#1 Game of Mafia Champions (WW Invitational) - Game Thread
09-05-2013
, 04:29 PM
I'm going to repost part of what I said earlier about Giga:
He hasn't posted in the past 30 hours, but the case against him is incredibly sloppy. Nobody has posted more than 1 paragraph (I'm probably being nice here too) on why Giga should be lynched. This is absurd when we have oodles of evidence pointing against MNOWAX.
What has Giga done that is so damning? Yes, he said he was going to be slow at posting, and since he hasn't posted in a long while I can see why people want to punish him for going against his word. But what else is there? You can see from his posts that he's very concise in his thoughts and not afraid to speak his mind. Let me repost this again:
He says what's on his mind, and he says it with such certainty. Mafia don't make such strong commitments like that with their reads.
The Giga lynch is too easy
I want to remind people of the following post made last night, should be obvious why:
Furthermore, with so little time left in the day, anyone who is trying to deflect the vote away from Giga and MNO should be immediately scrutinized for trying to mislead the town (Murska).
Quote:
Here is the post again:
Giga did take a stance. At the beginning of the day Taylor was posting the most and people were suspicious of him for the reason of posting. If you read Taylor's posts, he didn't do anything that screams suspicion. Sure, he was a bit trolly in some posts, but he wasn't pushing an agenda or being incongruent. Now, this doesn't mean that Taylor isn't mafia, but the votes and suspicion against him at the beginning of the game should only be taken with a grain a salt.
Giga said this then said that Taylor hasn't done worth anything fingering suspicion over. Then Giga says that pizzaguy is town both on a gut read and because of his playstyle. Then Giga says that he has a town read on Binkies because he's putting himself out there and accusing a variety of people.
It's the fact that Giga is consistent and direct with his reads that makes him town. He's not a good lynch at all, nor is there a good case against him.
Giga did take a stance. At the beginning of the day Taylor was posting the most and people were suspicious of him for the reason of posting. If you read Taylor's posts, he didn't do anything that screams suspicion. Sure, he was a bit trolly in some posts, but he wasn't pushing an agenda or being incongruent. Now, this doesn't mean that Taylor isn't mafia, but the votes and suspicion against him at the beginning of the game should only be taken with a grain a salt.
Giga said this then said that Taylor hasn't done worth anything fingering suspicion over. Then Giga says that pizzaguy is town both on a gut read and because of his playstyle. Then Giga says that he has a town read on Binkies because he's putting himself out there and accusing a variety of people.
It's the fact that Giga is consistent and direct with his reads that makes him town. He's not a good lynch at all, nor is there a good case against him.
What has Giga done that is so damning? Yes, he said he was going to be slow at posting, and since he hasn't posted in a long while I can see why people want to punish him for going against his word. But what else is there? You can see from his posts that he's very concise in his thoughts and not afraid to speak his mind. Let me repost this again:
Quote:
Ok after reading everything here are my reads:
Taylor got a lot of attention early on and I think the reason for this was from past experience from other games, also because not many people were posting at that time that definitely contributed as well
I don't fos Taylor because of that and because most of Taylor's lines can be seen as null rather than something that definitely can scream town or scum.
Askthepizzaguy is ridiculously town. My gut tells me this and so does logic. He seems very open and unafraid, not hiding anything and I like his overall demeanor very much.
I also like Binkies for giving many reads early in the game. I feel like Mafia wouldn't attempt this from fear of getting challenged. But who knows, after all, this is a game of Mafia champions. My townread on Binkies isn't a strong one.
Taylor got a lot of attention early on and I think the reason for this was from past experience from other games, also because not many people were posting at that time that definitely contributed as well
I don't fos Taylor because of that and because most of Taylor's lines can be seen as null rather than something that definitely can scream town or scum.
Askthepizzaguy is ridiculously town. My gut tells me this and so does logic. He seems very open and unafraid, not hiding anything and I like his overall demeanor very much.
I also like Binkies for giving many reads early in the game. I feel like Mafia wouldn't attempt this from fear of getting challenged. But who knows, after all, this is a game of Mafia champions. My townread on Binkies isn't a strong one.
The Giga lynch is too easy
I want to remind people of the following post made last night, should be obvious why:
Quote:
Aw c'mon Nana, that's a low blow. 
The reason I can't explain it is because it's day 1 and too early to be outing the villagers. Of all people I thought you would understand that. I can't be giving info to the baddies. I already said too much and that's it so go dig somewhere else. 
The reason I can't explain it is because it's day 1 and too early to be outing the villagers. Of all people I thought you would understand that. I can't be giving info to the baddies. I already said too much and that's it so go dig somewhere else.
09-05-2013
, 04:30 PM
