Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time?

01-28-2018 , 04:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cranberry Tea
I don't know, the WWE seems to do a decent job of putting on a show without having performers who get into trouble outside the ring.
Three just in the last few weeks or so.
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-28-2018 , 04:54 PM
putting this on in late jan seems mental. dunno about u lot but at the end of an nfl season i've had my fill. then in april or so im well up for the next season to start

put it on in spring/early summer. ok u gotta compete with baseball but i doubt many 88 year olds will be interested in the xfl anyway
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-28-2018 , 05:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kingweed
The gif that display on Tapatalk make the game look fantastic. I’d watch. Looks good.
Okay, so I managed to find it was LFL. That looks awesome.

WTF is XFL?
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-28-2018 , 05:59 PM
A combination of NFL and WWE basically
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-28-2018 , 06:24 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cranberry Tea
To be honest, I like the idea of a sports league with the swagger and over-the-top showmanship of the WWE. Putting the emphasis on the quality of the TV product, keeping games reasonably short, kicking out players that do stupid **** off the field, all decent ideas. Problem is football just seems a sport that's already saturated its market and has huge structural problems with concussions and injuries. idk, maybe start up an Xtreme rugby league or bring back American Gladiator or something.
See, I think "kicking out players that do stupid ****" kind of kills the possibility for maximum swagger and showmanship.

I mean the initial description of the league makes it sound like it's basically for fans who thought Tim Tebow got a raw deal from the NFL for being too Christian.
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-28-2018 , 11:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by nath
See, I think "kicking out players that do stupid ****" kind of kills the possibility for maximum swagger and showmanship.
I don't follow the WWE at all, so idk but it seems like they have a lot of guys like The Rock and John Cena who put on a good show but also maintain a squeaky-clean, family-friendly vibe outside the ring. Of course, that's easier to do when the drama is pre-scripted, but then that's the central conceit of a WWE-style sports league: that it would sacrifice authenticity and athleticism in exchange for showmanship and goofy characters. I'm basically imagining a league where RGIII cuts a pre-game promo and Ochocino has a fun new 2-minute long touchdown celebration every game.
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-29-2018 , 02:41 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by royalblue
A combination of NFL and WWE basically
That was the old iteration of the XFL. The new one seems like a combination of NFL and church.
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-29-2018 , 04:27 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by royalblue
A combination of NFL and WWE basically


Whose the target audience?

WWE is for under 12s and NFL is for all ages.

Is the concept going to be fake fighting in between a match? If so it sounds a lot of rubbish. A combo of UFC and NFL sounds like a good idea.
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-29-2018 , 08:47 AM
I know LOL Peter King but he brought up a good point this morning. He said back when the XFL came out, McMahon cut ties as soon as ratings went down after a few months. Said in order for this to have any shot, he needs to get someone to cough up $500 million and have a 3 year deal. Otherwise, no one will take it seriously.
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-29-2018 , 10:20 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kingweed
Whose the target audience?
Rednecks
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-29-2018 , 10:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kingweed
Whose the target audience?
fantasy football degens
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-29-2018 , 12:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by All-inMcLovin
I would totally watch a rebooted American Gladiators.
Agreed. This is totally a 'why not both' situation.

Quote:
Originally Posted by BOIDS
putting this on in late jan seems mental. dunno about u lot but at the end of an nfl season i've had my fill. then in april or so im well up for the next season to start

put it on in spring/early summer. ok u gotta compete with baseball but i doubt many 88 year olds will be interested in the xfl anyway
Yeah, not only that but the drop from the very best NFL teams playing at their peaks in the late playoffs/superbowl to XFL will be very jarring. They should wait a couple of months until we start Jonesing for footbaw
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-29-2018 , 01:45 PM
I think it could be interesting as sort of a testing ground for different strategies. Don't just have the same dip**** good ol' boy coaches who believe in "trusting the defense" and all that BS.

Maybe have a coach who runs the triple option. Hire that coach who always goes for it on 4th down. Coaches who always go for 2. Some of the ideas could carry over into the NFL and improve that product as well.
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-29-2018 , 01:48 PM
They rebooted American Gladiators recently, it was awful and no one watched it.
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-29-2018 , 02:48 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fossilkid93
I think it could be interesting as sort of a testing ground for different strategies. Don't just have the same dip**** good ol' boy coaches who believe in "trusting the defense" and all that BS.

