I think Slighted is not a villager and so I figured I should use my item

You seem to be building a case that I am an obvious wolf for bad reasons and which is wrong

I tend to agree, but did you express that thought previously?

yup

Because I respect your villlager game

eh, his vote was at 7pm and it tied the wagons at 3-3 (referencing my earlier mq)

not exactly a clincher

No I was watching Star Wars when Slighted did the not-villagery stuff

suga, what's your read on irtm? I noticed you put him up on a list earlier, spaced apart from others

Ok

Which reasons specifically are bad and why

Voting you instead makes in 4-2 in a 12 player game with 3 AFK non-voters, of which at least two and probably all three were villagers

So it actually would have been pretty close to a clincher

I don't recall you expressing that sentiment in the past. The only thing that's good about my villager game is that I'm pretty good at clearing myself through my attempts at game solving.

Right now the way the puzzle looks to me, you & Slighted are probably usually going to be wolves.

There just aren't really that many permutations of other things I find that plausible. The most likely alternative scenario involves a Monte/IANAWW power wolf team.

I'll keep an open mind, but I dunno.

If I'm power wolfing, I don't hard defend my wolfbro so I can bus another tammate

I'd just get a villager killed, which I almost certainly could have done had I wanted, considering I started the Crimson wagon from nothing relatively late in the day

I think he’s a villager but his vote on crimsonfox seems like the least critical one. I was a little suspicious of him yesterday at points but this is the first game I remember where he posted a lot

ah, that makes sense. I wasn't thinking about the 3 afks.

NeedMoreManasi - Peeked Villager

Sugabat - No idea. I never know what he's doing and I love it

CarolinaCoder - Early tone and posting was SUPER villagery she is usually way more subdued as a wolf. Starting to think that she possibly might have TMI with some of her recent posts and where she is going with them

Slighted - I like his reaction to being wrong about Crimson. Seemed like he just genuinely thought Crimson was a villager and was wrong, I think as a wolf he would just pile onto Crimson there

iamnotawerewolf - Had one read that I am a wolf and other than that not really playing much. Voted off wagon which is a bad look but other than that I'll just look at him later

Montecore - Mainly for the reason I gave day 1 but also he led the lynch on Crimsonwolf. Still think he is a SK possibility but never a vanilla wolf

JMurder3 - Seems happy enough to join on my wagon which FMPOV is wolfy jumping into a game and jumping on a villager's wagon

iraisetoomuch - Thinks I fake random voted to vote for him on day 1 as a wolf because I am a wolf who is super scared of his villager game or some insane thing I don't know what he thinks?? Probably just a villager

Village is like always losing here but here is my Tier list:

Manasi
Monte

Suga
Slighted
irtm

JMurder3
CarolinaCoder
ianaww

Which things specifically? What else did you pick up when you were reading overnight? Sacrificial lamb Crimson so you guys can solidify your places as thread leaders. I don't like the theory that much, but not much else even fits. Like Carolina/suga/IRTM should almost never have more than 1 wolf I don't think?

I have never expressed any sentiment regarding that in either way no. I am expressing it right now though lol. I think you just had to sub in wolf and are happy there is a villager wagon you can jump on

One of my 1st posts of the day was stating that I think you're likely to be a wolf, long before Monte started pushing you iirc.

irtm called me his “most likely wolf” first and when I told him to vote me he wouldn’t which I was thought was a little suspicious (note: he said “most likely” not necessarily a “likely wolf” though)

I think his reasons for saying that ended up being a misunderstand from some dumb thing I said, but then he actually voted me later and I don’t know why?

So by that logic, shouldn't my original push, Slighted, be a wolf?

Plus NL was gone and Donnie was boarding a plane

Each vote was actually super important

so I think irtm is a villager but just because he posted a lot and seems like a nice person and late voted crimson I guess, so I put a line break in my villager reads for him because that could be wrong

You think me calling Crimson's open the wolfiest,(which I was right about) was just seperation and that I should have voted for him instead of randing my vote.

My thought process was, since I am more confident in my villager reads, (2 out of 3 have been confirmed to be correct) that I should remove the villagers I have and rand the rest because I would have a pretty good shot at hitting a wolf that way.

So this game I am being punished for having good reads apparently.

We really need to wolf together at some point

Because your perception of what wolfing is, much less how I would actually do it, especially in this setup, is ridiculous

Mostly that Slighted got mad at me for voting Crimson, then voted Crimson himself but qualifies it with “idk about this vote,” then unvoted Crimson and voted ianaw