I'm not saying he is a villager.

You are the one saying he is a wolf.

fwiw, I'm not being flippant and will clarify later but can you please answer first.

binkles

lolcats please

i dont think you make your theory about wolves waiting the thread opening in wolfchat as a wolf

This is a trick that Boo is fond of for whatever reason. He thinks that questioning a wolf read necessitates leaning villager on that person.

It's nonsense.

agreed

ok... what do you think of noah stating he would try to post less? i'm getting the idea that he is preemptively trying to make his villa/wolf meta go away so he can avoid getting lynched later when he loses stamina.

i don't remember most of these people's posts.

oh also, I find it really weird that you're bashing boo for making weird reads and being conclusive about it. elaborating on it would be terrible, though.

False

Dude was sponging a sophistic case on someone who is more than likely a villager. It's possible that VMF could be just a lazy villager here, but it's equally likely he's a wolf.

I doubt he and PBAL are w/w, but I think one of them is

Actually, the trick was me trying to get him to come up with a reason after left him off his read list

If he loses stamina later then anything he says now will mean nothing, nobody is going to say "ohh he said he'd try and post less two days ago so him not posting now isn't a wolf tell" and he knows that. He's been berated for spamming in the past, people are already coming in here bitching about the thread length, and the content of all of his posts are villagery.

Not remembering those people's posts is a pretty good reason to have them as wolves. Most of those guys, if they're posting as villagers, you know about it.

Chips gave me good advice some time ago, he said that often on day one he'd list his villagers and his wolves and his unsures, and his villagers would be villagers, and his wolves would be villagers, and his unsures would be wolves. I think that's true a much higher % of the time than most of us would be comfortable admitting.

I don't understand what your last sentence about Boo, why am I not supposed to elaborate?

Oh yeah, Duckburg probably a reasonable vote too

I'm sure BJL will come in eventually and help me out w/r/t nutshot, I look forward to it

no, me elaborating on it would be terrible.

really terrible.

i'll stfu.

bjaids is no longer 100% on me, dont know if you guys were in the game but he claimed seer with me as his wolf peek

and i was a villager

lol bjaids

holy crap i feel like hell. ****ing baby got me sick. ****ing baby bitch. ****.

anyway i got an idea. everyone pick some person to read and count up their fluff posts and their hard posts. i'll do duckburg. but im starting at post 419 cause i don't feel like going back, at least not right now. so as the game goes on everytime i see a duck post i'll read it and mark it on my tally as fluff or hard

So just say that.

Why are you having filthy as wolfy?

fwiw, if it isn't clear he is not a person I have much of an opinion on yet.

Morning. Going to be phone posting for at least a day and a half so I apologize in advance if I seem a bit shallow with my reads and posts. I will also do my best to interact while itt.

I agree with the early Noah wolf leans.

People wagoning looshle early are looking for an easy mislynch imo.

Boo appears to be villaging, but his wolf reads are usually wrong, especially early.
Vix is also above rand to be a villager, but again he's another player whose reads I wouldn't trust.

Oh

well basically I don't think he can hunt wolves at any reasonable number >rand, he's probably slightly better than that at clearing villagers, and the way he posts makes discussion or any attempt to develop reads on him or others next to impossible, which is why being ridiculously overconfident is an awful habit

I'd probably self vote over voting Noah, fwiw

Sounds like you're coming up with a pre-emptive defense for when he calls you a wolf

Also, we really need to completely ignore the lost wolf crap that tends to derail almost every d1.

I defended hurp for it last game but I'm not going to white knight anyone again for it.

You need to evaluate the rest of the posts from that player. For example, binkles "better votes" list with looshle and wiper at the top sketches me out.

Lol binkles

It's really sad when you're wolfing, I wish you always randed villager. Because you're not a good wolf, and I feel bad for you.

bankles how in the world did you come up with me? I haven't done anything (and won't until I get home later), feels like you're just seeing if you can see what sticks. fishing for a mislynch if you will.

not a good look bro.

He was my first strong wolf lead too, that makes three people now.

I take this as a good sign.

Does anyone think Noah is a villager?

another thing i hope we do as a village this game is lynch utrs. let's lynch obvious wolves first, then utrs after that.

This trend where we talk about hard poasts v. fluff seems to have coincided with the village getting rocked on the regular

Not saying there's any causation there but--

yeah, **** it, I am saying that. Here's the point: it's a lazy ****ing way to make reads. If you think someone's a wolf (or a villager), say why. Don't just rely on, "oh he poasted fluff, wolf." Relying on that is bad and anyone who does it should feel bad.

if we lynch utrs in a 50 players game, its gonna take a week

@anyanka: why is noah a wolf?