Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Political chat about the Politics Forum Political chat about the Politics Forum

01-21-2019 , 10:52 AM
^^ agreed
01-21-2019 , 10:54 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Original Position
Trumpism is a local variant on a global phenomenon, it is not unique to the US.
This is true and it’s also not a new phenomenon. What’s different about the US is, unlike just about every other western democracy, instead of a parliamentary system we have a lol constitutional republic. It’s worth noting that nearly every other constitutional republic created in modern times has slid into dictatorship, and that even when the US goes on “nation building” jaunts (Ie: Iraq), we don’t set up the new countries with the US system, we set them up with a parliamentary system.
01-21-2019 , 10:56 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Louis Cyphre
This might well be the biggest strength of the Politics forum. It's usually my first stop if something major happens. The regs will aggregate relevant articles, videos, photos, tweets, background information etc. from across the web. That's pretty neat.
Yup “the presidency of Donald j. Trump” thread is one of the greatest aggregators of relevant political news stories on the interwebs.
01-21-2019 , 10:58 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Louis Cyphre
This might well be the biggest strength of the Politics forum. It's usually my first stop if something major happens. The regs will aggregate relevant articles, videos, photos, tweets, background information etc. from across the web. That's pretty neat.
Too bad we only hear one side of the political spectrum about those articles, tweets, etc., hey?

It could almost be your perfect digest of the major news if you knew more about why something has happened.
01-21-2019 , 11:05 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Louis Cyphre
This might well be the biggest strength of the Politics forum. It's usually my first stop if something major happens. The regs will aggregate relevant articles, videos, photos, tweets, background information etc. from across the web. That's pretty neat.
Yup.. Its my 1st stop. Better than any news site ever.
01-21-2019 , 11:06 AM
It is still very good though. It would be tragic to lose.

I might never have even heard of someone like AOC if it wasn't for 2+2.
01-21-2019 , 11:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bundy5
Yeah but I wouldn't put Jman in the same class as Wookie. Jman is just wookie's student as Noodle was and that UK mod although he seems nearly as radical left as you can get sometimes.

This whole new regime pretty much starts and stops with Wookie and frankly I'd like to see him put an Ikes bet on to show he is serious in making it work.

The bet would be if Mason nukes the politics thread if the rehabilitation doesn't work then Wookie gets nuked too.
Quote:
Originally Posted by El Lobo Gordo
Mrwookie needs to make a graceful exit. Maybe Jman can be rehabilitated but I am not too hopeful.
Quote:
Originally Posted by jman220
Lol I am legit curious who you are now. Come on, tell us... I have some theories.

Edit: If I guess, will you tell me?
Quote:
Originally Posted by bundy5
Not sure you'll be able to keep a secret though
Perhaps a currently exiled poster who doesn’t know how to keep his accounts straight?

Last edited by will1530; 01-21-2019 at 11:12 AM.
01-21-2019 , 11:09 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ChrisV
There are two separate issues here. It's true that some conservative posters have been bullied and conservative opinions screamed at. raradevils is my pet example, there have been others.

Then there's the issue of people who are just bad posters, who annoy people for one reason or another. The arrogant drivel juan valdez vomited out upthread ably demonstrates why none of us are interested in having him in Politics threads.

There's big crossover between conservative posters and bad/annoying posters. In part this is because conservatism is sometimes (though far from always) associated with an inability to imagine what it's like to be other people. The main reason, though, is that you have to have a reason to want to post on a majority-liberal forum as a rabid conservative, and while there are plenty of exceptions, very frequently that reason is that you want to troll, or lecture people, or otherwise be annoying.

So while it's true that there is a problem with intolerance of conservatives and conservative opinion on 2+2, and a problem with too much tolerance of abusiveness from liberals, it doesn't follow that if you got exiled or banned from Politics that it's because you're conservative. It's because trying to discuss things with you proved to be an unpleasant experience for the rest of the forum.

this. politics moderators will stop banning bigots, they will only exile for the bolded above.
01-21-2019 , 11:11 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bundy5
Too bad we only hear one side of the political spectrum about those articles, tweets, etc., hey?

It could almost be your perfect digest of the major news if you knew more about why something has happened.
Since most of the acceptable right wing stuff is also posted, is it the lol u mad stuff underneath the post that got you lol mad or is it that most of the Facebook memes are not acceptable in the Politics thread? I'm
01-21-2019 , 11:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by will1530
Perhaps a currently exiled poster who doesn’t know how to keep his accounts straight?
I don't think anyone apart from you thinks it's me.
01-21-2019 , 11:30 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chezlaw
It is still very good though. It would be tragic to lose.

