Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game 11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game

11-08-2011 , 12:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JimHalpert
hi vyk
i like that you put necro on your wolf list
i wasnt sure why everyone had him as villa
but everyone DID have him as villa
and it was creeping me out
only reason he is doing that is because ive called him out, the reason everyone else has put me as a villager is well cos im a villager i might not be cleared yet but give me a day or so and i will
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JimHalpert
have you wolved before noah?
have we even played before?
In SoA and never played with you.
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by necro
only reason he is doing that is because ive called him out, the reason everyone else has put me as a villager is well cos im a villager i might not be cleared yet but give me a day or so and i will
oh dont get me wrong, i dont have you as wolfy
it just kinda creeps me out when everyone has someone as a villager and i cant understand why
cause it means even the wolves are clearing them
so i feel im missing something hugely lol
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JimHalpert
hi vyk
i like that you put necro on your wolf list
i wasnt sure why everyone had him as villa
but everyone DID have him as villa
and it was creeping me out
Sup jimbr0 (that's my new nickname for you )

So I recently played with necro in true blood

I was a villager and he was a wolf

Here's what happened before I had to sub out:

I put a crucial vote on the JOAT wolf during close wagons, resulting in his lynch

Everyone is doing wagon analysis and assigning leans to the voters

Necro plops in and attempts to discredit my vote on the JOAT, and not only discredit but to cast doubt on it, implying that it was some kind of clear bus

I promptly pop in, give him sh*t for it, and immediately identify him as a wolf.

I then have to sub out and my replacement still gets mislynched at f3, despite my early mechanical clearance in the game

So the point I'm trying to get at, is that too many clear villagers is super bad for the wolves, who will be very hesitant to clear other villagers and assign vilalge leans after wisski's death, for fear of narrowing down potential mislynch opportunities
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by necro
i am also here trying to re-read me and omw yesterday to decide whether i actually believe he is a wolf or whether im just mistakenly tunnelling and im definitely more weighed towards him being villagery
this was pretty darn villagery
there's lots of work being done, and my baseline for his wolf game is pretty low (no offense)
even though I can't actually remember a wolf game from him
but I'm calling him new-villagery
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:03 PM
I wolfed with Noah in SOA.

I strongly believe this is his villager game.
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by necro
only reason he is doing that is because ive called him out, the reason everyone else has put me as a villager is well cos im a villager i might not be cleared yet but give me a day or so and i will
you called me out?

How about I call you out wolf

what then?
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:03 PM
unvote

noahs probs villa
i remember him from the woof chat i was railing in SoA now that he mentions it
he was pretty nervous
and i dont think the little experience could be the reason he's so freeflowing, read giving, and "hi why vote" -> proceed to answer questions quickly and clearly
when he was pretty nervous only a few days ago




hmmm
who to vote next to clear?
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by vyk07
By probably do you mean like a confidence interval significantly greater then 50% or a confidence interval barely shifting from the base ~25%?

Just how sure are you Silman?
maybe 40%
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by FCBLComish
I wolfed with Noah in SOA.

I strongly believe this is his villager game.
This is contextually inadequate information
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Silman
maybe 40%
it was more when you were refusing to contribute
you are slowly getting back from almost-lock-wolf
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Silman
maybe 40%
oh thank goodness

so we can still semi-cooperate this game then?
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by vyk07
Sup jimbr0 (that's my new nickname for you )

So I recently played with necro in true blood

I was a villager and he was a wolf

Here's what happened before I had to sub out:

I put a crucial vote on the JOAT wolf during close wagons, resulting in his lynch

Everyone is doing wagon analysis and assigning leans to the voters

Necro plops in and attempts to discredit my vote on the JOAT, and not only discredit but to cast doubt on it, implying that it was some kind of clear bus

I promptly pop in, give him sh*t for it, and immediately identify him as a wolf.

