Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread
View Poll Results: GOAT?
labron
184 30.31%
MJ (Michael or Maple)
325 53.54%
Therapist
8 1.32%
George Mikan
5 0.82%
Shaq Attaq
21 3.46%
Wilt the Stilt (100 pts yo)
14 2.31%
Timmy "Big Fundamentals" Duncan
20 3.29%
"Roger Murdock"
3 0.49%
Enchanted AIDS Wang (er, HIV+?)
9 1.48%
Larry Legend (+ HM to Bill Russell's laugh)
18 2.97%

03-10-2024 , 12:50 AM
D'Angelo Russell is a better scorer, passer and clutch player than Pippen, while AD is a superior defender and offensive player than Pippen - Jordan would win 70 games and the title every year with this cast, yet Lebron was swept in 2023 and is barely over .500 this year

Age isn't an excuse because Lebron had similar underachievement with other casts such as 1 sixty-win season with super-teams from 2011-2017 (and perennial underdog status in the Finals), or 5 seasons with 2 all-star teammates (only 2 titles in those years), or preseason favorites for 7 years (2011-2016 and 2021) but only 4 titles in those years.. There were upset losses, 4-0 sweep losses, record losses, 1st Round losses, 2nd Round loss, lottery or getting locked up in 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2014, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2021, 2022, and 2023

so basically every year of his career was crappy or outright embarrassing.

Last edited by fallguy; 03-10-2024 at 12:56 AM.
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 12:51 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SABR42
You're the one who claims LeBron is worse than Durant. No one needs to take anything you write seriously.

wouldn't take labald for free
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 01:01 AM
Dlo is garbage and no Jordan would not win 70 games with the Lakers roster

You slander Pippen constantly to boost Jordan
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 01:28 AM
It's the same old schtick.

Jordan carried a roster of bums, yet somehow they still won when Jordan had his worst series and shot 42% for the series.

Make it make sense.
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 01:43 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheGramuel
Trying to argue that 20% of a metric isn't 25% more than 16% of that metric is real next level stuff.

Yeah in poker if you had 16% equity and then you have 20% your equity did increase by 4% in absolute terms, 25% more relative to what you had before.
Of course and calling one hand over the other in value is a 4% mistake not a 25% ffs …

If me and bottom run an exam he gets 16 wrong on 100 and I got 20 wrong on 100 it would be incredibly stupid to say he beats me by 25% …
Especially on something I did on the fly just to make a general point

Anyway all this focusing just to try to burry the real point on how really Lebron miss so much regular season game past 34 and still call him an amazing steal man …..

https://fadeawayworld.net/numbers-of...-last-10-years
Quote:
Michael Jordan is one of those players from the “old school” era that made it a habit to play in every game. Jordan played in all 82 games nine times and didn’t miss a game from March 1995 to June 1998. Even at 40 years old, Jordan played all 82 games and played nearly 37 minutes a night. The all-time leader in assists, John Stockton, played in 82 games 16 times in his career. These superstars headlined the 80s and 90s. It might feel like that time was not far back, but we are pushing 30 years from that time. The game is changing whether you like it or not.
It’s like for couple of years the average is like 10 players in the entire nba that plays all games ….

Weak sauce era

https://www.reddit.com/r/nba/comment..._in_792_games/
Quote:
The average all-star in 2003 played in 79.2 games per season. 20 years later in 2023 the average all-star plays in 64.4 games per season.

Last edited by Montrealcorp; 03-10-2024 at 01:57 AM.
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 01:59 AM
The percentage argument in this thread might be my favorite yet.
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 02:01 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SABR42
4% as an increase over 16% is 25%, congrats, now you're getting it.

That's your margin of error.
You must lost a ton of money playing poker if u thought like that …..
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 02:03 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fidstar-poker
The percentage argument in this thread might be my favorite yet.
I hate it.
It’s a stupid talking point a benign on the fly made argument to prove a point where I knew it wasn’t precise but good enough to provide a big picture of what was going on game missing .
A clear down trend …
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 02:04 AM
So why are you replying? Let it die.
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 02:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
You must lost a ton of money playing poker if u thought like that …..
I'm up 7 figures from poker lifetime. Wanna try again?

You love to dig a hole for yourself don't you?
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 02:16 AM
I’m glad u think u beat someone by 25% when u have an exam of 84% while the other scored 80% shrug .

And it makes a lot of sense now you think LeBron his made of steal to me .
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 02:28 AM
You try to change the topic every time you say something idiotic and get shut down. It's hilarious. How do you manage any kind of real life relationship with that level of stubbornness?

