Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Political chat about the Politics Forum Political chat about the Politics Forum

01-21-2019 , 09:09 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by El Lobo Gordo
Our neurology is such that we tend to mirror the behavior of the people around us. That is why when you hear a laugh track on a sitcom, it is more likely you will laugh at the gag. Laughing is an infectious emotion and so are anger and hate.

MrWookie and Jman220 cultivated a field of anger and hate, which gets mirrored by new arrivals. MrWookie and Jman220 then cull the new arrivals from the group if they are "deplorables". Seattlelou, Rara and the other posters touted as conservatives who never got banned might just come from the set of people who have fewer mirror neurons and so didn't troll back.
LOL, you are so bad at this Mr. December 2018 join date who can name all the old politics conservative regulars. Where does the brown trout sleep, amirite? In case anyone isn’t sure exactly what is going on here, here’s a timeline of totally not previously IP-banned Fat Wolf and his concern trolling:

1. El Lobo Gordo, joins the 2+2 forums in December of 2018, a good decade after the end of the poker boom, and makes a beeline for the politics forum. Again, this is a poster who decided to join a poker publishing website solely to head for it's politics forum.

2. Gordo starts making a series of classic troll posts that result in increased levels of warnings and infractions from myself and Wookie including several PM exchanges. They are exactly the types of posts that a troll knows will eventually lead to a banning.

3. Gordo is finally banned after numerous warnings. Right on cue, he immediately heads to About the Forums to start a classic "lets ***** about politics" thread and compare the politics subforum to a hate group. Again, this is a poster that has been here for a month who knows to immediately head to About the Forums.

4. Around the same time Gordo in some fashion contacts Mason Malmuth. How it is apparent to someone who is brand new, has no apparent poker background or any knowledge of 2+2 publishing beyond it's politics forum and has been posting for less than a month that the person to contact is Mason is a strange coincidence.

5. And finally, Gordo starts private messaging other previously exiled posters encouraging them to join in on the thread. These are posters who were exiled months or years ago, long before Gordo joined. There is no reasonable way that Gordo could have known who to contact, and yet he does.
01-21-2019 , 09:16 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bundy5
Yeah but I wouldn't put Jman in the same class as Wookie. Jman is just wookie's student as Noodle was and that UK mod although he seems nearly as radical left as you can get sometimes.

This whole new regime pretty much starts and stops with Wookie and frankly I'd like to see him put an Ikes bet on to show he is serious in making it work.

The bet would be if Mason nukes the politics thread if the rehabilitation doesn't work then Wookie gets nuked too.
Lol wookie’s student. I was a politics mod before Wookie ever was.
01-21-2019 , 09:17 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bundy5
Yeah hopefully this sort of posting is no longer allowed? Jman/Wookie agree?
This isn’t the politics forum, and I’m not a moderator here.

Regards,

—jman220
01-21-2019 , 09:17 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by El Lobo Gordo
Mrwookie needs to make a graceful exit. Maybe Jman can be rehabilitated but I am not too hopeful.
Lol I am legit curious who you are now. Come on, tell us... I have some theories.

Edit: If I guess, will you tell me?
01-21-2019 , 09:20 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chezlaw
On policy and who I support I'm definitely left rather than not center left.



I very much doubt I would vote for a blairite 'new labour' party if it's ever inflicted on us again.
Surprisingly quite centre or centre right that Blair was. Was it the Iraq War which really did it?
01-21-2019 , 09:21 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jman220
This isn’t the politics forum, and I’m not a moderator here.



Regards,



—jman220
But thoughts anyway?
01-21-2019 , 09:22 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jman220
Lol wookie’s student. I was a politics mod before Wookie ever was.
So you didn't learn anything from him in your absence?
01-21-2019 , 09:23 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jman220
Lol I am legit curious who you are now. Come on, tell us... I have some theories.

Edit: If I guess, will you tell me?
Not sure you'll be able to keep a secret though
01-21-2019 , 09:24 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by juan valdez
Pointing out that I disagree with the notion that the USA is systemically racist isn't evidence to the claim I am a "white supremacist". It doesn't even make any logical sense. Either the claim is right or wrong, attaching some sort of accusation of white supremacy to it is just weird and makes zero sense.

You getting all excited about it is par for the course. Did the roadrunner drop an anvil on your head?

