should use mafia and innocent imo.

Not to be lynched till lategame:
Swiitch
Silman
Duckburg
Derwipok

Okay I'm just going to hope night isn't in 4 hours and I'm gonna go to bed.
Night all

Yes, or mafia and town. Angel is just too confusing.

Why? Weird collection of people if this is just a Strong Player Don't Kill kind of thing, and waiting until lategame is pretty extreme if that's your intent.

Can anyone familiar with the theme tell me if there's a villa character who's likely to have the kind of post restriction Duckburg is hinting at?

It's too hard to re-read on my phone. Can someone tell me if tao is a wolf?

Who do you disagree with?

not sure. His posts are weird and random. almost like yours.

lol?

Damn, I think he is a wolf but I didn't want to have to reread on my phone.

But now I will

Sup guys. Won't do much today because I'm about to go to work. Prob should just nk me now before I start reading souls and ****.

No, I am just putting it out there. I have trouble reading you.

I have the birds, but I'm rooting against them

Ok, gotta go.

Sponging Gadarene


THENOTHING

Wow, I could lynch you for that statement! How dare you root against the Eagles!

Well, to begin with I disagree with the notion of giving anyone a pass into lategame. I'm fine with d1 passes, but beyond that it gets increasingly tenuous, and I think saying "wait until lategame" for anybody is just not tenable. It's called a halfway rule for a reason.

Secondly, if your intent is to identify the strongest potential villas, I think you've left a couple of names off your list. Jim and cracked in particular are both excellent villas, and I could make an argument for a few more people as well.

Third, I haven't seen Duckburg dominate a game as villa in quite some time, and while Swiitch can certainly own souls as a villager, I think his wolf and villa games are polarized enough that we shouldn't be putting him on any kind of "do not kill" list until he's at least posted. If Swiitch ends up putting forth the same kind of effort as he did in Shadows of Amn, I agree that I don't ever want to see him dead.

Does this stuff make sense?

tao1

All of his posts are kind of about the game but not really about the game

are thou pertrubed brethren?

sup thread!

This game is gonna be AWESOME

I'm just here to announce that:

Noah
KruZe

are villagers, yay!

and Old Man Willow, is just crazy bad at gambling

more incoming as I solve this game

To be fair to tao (if he left me off a strong player list or whatever) I've played maybe one game with him and I couldn't even tell you what game that was.

Since I can't multiquote, does everyone want me to quote tao's posts one by one? I'm guessing prob not.

FCBL ameliorates my initial wolfy reads wrt his opening (didn't know he always opens with that seer line, thanks Gad )

vik07

FLY EAGLES FLY
ON THE ROAD TO VICTORY
FIGHT EAGLES FIGHT
SCORE A TOUCHDOWN 1-2-3

HIT'EM LOW
HIT'EM HIGH
AND WE'LL WATCH OUT EAGLES FLY

FLY EAGLES FLY
ON THE ROAD TO VICTORY

E

A

G

L

E

S

EAGLES

I see his posts and your point; I just don't think it's a particularly strong case aorn, and I liked his progression about OMW.

What do you think about TheNothing this game?

Maybe good to check if there is a character that must speak of statistics and logic frequently. It sure seems like possible signaling to me towards the wolves because we know there are lies, damn lies, and statistics which in my mind suggests statistics = evil.

Perhaps its slightly overstated, but I do think we need overwhelming arguments to lynch any of them. The list might not be complete, but I dont really know the others well enough to judge.

MODNOTE
I am open to extending EOD until tomorrow, if people want. I know I was late so I'm willing to be flexible to accommodate people. Please PM me and let me know if you'd prefer EOD 6:30 PM today or 6:30 tomorrow.

I'm also open to a shorter night and closing the thread later. I just don't know if that would screw anyone up. Let me know.