Quote:
Originally Posted by Hince
So I should be relatively safe not filing at all? I quit my job from stress about 2 years ago, and have been living off poker winnings (~40K/year) the last 2 years. I don't really consider myself a professional, but I still don't want to go to jail or anything.
So you want us to tell you how likely it is you will get away with breaking the law? I'm not going to answer that.
It doesn't really matter whether
you consider yourself a pro. I matters whether your situation matches that of a person who has to pay taxes on poker earnings.
If you are telling us that you quit you job and played poker with the intent of living off your winnings, and that you have actually done so, then I think there is a pretty strong case that you fall into the class of people who are required to pay tax on your net poker winnings. Your facts may well demonstrate operating a business, an organized approach and a reasonable expectation of profit.
IANAL, though. Get yourself some real legal advice.
As for the general issue of whether the CRA goes after poker-playing tax cheaters, several people have posted here that the CRA do not have much of a history of doing so. However, like they say in the markets, past performance is not necessarily a reliable indication of future results. For example, the UIGEA was passed in 2006, but the DoJ only charged sites for the first time a month ago. Up until April 14, past performance indicated the DoJ was only going after processors. There are changes going on at the CRA WRT to compliance and enforcement. Will this affect Canadian poker players? I'm not in a position to say.