Last edited by SABR42; 03-10-2024 at 02:46 AM.
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 03:15 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fallguy
First of all, who cares about defensive versatility if it's bad defense and the defense isn't elite - Lebron hasn't been an elite defender in his 30's (no all-defense in his 30's).. So who cares about a bad defender that is supposedly "versatile".. This doesn't compare to a DPOY-level defender like Hakeem or MJ that isn't as "versatile" (even though they both are anyway).. It's more valuable for jordan to lock up 3 positions than for Lebron to play bad defense on 5.
I agree.
I would rather have a A+ perimeter defender like mj and an other A+ for the inside instead of 2 B defender guys doing all 5 .
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 04:08 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SABR42
You try to change the topic every time you say something idiotic and get shut down. It's hilarious. How do you manage any kind of real life relationship with that level of stubbornness?
i love your way with people, insulting, trying to attack my character and my personal life many times while i didnt once and just trying to have just a conversation with you.

you and candybar fit great together...

But its ok i see you enjoying greatly and that is whats important.
so keep at it.
i can take it, your the man!
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 04:28 AM
I never attacked your character, only your inability to do math, and unwillingness to admit a simple mistake.

You could have ended this like 30 posts ago (as I said many times, just take an L when you're wrong) but you kept doubling down and tripling down on how your flawed math was a good approximation. It's honestly not a big deal to make a simple mistake, it's how you deal with it that reveals the kind of person you are. In this case, it shows that you cannot argue in good faith because when someone points out that you made a clear math error you can't even admit as much.

Then you tried to say that I must be a losing poker player and when that backfired you immediately abandoned ship and now just cry that I'm being mean to you. Yeah whatever lol.
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 04:31 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by candybar
Lebron missing a quarter of the games at an age where MJ literally didn't play any games at all isn't exactly a win for MJ.



MJ missed over a quarter of his team's games in 01-02 so that means he must have been all-NBA right?
That isn’t the argument .
Your argument says mj couldn’t play at LeBron level at 35-36-37-38.
Well like I said previously , it’s an incredible dive in skill and endurance the 12 month between 34-35 and 35-36 to claim mj couldn’t be all-nba .
Especially if he would start to miss 25% of game for resting….

Let’s see Lebron and his greatness because he start at 18 (well mostly 19 but w.e)
First season he miss the playoffs while playing at 21-5-6 ( I rounded up to help his stats) transforming a team from 17-65 to a record of 35-47.
Finish mvp 9 o0 .
not bad right ?

Second season Lebron miss again the playoffs while running at 27-7-7 (career average ) with a 42-40 team .
His all-nba ! Finish mvp 6 with those numbers !

That is just 2 season after mj retired , meaning same competition .

bolded part
So candybar opinion mj sucked and couldn’t be all-nba when he return right ?
lets use IF like candybar love to use....
Without any resting MJ first season return in 2002 , before the injury mj was at 25-6-5 playing all 46 games !

In his last 20 games up to the injury MJ averaged
27- 6.- 5 on 44%

In his last 10 games up to the injury MJ averaged
29 - 6.- 6 on 47%

before the Injury (46 games) .
That means he got better as the season progress which is normal .
He transform a team from 19-63 to a 26-20 team before the injury on its way to the playoffs .

Tell me candy bar , 20 games before the injury does that look like the stats of a young LeBron james being second all-nba in his second season despite his team missing the play off vs similar competition ?

Btw 46 games is just 10-15 games below many latest season where LeBron played 55 games 56 games at the same age where everyone praise his goatness with all-nba level right ?
But mj didn’t take time off tho …..

But yeah mj played with injury and couldn’t make his team wins anymore but he didn’t quit and still played 60 games trying to win injured ….and reducing his stats since it’s so important to you …


Now imagine if mj would have take a bit easier with some rest like lebron act today in an easier era on top of that !

His last season mj ran at 20-6-3 injured leading his team to a 37-45 season .
But mj sucked in your opinion that year and when I compared Lebron first season ( the season right after vs similar competition),
Lebron is great and no one says Lebron sucks despite bringing his team to a worst record and similar stats as a 40 years old MJ with a better team then MJ ever had with Washington !
And LeBron finish mvp 9 that year !

And mj played all those 82 games half injured anyway and u telling us without 25% of resting like LeBron does for many years now, mj couldn’t be all-nba ???

If I use your IF and speculation like u do I surely can say mj , In this weak sauce era with no D , huge amount of resting by almost every players , MJ probably could of been as good as Lebron to be all-nba for many years past his retirement from 1998 easily. …
maybe not at 40-41 but certainly 2-4 years after his retirement....

Last edited by Montrealcorp; 03-10-2024 at 04:52 AM.
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 06:14 AM
Quote:
But mj didn’t take time off tho …..

