Quote:
Originally Posted by captain binkles
what on earth are you talking about
yes, that's exactly what I'm doing
Monte is >rand to flip wolf but still flipping villa >50% of the time imo
Nothing slighted has done himself merits calling him a villager or a wolf imo
It'd be incredibly stupid to have slighted as a villager just because I had Monte as a wolf. Well not that stupid, but a pretty big leak.
I am obviously considering v/v because otherwise I'd have slighted as a villager
All of which I said in the post you quoted
It's like you read that post, ignored everything I said and then tried to come to some random conclusion
let me put it another way:
if Monte flips wolf we can give slighted some villa points
if Monte flips villa we give slighted nothing
if Slighted flips wolf we can prob give Monte a few villa points but not many
if Slighted flips villa we give Monte nothing
Quote:
Originally Posted by VarianceMinefield
bla bla bla
shut up binkles
here binkles made a =rand post and not at all a reflex of his game (cause he was just really talking about how he makes reads) and variance goes super aggressively against him with the 'bla bla bla' and vote. that's what I said yesterday struck me as kinda forced/ w/w but I didn't feel it was worth anything because I haven't read binkles at that point and I was maybe already tunneling vmf and making stupid conditional reads wrt his role, but now that we know binkles was a wolf this looks slightly damming for variance. I mean first of all, the post wasn't really wolfy, was it? it has a lazy free flowy tone to it. I always have a hard time clearing people that don't see what I'm seeing, and this is basically what variance's vote strucks me with. he is spotting wolfiness in binkles when I don't see how that's really possible with his posts. the 'bla bla bla' part is very forced and sounds like variance's SOD wolfy version. it also makes sense for variance to 'hide' himself with an early vote on a wolf both to avoid getting tdomed and look good when/if binkles flips. wolves usually don't think like that (i'm gonna make these early posts to create separation from my wolfbro) but unconsciously it's probably much easier to pile on your wolfbro early for BS reasons than to pile on a villager.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Outed Wolf
you're rationalizing to yourself in the most awkward way to have a vote on binkles
this is outed after zdye post (who I'm hardclearing considering his interaction with binkles) voting binkles. the zdye post is actually pretty good and not really awkward, so Outed's defense sounds a little weird to me. it's also worth noting that Outed somehow felt inclined to make that post, not really pushing zdye and not showing off a suspicious mindset. so some wolf points here.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Silman
here's the thing though
binkles is making me uneasy
he made me feel uneasy last game as wolf and I said so and he was wolf
but there's nothing I can point to and say it's wolfy
like there is some hedging of bets and some cases that don't make sense
but those are meh reads at best
that said I don't like the dwetzel or monte votes
very unlikely w/w
Quote:
Originally Posted by Boo Radley
hurp durp
probably tarped duckburg
voat silman though
lol OMG this is such a ridiculous vote. silman done 0 wolfy things that far in the game, it's such a senseless unflowy vote to make. mehhh hope I'm not blindly tunneling here but the wolfy stuff I spotted came basically from vmf and boo who I thought were woalves yesterday.