It's actually not a lie. Wookies story and justification for my exile ITT is the first he's ever even attempted to explain himself. All of this is new info

Also you're not doing anyone any favors by spamming empty attacks and one liners. Admin is considering closing politics down in part from posters like yourself and your other account

Also to whoever posted Jman apologizing for flying off the handle. The point is to not fly off the handle, saying sorry doesn't undue flying off the handle. You're supposed to just not lose your mind in first place. That type of rage must be hard to contain though... that was something special
Lol Juan, criticizing my criticism of a literal nazi salute is not a good look for you and kind of gives way the ball game.
01-21-2019 , 09:26 AM
Ultimately the reason you guys will never be satisfied despite getting pretty much everything you ever asked for (new mods, different rules, a whole forum just for you) is that you're not being honest with us or yourselves about what you really want. It's obviously not about civility (you guys are some of the worst in that regard) it's that you want your views to be respected. You want people to nod sagely along with your pronouncements about black fatherhood or whatever, maybe to disagree but ultimately to take your views seriously. As presumably well off white males you still get plenty of unearned deference in the real world because most of your interactions are likely in customer service situations but that same deference is missing here and it irks you utterly.

Basically, no amount of Mason finger wagging is going to make me respect your opinions. No matter the tameness or civility of my language my contempt for your views will always come across. You're never going to get the rousing round of applause you "deserve" for your bold contrarian opinions. It's long past time to move on.
01-21-2019 , 09:33 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by commas,are,funny
As a man of reason and logic, I was drawn to poker and this site, two venues where logic and unbiased thinking reigned. I did extremely well as a result, to the tune of millions of dollars in net winnings. Like many, I ventured off into other forums, including the politics forum, which had truly interesting ideas being discussed from all political bents. For example, I never would have known about "AC" had it not been for this place, and though in the end AC proved flawed and unreasonable, it was a valuable experience being able to discuss its merits. The same was true for various other political issues--economics, the role of government, national security, the surveillance state, and so on. You could get an honest discussion with people who see things differently, and that was honestly an extremely valuable experience in helping me shape my understanding of the world during my early adult years. Far-left posters weren't over-represented at the time; if anything I remember thinking they were under-represented.

The politics forum has been truly terrible for close to four years now. Absolutely none of the above occurs any longer. The forum is now and has been a one-way street of far-left liberals, and for the most part of particularly the last three years there has been no worthwhile discussion of the sort that used to occur.

The reason for this is clear: the moderation is completely biased to the same political stripe that dominates the forum. They are unable to moderate the forum in a way that would be beneficial to everyone, rather than just those of their political affiliation. The problem will not get better until this changes.

Why do I care? Am I a snowflake? No, I clearly care much less than the politics regulars who have tens of thousands of posts and spend hundreds of hours a month there. I'm speaking up as a voice from the past--someone who enjoyed this place and remembers what it used to be like, but like hundreds or perhaps thousands of former posters I've been driven away.

I shared some of my observations in Mason's thread, and I did so reasonably and honestly. I was banned for this post, for three days:

https://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/s...&postcount=134

Originally I had said "mentally inert", meaning unchangeable, to describe the experience of arguing with the current coterie of politics regulars, but thought about it and rephrased the term to "mentally inflexible", to more clearly capture the sense I meant to convey. Result? A three-day ban. A three-day ban for "mentally inert", which was directed in the abstract and not at any particular poster, and had already been self-edited. Ask yourself honestly if this is worthy of such a long ban without warning, and if this treatment would have been applied to a typical plainly left-wing politics poster. This is a microcosm experience of anyone not fitting the narrow mold of allowable opinions in the politics forum today.

My message is simple: you cannot have a functioning forum with mutual respect when the moderators are so heavily biased politically and personally. You will get exactly what you get: a place that is comfortable for people of the exact same political leanings, and no one else, where moderation is applied capriciously and unfairly. It hurts my logical reasoning faculties to see people scratch their heads about why the forum is so terrible, and not address this clear elephant in the room.
lol u mad
01-21-2019 , 09:34 AM
lol he mad
01-21-2019 , 09:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 6ix
lol u mad
or this. ^
01-21-2019 , 09:36 AM
lol we all mad for reading it
01-21-2019 , 09:37 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by tomdemaine
Ultimately the reason you guys will never be satisfied despite getting pretty much everything you ever asked for (new mods, different rules, a whole forum just for you) is that you're not being honest with us or yourselves about what you really want. It's obviously not about civility (you guys are some of the worst in that regard) it's that you want your views to be respected. You want people to nod sagely along with your pronouncements about black fatherhood or whatever, maybe to disagree but ultimately to take your views seriously. As presumably well off white males you still get plenty of unearned deference in the real world because most of your interactions are likely in customer service situations but that same deference is missing here and it irks you utterly.

Basically, no amount of Mason finger wagging is going to make me respect your opinions. No matter the tameness or civility of my language my contempt for your views will always come across. You're never going to get the rousing round of applause you "deserve" for your bold contrarian opinions. It's long past time to move on.
I can confirm that I want civil debate along side it being respectful (which are basically the same thing) but I want tolerate debate too.

I don't want it that people with opposing views can be shouted down with little to no substantive argument by posters who hold the majority view in the forums.

Not sure this is asking for much is it?

