Quote:
Originally Posted by Howard Treesong
Nick Bostrom, no tyrant himself, makes a case that a tyrant may be required to save the human race. I don’t know that I accept his premises, but they seem not entirely implausible. I’ll see if I can find a link when I’m out of this ridiculous traffic jam I’m in.
He may think a dictator that is super wise or a philosopher king equivalent group of people.
But i think that we do not have that many great examples in history and the word is reserved for abusive leaders that torment their people and exploit power leaving behind countless victims like Genghis khan or at best Julius Caesar (with good times) or modern monsters like Hitler, Stalin and Mao. But of course even Mussolini or in recent decades Ceaușescu, Qaddafi, Saddam, the North korean family line since the war etc. These were all killers of many and brutal characters. Even great ones like Alexander the great had their dark hours.
I believe its possible to have a charismatic ethical leader for life that simply gets what is good for all and what needs to be done and motivates manipulatively the masses in directions that are ultimately good for them and who knows how to pick up the right people to help him. However i prefer a system that has many leaders that earn it by effort and skill and supported by a core democracy that makes it possible for everyone to rise to influence on merit and for the voice of the people on many issues related to their daily experience to always be heard and influence direction. However a correct direction may need indeed specialists and not the will of the masses in everything until we arrive at the point the masses are well educated and participate with care for citizenship.
I am not against a system that until then every person has different voting weight based on past record and skill or education or service to society.
I believe a poor education base allows the democracy to become a joke in the hands of powerful influence centers and manipulative charlatan politicians. So democracy without care for honest citizenship leads to tyranny of the idiot majority.
Last edited by masque de Z; 04-02-2019 at 02:59 AM.