Quote:
Originally Posted by captain binkles
Insanity is probably a top 4 villager in this lineup
he says this in response to vyk btw, who is a villager
Quote:
Originally Posted by monikrazy
this is a classic SHROOP
there is no way insanity would be considered a top 4 villager if everyone had potential to be village
Quote:
Originally Posted by monikrazy
binkles
Quote:
Originally Posted by monikrazy
got him
Quote:
Originally Posted by captain binkles
nope
this player list isn't very strong
Quote:
Originally Posted by captain binkles
Tanner didn't you just say you thought I was a villager?
Quote:
Originally Posted by monikrazy
i dont think you would have insanity in your top 4 if you looked it over carefully and/or reviewed the stats
i will look at other things but i find it slightly suspicious
just like Gad dissapearing after he realizes i knew he was vig hunting
Quote:
Originally Posted by captain binkles
I actually just double checked and it goes something like this:
Villagers I'd consider definitively better than Insanity in this game:
Me, Silman, Gadarene
then I think there's a clump afterwards of like Moni, Sando, Euro, Forsy, halfhearted Sooted (from all I've heard fullhearted sooted goes up a category), Vagos and then Hurp and Loosekanen as my dark horse picks
You may not have played with Insanity much but I assure you he's very good
in b4 everyone is insulted
Quote:
Originally Posted by captain binkles
Oops I forgot about Tweedy, he's very good too
hope that doesn't make him mad
Quote:
Originally Posted by monikrazy
sigh.. i think insanity is a promising developing player, and i think he is a fairly difficult mislynch.. but i don't think he is an accomplished wolfhunter
but your rankings are way off and you are leaving out players (okse, Duck, TheNothing for started)
Gad is too high
i will accept that your ranking is compltely flawed though which makes the odd of this being a genuine Shroop lower
So here is the whole series of posts. You will notice that even though he should be in anti-spew he spoke candidly about several things.
For one he was probably tellingt he truth about where he thought insanity ranked as a villager given the wolf composition. We can infer this based on Fors flipping wolf, who would be considered a strong player close to universally.
Similarly, he later adds I forgot Tweedy - who flips village.
Moreover you can see that I cut him a little slack at the end, but the whole time I am working on extending the interaction. Binkles probably didn't want to extend the interaction much more than the extent of seer-hunting. He also makes a post to tanner that I including which looks like he was doing similar.
I think the end of day interactions add to this.
Again, I understand why people could argue that binkles is in anti-spew d2 but I would argue that anti-spew does not work. You can't control how someone responds and you should not create openings that allow village to clear themselves.