I enjoyed that.
Quote:
Originally Posted by MrWookie
Oh ok. Let's take a look at what complexity and nuance is being defended with the above:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zeno
Female gypsies are by definition whores, right?
Right.
I mean, this perfectly encapsulates what's wrong with this thread, as spank is pointing out. You and dereds are taking him completely out of context to slur his character. Read the whole thing rather than Dered's snippet:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zeno
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
Yeah, I'm in Eastern Europe right now - all the insults involve one or another of your relatives being either a whore or a gypsy. But in American parlance among a certain demographic I assume it is a positive. Is the whore greater than the sum of its parts though? That's the real question.
Also, lol, trust an academic to be following the orthodoxy of being positive toward sex work. That's like one of the ten commandments of being a refined human being in academic circles. Respect for whores.
My bold.
Female gypsies by definition are whores, right.
This also reminds me of a conversation I had years ago with a scientist from Romania that I met at a conference (he was brilliant and knew 7 languages). He went into a tirade against the vile gypsies that plagued Romania (and Hungry). He thought I was ignorant and stupid for my sympathies for the Roma. It was an interesting discussion/argument that he won, hands down. He did me a great favor and reinforced the budding notion I was beginning to understand - that it is best to actually know something of what one is discussing to have a meaningful/fruitful debate.
In the blue he's talking about Eastern European cultural attitudes to gypsies, not himself claiming they they are all whores. It's a wry observation about attitudes in Eastern Europe, not a slur on gypsies. He says himself in the next bit he knows nothing about them.
This is like defending someone from heresy from narrow minded busybody religious nuts - every utterance that doesn't precisely follow careful orthodoxy is wrong and evil, bad faith is always assumed. It's ridiculous and toxic.
And yeah I'm done commenting but if people keep replying to me...
Last edited by ToothSayer; 11-07-2017 at 02:13 PM.