Chrja, start reading, and posting.

Binkles, if I had to put numbers to it, I would say Tony is in the mid/high 50's for scum and the others you named are high 70's or 80's for me, percent chance of being wolf, is what I am feeling.

Hiya buddy

I don't think anything important enough has happened to really be worth noting at the risk of contaminating your thoughts, to be honest. Might be best if you read through things yourself given it's only 500 or so posts

You really think AngryPidgeon is ~80% to be a wolf even though you don't really remember most of what he's done that isn't in relation to you?

I mean, that's a really high level of confidence :P

This post reads strange to me. maybe its my poor english but it sounds like its been edited a couple of times, and if thats the case I don't like it as its a first post.

I will just get straight to reading then.

Binkles, my feel changes as I read, though I do not recall all I read. Like a running tally.

The second post of fank009 isn't any better. I didn't find that Taylors post to be wolfy, he is making an obv. joke. To me this looks like fan just want to join voting Taylor.

weareking get a small lean for having the same thought as me regarding Fan's vote.

watch everyone, as chrja repeats arguments that have allready been, at snail pace...

Yeah I get that. I just think 80% is really really really high and I'm very rarely, if ever, that sure about someone being evil on day 1. And if I was I'd be absolutely up in arms about making sure they were lynched given lynching at random is going to be ~30% to lynch a wolf

I find the colored part to be villagery - trying to hide your own role in fake questions while still trying to get some answers, isn't something wolfs usually care about in their first post.

Thats how i get caught up, deal with it.

but please elaborate on why that joke by Taylor was wolfy?

Tbh this is precisely why I hate D1. I can almost guarantee D2 won't have nearly as many posts, and yet the chances of lynching mafia are lowest on D1, when town has nothing to go on.

And I forget who it was that said something about meta reads. While they are no substitute for in game tells, I'm certainly going to consider them on a day where town knows next to nothing. I did call out Giga = maf and Fank = weak town, and provided reasoning outside of basic meta for both, even tho I initially scumread Fank.

Normally here I'd be screaming for you guys to vote Giga, my top scumread, but MNOWAX isn't really any better so if the lynch goes through on either one of them that's fine.

And yeah dancing chicken, I thought the same about Athexx but since then he's basically not even posted.

Also what chrja's doing isn't a scumtell in the slightest. It shows that despite being a late entry into the game he's rereading the entire thing and pointing out stuff where he can, which shows a certain level of care that mafia are unlikely to have.

I don't like this post - I find it wolfy to kiss up to the guy questioning you, and i went back and in no previous post did he express any opinion on binkels.

I mean I guess mafia could be feeding him information from early day on what's happening, but I'm the type of person that if there's two opposing theories for something, I'm going to choose the one that makes the most amount of sense. I expect him to be one of the better posters once he gets caught up.

I don't get this vote by soah.

Soah correct me if i am wrong. but didn't you at one time tell me that.

"We don't vote people for not acting villagery, but for acting wolfy."

I agree that binkels is in no way is villagery, but i don't think he has been wolfy either.

This is the second time the expression FoS is used - what is the meaning?

- I dont like the "deal with it" attitude, basically, you can have a book, explaining the same thing, instead of 9001 short stories.(to each his own)
And If you read on, You'll see my response to the "fitz being wolfy" comment later on


Isnt a scumtell, not really, It does clog up the chat, and bring up arguments that have allready been brought up, but I guess thats what happens when people are catching up. (like i said, to each his own.)


FoS= Finger of Suspicion FYI

Yeah, Finger of Suspicion is basically naming someone as a main/high suspicion in the event that you're not voting for them at the moment for some reason, but want to have a similar impact as if you were.

I don't like this post.

its to self aware to immediately start defending your self, its not a villagery mindset.

FYI all, I'm not quite caught up but I'm checking in. As I told Thingy when I signed up, this first week is going to be rough for me, especially with this site being blocked from work which means my usual time to post and catch up on the game is missing, and this week I'm going out of town with my wife for my anniversary. So sorry for my own lack of input.

I did see after some responses came in to my initial rules questions that we are supposed to pm those to the mods, and I did. Is it legit on this site to post those responses?

Once Chrja's caught up I expect him to not fall back behind.

And basically Fank there's 2 ways you can look at it. Either he's town feeling a bit of guilt and catching up, or he's mafia and either relying on his scum buddies to active lurk and make these posts up for him or doing this all himself.

Given that there was no pressure on him despite him never posting, I think mafia bothering to reread the entire game wouldn't be an option here, at least not with this many posts already made.

So that leaves us with the first two options. Option 1 is plausible and I can understand it despite it kinda being a nuisance spam wise, and option 2 is less plausible since I doubt his partners would care enough (it goes back to option 3 essentially).

since when did you need pressure on you to post? if that was the requirement, there wouldnt be any posting... There is the idea of gaining townie points, but I do agree with you that it is a bit extreme