And btw this whole idea of banning new accounts that are believed to be gimmicks set up by existing members to troll the majority view is farcical as the only way things are going to change is for new members to be let in. I'm sure that it is going to take quite a bit of time for members that had left politics for its toxic posting environment to be confident that things have actually changed.
01-21-2019 , 09:44 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by tomdemaine
Ultimately the reason you guys will never be satisfied despite getting pretty much everything you ever asked for (new mods, different rules, a whole forum just for you) is that you're not being honest with us or yourselves about what you really want. It's obviously not about civility (you guys are some of the worst in that regard) it's that you want your views to be respected. You want people to nod sagely along with your pronouncements about black fatherhood or whatever, maybe to disagree but ultimately to take your views seriously. As presumably well off white males you still get plenty of unearned deference in the real world because most of your interactions are likely in customer service situations but that same deference is missing here and it irks you utterly.

Basically, no amount of Mason finger wagging is going to make me respect your opinions. No matter the tameness or civility of my language my contempt for your views will always come across. You're never going to get the rousing round of applause you "deserve" for your bold contrarian opinions. It's long past time to move on.
It's this, and ultimately why the 'attack the idea, not the poster' rule and other derivations will always be an obfuscation. In other words, nobody actually give a **** about personal attacks. They're easily brushed off. But attacking the ideas is a bridge too far, because their ideas are their children, their precious little babies. And just to solidify the analogy a bit, the parents here can attest that it'd be much more disturbing to see their child called a 'dumb mother****er' or some such than it would be for they themselves.
01-21-2019 , 09:45 AM
Quote:
Not sure this is asking for much is it?
Yeah, it is. It assumes that you are owed interaction on your terms regardless of the content of your posts.
01-21-2019 , 09:55 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bundy5
But thoughts anyway?
I don’t comment on other moderator’s decisions outside of my forum.

Regards,

—jman220
01-21-2019 , 09:57 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 6ix
lol he mad
See, this is why Clovis was definitely wrong about getting rid of these types of responses. This was ****ing hilarious.
01-21-2019 , 09:58 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bundy5
Surprisingly quite centre or centre right that Blair was. Was it the Iraq War which really did it?
No, from the very beginning. I was a very reluctant voter for him first time but did because I was just about swayed by the arguments against refusing to. I think I got that wrong.

The Iraq war was in a different league. I like to see him on trial over some of that.
01-21-2019 , 10:01 AM
Like, I did that same 'lol u mad/lol he mad' bit with Commas in the stickied P thread and he got more mad, and then Jman deleted the whole mess, which was a wise modding decision and why he gets paid the big bux.

But, like, where do you even begin with a post like that? You don't need to be a political scientist or well read (hell, some of my favorite observations are from non-well read but very clever and thoughtful people) to post in politics. The bar is really low and should be, but there are at least a dozen tells in that post alone that show he doesn't have a clue as to what he's talking about. Not that he has the 'bad' or 'wrong' politics, but that he doesn't grasp fundamental definitions and terms.

Even that isn't a problem (though I personally don't have the patience anymore to politely explain things) by itself but the deadly duo is being stone ignorant whilst also be brazenly self-assured about your non-ignorance. And again, I'm not talking about the beliefs in concepts, I'm talking about the concepts themselves. Like, just broadly explaining what the axes on the political compass mean or similar things.

TL;DR - It's ****ing disturbing that a bunch of people seem to sincerely believe Hillary supporters are the far fringe left.

Last edited by 6ix; 01-21-2019 at 10:09 AM.
01-21-2019 , 10:03 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by tomdemaine
Yeah, it is. It assumes that you are owed interaction on your terms regardless of the content of your posts.
Perhaps ignore is a better option for you then
01-21-2019 , 10:05 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jman220
See, this is why Clovis was definitely wrong about getting rid of these types of responses. This was ****ing hilarious.
Heh, like I just said I do approve of your decision to delete it from the stickied thread though, to keep the tone SRS BIZ.

But I saw Commas post another screed and thought, hey, don't let a good bit go to waste.
01-21-2019 , 10:29 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 6ix
Sorry pull the band aid off like that for any non-politics-posting-or-reading trump voters and supporters reading this thread but there it is. If USA#1 was a big boy country like other western nations the Dem primary would've been the general election. And as much as you might imagine your fellow Americans don't respect you for it, the citizens of those western nations respect you far, far less.
Trumpism is a local variant on a global phenomenon, it is not unique to the US.
01-21-2019 , 10:50 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jalfrezi
This.

And as the moderation has done a good job of removing posters who repeatedly post lies in place of reasoned and supportable arguments (like the poster who's dominated this thread) it's mainly easy to read for a digest of current events.

This might well be the biggest strength of the Politics forum. It's usually my first stop if something major happens. The regs will aggregate relevant articles, videos, photos, tweets, background information etc. from across the web. That's pretty neat.

      
m