I then have to sub out and my replacement still gets mislynched at f3, despite my early mechanical clearance in the game

So the point I'm trying to get at, is that too many clear villagers is super bad for the wolves, who will be very hesitant to clear other villagers and assign vilalge leans after wisski's death, for fear of narrowing down potential mislynch opportunities


I agree with your conclusions.
Are there specific posts you see necro doing this?
Or anyone else for that matter?
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:05 PM
OK.

I am leaving in 10 minutes and will not be back for the rest of the day.

I see no reason not to leave my vote on VYK unless something very compelling comes up before I go.
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:06 PM
Palo
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:06 PM
Credibility

Credibility

Credibility
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:06 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by vyk07
This is contextually inadequate information

I disagree. I am calling Noah a villager based on previous interactions. If you are saying that it is useless if I am a wolf, then wait until I die and then use it.
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by vyk07
you called me out?

How about I call you out wolf

what then?
you have me confused with someone else regarding the eadgbe lynch because i dont remember any interaction with you at all that game except for d5 or so when i was trying to set you up for a mislynch you might be right and we did have an argument but i have no recollection whatsoever

as for your calling me out, well your wrong i am a villager and even more sure that whether your a wolf or a villager if your going to try and get me mislynched then your harming the village and should still die today
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Palo
Some reads starting with low post count players.

Loretta; 6 posts, villa lean. Says he'll be low participation for first couple days but still had reads on several players with reasons and got a vote on a wagon leading up to EOD. The vote was unfortunately on a villager but at least he voted a wagon which is generally good I believe.

Duckburg; 10 posts, fancy play specialist, no lean right now. He's as cryptic as ever and voted Silman. He's got a mechanic thing going that I don't want to discuss or get into. Others can do it but I really am trying to get away from that.

Bremen; 15 posts, villa lean for being too wolfy to be wolfy, Votes Vyk apparently because Bremen is a Philly Eagles fan and Vyk roots against them and gives a better feeling about FCBL for liking the Eagles. Gives Tao a wolfy read for a previous game. Says he is ridiculous and distracting as a villa and serious as a wolf so ldo villa if this is true. However, it's just anti-villa to be this way and not care but would take tremendous balls to make these posts as a wolf. I don't know Bremen well enough to know if he's capable of this as a wolf. If so disregard the too wolfy to be wolfy part and just make him wolfy.
I have a weak villa lean on palo based solely on this post. Thoughts?
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by vyk07
Necro plops in and attempts to discredit my vote on the JOAT, and not only discredit but to cast doubt on it, implying that it was some kind of clear bus
show me where this happened because i do not remember it and if it didnt happen then your lying and all liars must be lynched
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:10 PM
hey all, trying to catch up
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:11 PM
"starting with the low posters" implies he would continue with more reads.
Did he?
Also, iirc he said he'd be around for a while and then out during the day phoneposting but wasnt able to post very much when thread first opened?
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Palo
I'm sorry. Are you saying Bremen is capable enough to be so ballsy wolfy as a wolf? If so then I already said I agree he's just plain wolfy then.



Agree with this. I thought she was villa yesterday. I've played a few more games than her I think and still am not clear on exactly what is seer hunting in thread.



So does him switching off Kruze to VM make Kruze more likely a wolf? I think I've played one game or two at most with Kruze and he seems to be like mini-Anarchist to me. No clue what he is or what he's doing.
there's this, shortly afterwards?
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:15 PM
Silman:

I have potentially valuable information for the village
but it would require me to claim my role
theres no way to out it without outing my role
and i may not live past tonight where the information would be lost

thoughts?
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote
11-08-2011 , 12:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by FCBLComish
I disagree. I am calling Noah a villager based on previous interactions. If you are saying that it is useless if I am a wolf, then wait until I die and then use it.
perhaps it was a poor choice of words

I meant more like beating a dead horse with a stick inadequate

your like the 10th person to go out of your way to specificly call noah a villager

it's already beyond obvious
11/7 Supernatural Mishmash game Quote

      
m