Page 3 funnies

This is NF's first post

TEB is like a level 5 troll

[redacted]

I still agree with this

Hooray for banter

Monte started pinging me early with this post that I interpreted as "TTT is sleeping so he must be a wolf"

Yep

This line of questioning -- do you consider yourself a better blah blah -- I've seen wolves use this question in early game repeatedly just to stir up conversation and false interaction. Gadarene did this in WN's game a few months ago, Tappo/Mucks did this in the game we just wolfed together. This was a major ping for me.

TEB LOCK CLEAR

This one was weird in hindsight because NF has never seen a Cory wolf game

This makes me worried that NF and Cory could be w/w, but that's tinfoil, haven't seen wolf signs from Cory otherwise

I don't understand this vote from Monte

I don't know why he has suspicious of NF at this point, NF was being his usual self for most of D1 IMO, I'll show you guys what I mean when I get further into the pages

lol

Mucks sees it too, so at least I'm not crazy

My spider sense is not tingling

OMG OMW

If there's anything suspicious on that page between the [redacted] members, it might be Redd buddying Cory a little, but mindmelding is kind of our thing so I don't find it wolfy

TTT - I think you would be better served ISOing certain players rather than just quoting massive walls of text that literally do nothing other than to copy and paste page 1, 2 and 3.

Who are the 4 wolves IYO? Also, why, obviously?

Most of page 4 is me so I didn't quote it all

Dice's posting here is a little rigid but not wolfy

I'm not sure what his point is

Pingpingping! I don't know why Dice would say TEB is a mislynch waiting to happen

Talking to TEB

Yep I agree

It's also what Monte is doing now I think

This whole interaction with Monte was bizarre. This kind of hard deflection is more wolfy than villagery, just saying "No." as if I'm an idiot for reading him as wolfy; UD did the same thing as a wolf

This is why I stopped getting @ Monte in early game, because I had a villa lean on NF and trusted his judgment

It may be TMI in retrospect, I can't say Monte has been villagery in this game. Or they are w/w or NF is v and is just wrong, or... I don't know yet, we need a flip.

Dice had a pingworthy post on this page, and there's weirdness between NF and Monte (like NF hard defending Monte after Monte is friendly chatty with him, votes for him without explanation, desperately tries to get me to leave him alone, and leaves) that I won't be able to figure out without a flip

Did Monte offer his solve for this game? I gave him the chance to, where's he at wrt that?

If its not NoFear/You its NoFear/CoryCurren. I doubt Mucks, UAW, or Mets is on the wolf team but I could be getting tricked.

hey TTT,

keep doing that thing where you quote massive walls of text that no one is going to read to make it look like you are doing #work

also pretend that you don't already know that i read the entire thread last night and have posted at least 150 times on this game day, always in real time, with an evidently villagery thought process

i am going to eat a delicious lunch of grilled chicken and greek yogurt because i had too many chewy chips ahoy last night due to stress

carry on

I'm remembering things I either forgot to finding things I missed, and I'm running in zombie mode since I have a fever, I think this is worthwhile. But I'm looking at NF/Monte/LB/Dice team right now maybe? I don't think you are a wolf, you had a normal opening and the biggest reason you were wolfy is your inactivity, and you're here now and trying to solve

So my current villa pile is
-Mucks
-Mets
-Cory
-UAW
-Bhuber

Leaving
-Monte
-Nofear
-Dice
-Luckbox
-Redd

I could lynch any of Monte/NF/LB/Dice today, probably in that order, with Redd in a more distant fifth place, he still gives me glimmers of villageryness. If somehow those 5 do not contain all the wolves, I'd be willing to bring Cory back into the fold, but not before we have to. We have been in full or nearly full agreement for this entire game, I don't see him faking that as a wolf

It's funny that you get on my case for being aggressive or obnoxious, but when you're cornered, you act like a kid throwing a temper tantrum. It might be villagery... if you weren't probably just a wolf

Message me tonight to remind me to sign up

awfully conciliatory tone for someone that's on your short wolf list

why not just drive me into the ground and get me lynched if you're a villager and I'm a wolf?

