Quote:
Originally Posted by Zeno
Civilization is only a thin veneer. Read Thucydides. Plato thought he could cure the veneer into something solid and lasting. It is an interesting read to the point of silliness.
Civilization is all we have and the reason in the end we will have everything, most important of all wisdom, not just that which is based on suffering but on life long effort to understand the world through the one and only romantic epic, the enterprise of discovery that is the study of natural law. You cannot have science or math without civilization.
I remember Thucydides the realist, the father of scientific history, my fellow Athenian from the distant past. 25 centuries separate us. He lived in interesting times witnessing the glory and defeat of Athens. Athens seemingly never recovered from that. However this play is not over yet because i recall what Athens gave to my childhood and it is precious. Some forms of victory are possible much later than one could ever imagine. But do not ask a cynic to argue that.
I remember his objective nature, his attention to detail and the study of the human condition but also an ever present lack of optimism. I salute his scientific approach to history. But in the end in my opinion he let the time he lived in and things that happened to him to mark his viewpoint with cynicism. A plague and an irrational war after the most glorious of times will do that to a man. Witnessing that democracy needs wise leaders but leaders can also be dangerous to democracy as others noted, however true must not be enough to turn you into a cynic about democracy itself. Ultimately the strength of democracy is not just its leaders but the wisdom of the public that selects them. To think that the public can not improve and become wiser is a cynical position.
This is a special man that aims to teach us about the human nature. I cannot compare our time with his. He did witness suffering and failure and his greatest gift is to make us remember how all can go wrong so easily when fear and not reason dictates choices. A man that doesnt have science and math at his core but only in his peripheral education will forget optimism though in his work.
The ultimate gift of civilization is science. Science teaches you more than everything to not be afraid of darkness, to pursue against odds the impossible, to never feel defeated by a problem as long as you still care to bring clarity.
I will combine Archimedes and Thucydides, Alexander the great and Aristotle among many others. I will observe all and see what each teaches us about the human condition. In the end you have no choice but to want to be objective, a permanent student of natural law but also an unchained optimist with relentless brilliance against all odds. Dare to dream big and embrace what is possible, synthesis, resent cynicism but learn from suffering and failure, never allowing it to lead you to the conclusion this, to be here witnessing all, is anything but a giant miracle.
Instead i will paraphrase the line from a recently lost great one, Freeman Dyson, " This is the most interesting of all worlds and it is our purpose to make it so."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thucydides
Last edited by masque de Z; 03-19-2020 at 09:28 AM.