I might never have even heard of someone like AOC if it wasn't for 2+2.
Well since I'm exiled I only heard about AOC through the Ms OOT contest but you probably didn't want to hear that.
01-21-2019 , 11:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jman220
This is true and it’s also not a new phenomenon. What’s different about the US is, unlike just about every other western democracy, instead of a parliamentary system we have a lol constitutional republic. It’s worth noting that nearly every other constitutional republic created in modern times has slid into dictatorship, and that even when the US goes on “nation building” jaunts (Ie: Iraq), we don’t set up the new countries with the US system, we set them up with a parliamentary system.
Sure, I prefer parliamentary to presidential (what I assume you mean by "constitutional republic") systems of government. However, even parliamentary and semi-parliamentary systems are seeing this phenomenon in Western Europe - eg 5 Star and Northern League in Italy, AFD in Germany, Brexit in the UK, Le Pen in France.
01-21-2019 , 12:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by tomdemaine
Ultimately the reason you guys will never be satisfied despite getting pretty much everything you ever asked for (new mods, different rules, a whole forum just for you) is that you're not being honest with us or yourselves about what you really want. It's obviously not about civility (you guys are some of the worst in that regard) it's that you want your views to be respected. You want people to nod sagely along with your pronouncements about black fatherhood or whatever, maybe to disagree but ultimately to take your views seriously. As presumably well off white males you still get plenty of unearned deference in the real world because most of your interactions are likely in customer service situations but that same deference is missing here and it irks you utterly.

Basically, no amount of Mason finger wagging is going to make me respect your opinions. No matter the tameness or civility of my language my contempt for your views will always come across. You're never going to get the rousing round of applause you "deserve" for your bold contrarian opinions. It's long past time to move on.

And you want people to implement your beliefs and ideals into policies despite not being able to obtain the voting blocks and/or legislative power required by our system. Even if the left "we are good and just" personification was accurate, your inability to triumph over the evil deplorables of Trumpkinville in FL, WI,PA and OH have you demonizing the 50%ish percent of the voters who prevailed and elected Trump over your candidate. Instead of seeing value in trying to change voters minds, you write off a substantial portion of the population as stupid, racist sheeple who dont vote there own self interests, let alone vote for the greater good of mankind.

Hence, the echo chamber of leftist idealism of the 2+2 Political Forum shouting down any opposing viewpoints. You have easily created the safe space for your righteous ideals in an imaginary world where the moderators cherish the dog-piling and their ability to permaban the opposition. There is nothing wrong with this world, why change anything?

Well now it is changed because the owner says it must. No one cares about your respect or your contempt, except you. Its your own narcissism telling you "i am a better person than everyone because of my moral code and i should be able to insult and degrade the honor, intelligence and views of the oppositon with immunity" that will cause the demise of the Politics Forum.
01-21-2019 , 12:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bundy5
Agree with you about the tracking thread. It is a great idea in theory but that assumes level minded modding.

Everything thing including the responses to the ATF politics threads from Wookie and the other mods that have come and gone have been about trying to sweep things under the carpet.

I also had to have a laugh at Wookie's first response to the thread which was to ask for individual problem posts. If you can't see that there is a problem that Jman has somewhat acknowledged how can you be tasked with changing things?
bundy, heres the thing. if right wingers got "level minded modding" it would be a complete sht show. you guys wouldnt know what hit you.

the fact is, lefties get modded much tougher, and righties get more rope.
01-21-2019 , 12:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bundy5
Lol wookie trying to justify whenever he exiles someone.

Question wookie and this will go some way to determining if you are a proper person to be tasked with the turn around of the politics forum and I mean political views don't change overnight but what is your position on anyone who voted for Trump (may not be Trump supporters now or have changed to being Trump supporters from voting for HC or not voting at all).

Are they still ****ing ******s in your mind or do you think what they did was ok but you disagree with what they did?
I guess I can take this one. No, by and large, I don't consider Trump voters "****ing ******s." I don't now, and I didn't then.
01-21-2019 , 12:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jman220
Lol wookie’s student. I was a politics mod before Wookie ever was.
Hey man, you can't deny all those mod lessons I've been dishing to you over the last few days.
01-21-2019 , 12:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jjjou812
And you want people to implement your beliefs and ideals into policies despite not being able to obtain the voting blocks and/or legislative power required by our system. Even if the left "we are good and just" personification was accurate, your inability to triumph over the evil deplorables of Trumpkinville in FL, WI,PA and OH have you demonizing the 50%ish percent of the voters who prevailed and elected Trump over your candidate.
Not my candidate. Hillary was a centre-right corporate stooge. I would have voted for her if I could but it would not have been a happy vote.

Also

http://www.electproject.org/2016g

Quote:
Voting-Eligible Population (VEP)
230,931,921
Quote:
Trump 2016 : 62,984,828 votes
Looks like about 27% of voters by my calculation.

