I have little knowledge of where you are coming from, so I'm not entirely sure how to respond, or what tone to take to help make things clearer.
Quote:
Originally Posted by lastcardcharlie
Without wishing to be rude, I think these examples might say more about you than they do me. I am not by nature promiscuous, and am compulsively punctual. I also do not consider acting with respect at a religious ceremony as pretending to be religious.
"Without wishing to be rude"?!? That is one of the very common lies people tell. What it means is, "I am being rude because I disapprove and want to distance myself from you, but I'd like you to pretend that you are not offended." It is just a more elegantly worded "just saying" or "no offense, but."
http://www.npr.org/2010/12/18/132160...pid-just-sayin
(I wasn't offended, by the way. My grandma wanted my to be a gigolo, I work from home, etc.)
Anyway, the examples were given as easy-to-understand common examples and following up on them. I'm sure that you have sufficient imagination to internally supply examples from yourself and those around you:
Someone who is happily promiscuous and knows that grandma doesn't like promiscuity = Someone who is happily XXXXXX and knows that YYYYYY doesn't like XXXXXX.
I will take issue with your "I also do not consider" part. You are absolutely misrepresenting yourself in the situation.
Quote:
I said I accepted the likelihood of something. Part of me (probably some juvenile hangover part) does not accept that thing. I worded it cautiously enough for it not to be dishonest, I think.
You worded it quite politely, which is a social nicety that manipulates my feelings toward wanting to explain things nicely and as well as possible. I do have very strong doubts that you think your "naïve and self-defeating view" (as you put it) is incorrect, but I can tell that you'd like to have an explanation.
Quote:
An example of when I am dishonest is when people ask me how I am, just so as not to be too much of a weirdo.
[mocked horror voice]No offense, but you misrepresent yourself as a non-weirdo when you are a weirdo?!? Most people don't want to have to be associated with weirdos, so your lie is certainly a horrible thing to foist upon them. Without wishing to be rude, I bet that you are the type of horribly deceitful person who even stands up and sits down during the funeral, and probably even says "amen" at the appropriate times![/voice]
Quote:
If dishonesty is so commonplace and necessary for the functioning of society, as you claim, then why do we have these repercussions?
Forget the "society" part. Really, other than some governmental regulations regarding some very harmful or particularly annoying sorts of lying, society has nothing to do with it.
Lying is something that is usually done on a more personal level. You have already shown that some deceitful behavior is acceptable because it is reasonable. We generally only get upset about behavior when we can't say "yeah, I'd probably do that too."