As for the why:

Monte because he seems much less likely to be a villager than a wolf who simply got his WIM back. The way he talked to me like he knows I'm a wolf (last chance to mislynch me) and then like he knows I'm a villager (you can't read me) and then openly trolled the thread for most of D2 and has been hyper-specific in his arguments for why people are wolfy. He doesn't seem to be taking the big picture into account when he makes arguments, he's dodging the meat of the thread, he's just screaming the loudest about the scraps.

Nofear because he's gone a long time without actually doing anything. His D1 reminded me of his villager game, but it never evolved. In the game we swept UD, he kept coming back and pointing out new things that helped us narrow down the wolf team on D2. I haven't seen that here, and his hard defense of Monte doesn't jive with the way Monte got @ him and left his vote on Nofear for roughly half of this game in terms of real time. NF/Monte fit well together for w/w.

Luckbox is harder for me to read, but him being a wolf makes sense to me because he seemed to get defensive when Mets got @ him early game, and he's had some weird gibberish moments in this game that I don't have tabbed by remember seeing. I saw Redd had quoted one recently when I was making those early game posts.

Dice because we're running out of suspects and I'd lynch him before I lynched Redd or Cory. The [redacted] has mindmelded repeatedly throughout this game and I don't see them being wolves. Dice is doing a lot better than he did as a wolf in his previous game, but Mucks could be right that someone is coaching him, if you look at that post of his I said was pingy just a few minutes ago, that could be a slip. I don't recall LB/Dice interacting much; I bet if one flips wolf, so will the other.

This is Tom's process - why do we have problems with that?

Nofear saw me as a wolf in a turbo once. I lolcatted the entire game and took advantage of a drunk wangpirate to win at f3 against a SHC Kaze ^.^

You're the only one that understands

Imma ISO Monte for great justice

you sure got caught up on my d3 posting super quickly

do you want to take the time to address any of my actual arguments or just dismiss them because I'm not thinking how people "fit together" yet

newflash: we have killed no wolves and are almost to ML, I don't care who can't be a wolf with whom yet. The time for that will be if/when a wolf is lynched

wait until ~6:30 when I peace out for most of the rest of the night; I won't be back for the rest of the night and you can probably get me lynched at that point

This is troubling. Mets spends all of EOD1 calling Tom and I lock wolves without giving any real reasons - but then he votes EndBoss - the player Tom and I spent all of day 1 pushing and blindly defends Bhuber.



So I guess Luck thinks Tom and I were wolves bussing EndBoss so thats why he voted EndBoss?

Well that cant be the case because he just gave the LOL reason for not wanting to vote NoFear because supposedly I'm bussing him.



Luckbox has made NO SENSE whatsoever this game. For the people who have played with Luckbox before, is he generally this bad as a villager?

No, of course he isnt. He is a great villager.

In those quotes up there - Luckbox goes from giving EndBoss a day 1 pass for having too much confidence as a wolf, to voting him over Bhuber in less than two hours in which EndBoss hadnt made another post.

LOLWhat?

I meant Luckbox* not sure why I said Mets

lol

You realize if we are both villagers your trollish grandstanding for the past 24 hours has been extremely counter-productive, right? Do you realize this?

I find it hard to believe you are villa given your insistence on proving me wrong rather than proving yourself right

Redd I like what you've got there

if you think that's what i've been doing you obviously haven't been reading the thread

others have read and followed my line of thinking and found it villagery

also i'm far from the only person you have to convince about being a villager; i was relatively quiet about my suspicions until others (i believe it was muck first, but could be wrong) came out and started to question you

the amount of credibility i had with the thread plus my own uncertainty that maybe i was crazy made me hesitant

i also find the underlined amazing coming from you

Ok so from Luckbox post #1 where he says EndBoss gets a pass to Luckbox post #2 where he votes Endboss


guess how many posts EndBoss makes?

Zero. So Luckbox completely changed his mind on EndBoss for ???? reasons.


Between those 2 posts he keeps calling Tom and I lock wolves, but then votes the #1 suspect we are pushing in EndBoss.

LOLwhat?

one thing i will say about luckbox is that he came around on me awfully quickly, which is concerning to me given that if he's a wolf he obv knows my role

on the other hand, it's hard to say objectively that my d3 hasn't been villagery

the end result is that i shouldn't be driving the lynch with how terrible my first few days were, so I'm going to take a step back and respond to people as needed and let things develop a bit