Quote:
Originally Posted by captain binkles
what on earth are you talking about
yes, that's exactly what I'm doing
Monte is >rand to flip wolf but still flipping villa >50% of the time imo
Nothing slighted has done himself merits calling him a villager or a wolf imo
It'd be incredibly stupid to have slighted as a villager just because I had Monte as a wolf. Well not that stupid, but a pretty big leak.
I am obviously considering v/v because otherwise I'd have slighted as a villager
All of which I said in the post you quoted
It's like you read that post, ignored everything I said and then tried to come to some random conclusion
let me put it another way:
if Monte flips wolf we can give slighted some villa points
if Monte flips villa we give slighted nothing
if Slighted flips wolf we can prob give Monte a few villa points but not many
if Slighted flips villa we give Monte nothing
Meh.
I think your case on monte is thin. He is one of the more eloquent players in the game, and people like that craft posts regardless of affiliation.
I also think you moving tweedy to the top of your villager list right after he calls you a wolf is sketchy. A villager (which tweedy probably is), will get that warm and fuzzy feeling about being correctly identified and be less likely to push you much harder.
And I get the feeling you're buttering up Silman. I was going to call him a wolf right around the same time you put him 2nd on your villager list. Silman had a string of villagery posts and inquiries right after that, so I'm backing off that initial gut read. However, finding him so villagery when you did is not how I'm seeing things.
So I feel inclined to vote for you,
binkles.