Maybe have a coach who runs the triple option. Hire that coach who always goes for it on 4th down. Coaches who always go for 2. Some of the ideas could carry over into the NFL and improve that product as well.
You could do something like one team can never punt. Another team never kicks FG's. Make up like 10 quirky rules and have the head coaches randomly pick one out of a hat before kickoff. I want chaos!
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-29-2018 , 04:46 PM
I like the idea of rule changes. My suggestions:

-2 points for all FGs (instead of 3 to encourage teams to go for it more).
-Turn the 2 pt conversion into the 3 pt conversion (goal to goal plays are exciting so encourage more of them).
-Figure out a way to use soccer's goal line technology at the goal line & for first downs (no more of this guessing ****).
-Loosen up the the illegal formation penalty to add some offensive creativity.
-Instead of a coin toss to decide who gets possession at the start of the game, halftime and OT you do a jump ball with 11 on both teams on the field and whoever recovers the ball can advance it like a kickoff and once they are downed they start the drive there.
-If you punt the ball on 4th down you have to play with one less player on the field that play (encourages teams to go for it).
-Teams get unlimited challenges and can challenge anything but once you get two wrong you don't have any more challenges. Someone in the booth reviews the play and makes the call and they have a max of 30 seconds to make a decision.
-On a kickoff the receiving teams starts a drive at the 25 if the kick goes in the endzone (or through it) - except if it goes through the up-rights then they only get it to the 20.
-Get rid of the rule that if you fumble into the end zone it is a touch-back for defense.
-Make defensive pass interference a max of a 25 yard gain.
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-29-2018 , 09:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SuperUberBob
Apparently they won't allow anybody in the league who has a criminal record.

Translation:

kind of racist to say black people are criminals isn't it? You know white people get arrested too.
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-29-2018 , 09:50 PM
XFL would be better served having the season as the same time as the NFL, just run the games in the morning on Sunday. People are already in football mode. Come SB, people are footballed out, but I think Sunday morning could actually work for them.
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-29-2018 , 11:07 PM
Allow six kicks per team per game. A kick is defined as a punt, FG or extra point
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-29-2018 , 11:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by EddyB66
kind of racist to say black people are criminals isn't it? You know white people get arrested too.
White trash football fans (Vince McManon's target audience) that refuse to watch the NFL because of black players kneeling definitely think of white people when you ask them to picture someone in jail.
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-30-2018 , 12:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Matty Lice
White trash football fans (Vince McManon's target audience) that refuse to watch the NFL because of black players kneeling definitely think of white people when you ask them to picture someone in jail.
I thought my message was obvious but that's two people who didn't fully understand it.

To be fair, one was bahbahmickey and his response was to try and rat me to the mods or some **** like that because calling out his racism triggered him.
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-30-2018 , 12:18 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Matty Lice
White trash football fans (Vince McManon's target audience) that refuse to watch the NFL because of black players kneeling definitely think of white people when you ask them to picture someone in jail.
you think that's why people refuse to watch? I stopped watching this year because I am sick of not knowing what a catch is, the referees blowing the whistle when a fumble is being returned, replays taking forever, and the games taking 3.5 hours to play. If ever there was a time for somebody to take a shot at the NFL, now is the time.
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-30-2018 , 12:22 AM
So this league is going to be more extreme? then they will need a way to coax players to leave the nfl. No player is going to play in a more extreme league for less money. If they get Johnny Football that could be an attraction at least for the first season. Good luck with the CTE issue, I hope Vince has a plan for it.

Vince is notoriously ruthless. Don't be surprised if he tries to steal talent from NFL whether it be announcers, players or coaches.
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-30-2018 , 12:36 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SuperUberBob
I thought my message was obvious but that's two people who didn't fully understand it.

To be fair, one was bahbahmickey and his response was to try and rat me to the mods or some **** like that because calling out his racism triggered him.
I get that you think some people stopped watching the NFL because of players kneeling. I just didn't think that was a good enough excuse to post what you posted. Even if you weren't trying to be racist that post should be removed - that is the only reason I said anything.

Nobody said anything about me before I posted that so I'm not sure why you think I said something because I was wrongly accused of being a racist after I posted that.

Usually posters are quick to call out a post they perceive as racist - no matter who the poster is. Even if it was tongue in check I'm shocked more people haven't said something to be honest.

Back on topic: I'd be shocked if this league lasts 3 years. Long live the NFL.
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote
01-30-2018 , 08:49 AM
NFL is such a garbage product that it really should not be that hard to make a product so much better that it could take over someday.
Was the XFL just an idea ahead of its time? Quote

      
m