "lynching is pro-town" in 100 words.

You seem town. This TommyDanger dude seems town too.

In any case -- even if no-lynching was pro-town -- you do not propose it in the first post of the day 1!!!! Can't you see how the proposition is 100% anti-town?

Tommy, with regards to the bolded, just some clarification with well named's claim:

Claiming villager on this site is pretty much a token opening and just means you're declaring yourself aligned with the village. It's not the same as claiming vanilla villager with no powers.

Lettuce werewolf

vagos

You know better than to say that anti-town = mafia. It's simply not true.

BLFG

Sketchy ****, Rayn.

You might be right. I want to hear more from STS. Now who do you think is mafia?

I did think VE's villager comment came across as a bit more...awkward I suppose? than well-named's did. I guess his felt more like saying 'please believe me' and well-named felt more like 'this is what I am suck it if you don't like it'.

sup Chips

but no

This is an interesting way to evaluate things. Early good read on you.

Sup and thanks for the responses so far.

I am willing to change my game based on circumstances, we're all very good players but that also means that we'll be good at lying. I've found in my community that a no lynch is also often met with resistance, but it gets people talking about the dynamics of the game that are hidden, while the roles and possibilities in this game are revealed and open

I hope you can forgive me discussing the difference in our communities(not purely for filler) because I think it would be interesting and useful knowing the different cultures, especially since some sites have more than 1 player representing them and they are familiar with their tricks and strategies.

Crabby and I like to keep roles hidden for as long as possible to be useful. Scum hunting is the best, but town does not always agree on scummy behavior and results speak louder than behaviour

It's just unfamiliarity with the parlance.

So rayn in this game too? Superb.

VE's claim is par for the course. He does that as either alignment. The wording is strange because of the different terminology used to differentiate town from mafia.

See? I nailed it.

No one has seemed particularly wolfy to me so far, but I would say there was something about darthe's big psych post that seemed a little off, or a little bit like trying too hard to make up a read. I also think that maki dropping in by first responding to someone else, and then saying nothing original is slightly wolfy

BLFG

I read his bio. He's a wolf here.let's lynch him.

Btw, I'm using the mobile twoplustwo app. It's not bad for when you're afk or your work blocks the site.

We have played lots of games previously, one ended a couple of days ago. And I think his opening has been on the worrisome side.

This is a neat idea. I like it. Of course, I'm horrible at reading evil-Murph so it's probably not useful to hear what I say.

The main thing to take away from Murph is that he is a creative player. Most of his plays go a level deeper than meets the eye. He is not "by the books" at all, which works to his advantage when he's evil and can be a real pain in the ass for evil when he's good.

I echo the sentiment of Murph being involved, good-natured, and quite a hilarious fellow with his offbeat brand of humor. But he'll do this as either alignment. I haven't found any glaring "this is good murph and this is evil murph" kindof things. I feel like evil-Murph is more quick to cast wider nets of suspicion to keep good's level of doubt high, but I'm not sure if that's actually true or not.

Sorry I left but I got really invested in how madoka ended.

My input on the last few pages:
In my experience, seasoned players don't go out of their way to try and prove they're one alignment or another unless prompted. That naturally puts a few people on my suspicious list right out of the gate.

Also, you've convinced me on the day 1 lynch strategy. In the past the threat of impending lynch has gotten a few people to act out of character now that I think about it, so I'm all for it.

So here is the situation on weekdays. I'm phone posting presently and won't be at a computer until around 10 hours from this post. This should only be an issue if I come under heavy scrutiny though and I don't forsee that being an issue this game considering my uncanny ability to appear town AS town. But if I go for hours between posting during the week, it's likely because my phone died or something.

Fair nuff. The different terminology/slang here threw me a bit at first so that makes sense.

Votes are the best ways to make people talk. I want you to explain why did you think it's beneficial to propose a no-lynch right at the game start? Why should we talk about dynamics of the game? Why not find and lynch scum instead?

And that's not to say Murph doesn't know the books. He knows them, has read them, and cuts out pages of different books and pastes them together to keep things interesting.

Well, looks like we won't be snugging anytime soon, but I hope to one day win your approval.

These bios make it pretty clear there was a mistake in who's representing SE and who's POG.

I tend to expect that evil isn't going to come out with such barbs as "conspicuous" and "unimpressive" so I actually have an early good read of yamato for his stern, disapproving head-shaking.