Quote:
Instead of seeing value in trying to change voters minds, you write off a substantial portion of the population as stupid, racist sheeple who dont vote there own self interests, let alone vote for the greater good of mankind.
Changing minds would be a fine goal if minds were changeable. If they haven't changed after the last 2 years of lol trump stumbling from one self created crisis to another then yeah, they're a write off. Luckily we don't need them to enact change we just need to energise like 1/10th of the 42+% of people who don't vote.

Quote:
Hence, the echo chamber of leftist idealism of the 2+2 Political Forum shouting down any opposing viewpoints. You have easily created the safe space for your righteous ideals in an imaginary world where the moderators cherish the dog-piling and their ability to permaban the opposition. There is nothing wrong with this world, why change anything?

Well now it is changed because the owner says it must. No one cares about your respect or your contempt, except you. Its your own narcissism telling you "i am a better person than everyone because of my moral code and i should be able to insult and degrade the honor, intelligence and views of the oppositon with immunity" that will cause the demise of the Politics Forum.
Pour one out for the politics forum but I very much doubt it will be my posting that will be responsible. I'm not that memorable.
01-21-2019 , 12:24 PM
Bundy, have you even considered taking up a hobby of some kind?
01-21-2019 , 12:31 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Original Position
Trumpism is a local variant on a global phenomenon, it is not unique to the US.
Right, but I was referring to broad historical trends and the comparison between the US and other countries in relative terms, not the rise of Le Pen and Brexit et al. I'm mainly talking about how Bernie was viewed as a radical leftist and the rest of the world said, uh, wat?
01-21-2019 , 12:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by will1530
Perhaps a currently exiled poster who doesn’t know how to keep his accounts straight?
Lol amazing

We probably should have realized that bundy and Gordo are the same guy.

I wonder how many other accounts he has?
01-21-2019 , 12:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jjjou812
And you want people to implement your beliefs and ideals into policies despite not being able to obtain the voting blocks and/or legislative power required by our system. Even if the left "we are good and just" personification was accurate, your inability to triumph over the evil deplorables of Trumpkinville in FL, WI,PA and OH have you demonizing the 50%ish percent of the voters who prevailed and elected Trump over your candidate. Instead of seeing value in trying to change voters minds, you write off a substantial portion of the population as stupid, racist sheeple who dont vote there own self interests, let alone vote for the greater good of mankind.

Hence, the echo chamber of leftist idealism of the 2+2 Political Forum shouting down any opposing viewpoints. You have easily created the safe space for your righteous ideals in an imaginary world where the moderators cherish the dog-piling and their ability to permaban the opposition. There is nothing wrong with this world, why change anything?

Well now it is changed because the owner says it must. No one cares about your respect or your contempt, except you. Its your own narcissism telling you "i am a better person than everyone because of my moral code and i should be able to insult and degrade the honor, intelligence and views of the oppositon with immunity" that will cause the demise of the Politics Forum.
I think you're supposed to put your thesis in the 1st paragraph and then provide support.
01-21-2019 , 12:43 PM
Writes two paragraphs whining about the lack of respect, then says nobody cares about the respect, then tops it off with another couple sentences whinig about the lack of respect.

Last edited by well named; 01-21-2019 at 12:51 PM. Reason: removed personal attack
01-21-2019 , 12:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jman220
See, this is why Clovis was definitely wrong about getting rid of these types of responses. This was ****ing hilarious.
This will be my last post on the topic, and it's directed I suppose more to the management and lurkers rather than the regulars and moderators, who have proven themselves unaffectable by reason ("inert" even). The quoted post was not "hilarious", it was stupid and pointless, and was made by a proudly rude and anti-intellectual poster with a history of clogging up threads with useless, content-free posts. He's certainly entitled to try to bring down the level of discussion as usual, but it's quickly followed by this moderator who gives a "thumbs up" to it--go ahead, that's what we like to see! The other moderators, wookie and goofyballer, behave the exact same way. They will readily ban an outsider who they disagree with for minutiae. They create a truly terrible forum, and wonder why they get negative feedback. My experience is the experience of all posters who wish to post freely and respectfully, and this is why they're all gone.
01-21-2019 , 12:54 PM
Since Mike Haven promised that almost anything would go in this thread, I'm not planning on moderating it heavily, although perhaps it would be better if I did. I dunno, it wasn't my idea.

But I will arbitrarily and capriciously moderate posts if I think they are too far over the line, just fwiw. Please direct all complaints to the ATF politics thread containment thread in French BBV.
01-21-2019 , 12:56 PM
6ix's u mad posts were "a little bit of fun" if you want "vigorous debate" feel free to respond to any of the multiple high content effort posts itt. If you're so precious that you can't take a bit of a ribbing without taking your ball then there's just not much hope for you.

      
m