XXsooted should probably do some work

gn Silman <3

and ya, acceptable votes are like DarO, Zdye, BAIDS and then maybe some other people

unacceptable votes are anyone I cleared in my earlier list and then also CT, Ashington and Boo and I'm sure some other people too (like that captain binkles guy, he's an obvious villager imo)

Bon Nuit

okay, i'm through the first 3 pages

i'll save everyone the long reads post & just give a list. if you want info on any read, please ask & i'll elaborate. i'll be reading the last few pages & then i'll be real time, baybee

Villagy
Ashington
Tweedy
LKJ
Forsy
Shark

Wolfy:
Holdem
Dwetzel
CDL
Moni
Binkles

Oh, before i forget:

Got semi-caught up on my phone walking into work

binkles voting me was surprising (because he usually reads me correctly) so it would feel good (and a little lazy) to call him a wolf, but I'm not prepared to do that yet. d1 is d1 and thin reads are thin reads; his tone also feels different this game, but that could be an artifact of him being the lost wolf that game. I've never done it, but I'd imagine you'd want to soften your reads in general early on, because it would kind of suck to hard read half your team as a wolf early in the thread and then have to figure out reasons to flip once/if you get found

it feels just as lazy to call zdye a villager for defending me, but that's what I'm going to do.

tweedy feels villagery too for reasons I already explained

people voting dwetzel for changing his entrance when he said he was going to in the signup thread either have poor memories or an agenda

going to try to get caught up in the next half hour or so

Ash, LKJ, Moni, go

referring to the differences in his tone this game vs the recent MLP where he was the lost wolf/JOAT

ashington - i wrote in notes that when people are effortlessly funny, it makes me think they are a villager. same think with LKJ, that explains the read on him too.

Moni - at first, it felt like moni was just in thread, carefree (yes i like that word), going with the flow but then had a few posts that felt like he wasn't "in tune" and was commentating. it's not a strong read by any means.

also, it looks like everyone has tweedy as wolfy. i thought his super serious game-solvey self was villager. i must be missing something or else this is gonna be another one of those games where my reads are gonna be totally opposite so i should just flip my lists.

lol wat

Seems like everyone thinks he's a villager afaict

i'm on pages 3-4 and there's a flurry of votes on him. ??

i'd like to lynch Big Country because i can't even read his posts

maybe they think laid back tweedy is village and game solvey is waffle tweedy

Silman coming at binkles feels like a villager cross-examining. i like it. compared to the last game, it's refreshing.

If I'm any kind of seer, I don't choose my own peek
If I'm full seer I got of peek of Silman villager
If I'm aligment seer I got Shark villager
If I'm even seer I got Montecore villager


If I instead is picking peeks for a seer I sent in loosekannon

I might have to start poasting tittay pics again to un-gay this thread

yeah, people are starting to list him as lock clear now where i am. makes me feel better.

bonkles why do u want me to die

NSFW!!!






Apparently you can't hide video in spoilers?

please due br0

i might actually move ashington down the villa list.
the sponging makes me

i agree with tweedy's initial read on Vagos - when he closes his post with "that's all i got". i do that nearly every time as a wolf.

lol - def not clicking it now

i don't really like VMFs entrance. he's got a lot of animosity aimed at binkles & i'm not sure what to think about it.

These are my notes as I'm catching up:

silman -- seems more villagery than he seemed in MLP (when he was a villager). this is only my second game with him so I'm not sure if he's one of those people that tries hard to be villagery as a wolf, but absent evidence to the contrary I'm going to lean villager on him

vmf's entrance into the thread is villagery, and yes, it's probably influenced by the fact he's fakepeeking me villager; it's also influenced by the fact that he came right into the thread making strong, definitive (maybe even slightly spazzy) reads, which wolfVMF is less likely to do ime.

not sure I buy tweedy's pushing of vagos but I like where his heads at

no real lean on hurp, if pushed i'd say villager but meh

bryant/henrik's posting style is so annoying that i'm not even reading it; hopefully that's not a mistake

forsy continues to be mega villagery

boo's trolly entrance probably role neutral, duck voting him for "laying lost wolf cover" is pretty bad considering boo did the same act last game as a villager

wiper entrance seems awkward, specifically his wtfing about his role seemed slightly forced, and a relatively facile thing to do being that multiple people in the thread had already done so early in the thread, which he's no doubt seen. not sure what significance, if any, to attach to his posting the same thing twice

duckburg's interaction with boo is villagery, and also more substantial than anything he did in MLP

caught up now