MJ took all of 94 off, most of 95, all of 99 off etc ..

You don't see how playing 21 consecutive seasons is harder than playing 10, especially when you have as many deep playoff runs as Lebron had

You are also trying to compare Jordan's Wizard year to Lebron as a rookie, I mean come on

You ignore that Lebron has had quite a few injuries over the past 5 years that have been the main reason he's missed games, more than the load management but also want to only look at the healthy Jordan Wizards games

Quote:
If I use your IF and speculation like u do I surely can say mj , In this weak sauce era with no D , huge amount of resting by almost every players , MJ probably could of been as good as Lebron to be all-nba for many years past his retirement from 1998 easily. …
maybe not at 40-41 but certainly 2-4 years after his retirement....
time machine where he doesn't quit twice and plays straight to 40, the funny part would be that it likely would hurt his GOAT status with you guys because it's likely he picks up a finals loss and the mystique of 6-0 goes away(maybe they don't get Rodman and restack roster for the 2nd 3peat etc), it's ****ing hard to play 20 seasons, Lebron is the first player in history to still be dominant in year 20+ you can't just add 50% of Jordan's career worth of games in a hypothetical

Jordan was a quitter
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 07:11 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bottomset
MJ took all of 94 off, most of 95, all of 99 off etc ..

You don't see how playing 21 consecutive seasons is harder than playing 10, especially when you have as many deep playoff runs as Lebron had

You are also trying to compare Jordan's Wizard year to Lebron as a rookie, I mean come on

You ignore that Lebron has had quite a few injuries over the past 5 years that have been the main reason he's missed games, more than the load management but also want to only look at the healthy Jordan Wizards games



time machine where he doesn't quit twice and plays straight to 40, the funny part would be that it likely would hurt his GOAT status with you guys because it's likely he picks up a finals loss and the mystique of 6-0 goes away(maybe they don't get Rodman and restack roster for the 2nd 3peat etc), it's ****ing hard to play 20 seasons, Lebron is the first player in history to still be dominant in year 20+ you can't just add 50% of Jordan's career worth of games in a hypothetical

Jordan was a quitter
o0
after that injury MJ was planly done but to say he washed out at 38 where his first 46 games was impressive , no i think what he showed at 38 certainly would of been able to do better at 35-36-37 , especially if u had up him taking rest .

the concept of comparing lebron and MJ isnt to prove MJ was better then Lebron rookie and second year, it is to compare the similar opposition !

Lebron didnt made the playoffs with a better team and making around the same stats as MJ pre injury and making around the same wins as MJ as well.
And lebron second year did made the all nba with similar stats as MJ pre injury vs the same competition.

it isnt hard to just imagine a little more of MJ not having an injury and just continuing on trend for another 20-25 games and see MJ clearly making the playoffs and being all-nba .

If MJ sucked in his first year pre-injury and second year then sorry to say but lebron sucked even more cause he had a better team and couldnt do much better and still lebron was considered mvp 9 in his first year and made all-nba in his second ....

was steve nash at 17-7-3 better then MJ at 25-6-5 pre injury for 3rd team for example ?
MJ was legit in his return when u look the progression and team record, thats all.

And again the narrative isnt MJ being 40 , its about MJ not being able to do what lebron did at 35+ which to me is ludicrous.
he clearly showed he probably at least untill 36-37 taking into account his 46 games at 38 and the competition he had to face.
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 07:22 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
Second season Lebron miss again the playoffs while running at 27-7-7 (career average ) with a 42-40 team .
His all-nba ! Finish mvp 6 with those numbers !

That is just 2 season after mj retired , meaning same competition .

bolded part
So candybar opinion mj sucked and couldn’t be all-nba when he return right ?
lets use IF like candybar love to use....
Without any resting MJ first season return in 2002 , before the injury mj was at 25-6-5 playing all 46 games !

In his last 20 games up to the injury MJ averaged
27- 6.- 5 on 44%

In his last 10 games up to the injury MJ averaged
29 - 6.- 6 on 47%

before the Injury (46 games) .
That means he got better as the season progress which is normal .
He transform a team from 19-63 to a 26-20 team before the injury on its way to the playoffs .

Tell me candy bar , 20 games before the injury does that look like the stats of a young LeBron james being second all-nba in his second season despite his team missing the play off vs similar competition ?

Btw 46 games is just 10-15 games below many latest season where LeBron played 55 games 56 games at the same age where everyone praise his goatness with all-nba level right ?
But mj didn’t take time off tho …..

But yeah mj played with injury and couldn’t make his team wins anymore but he didn’t quit and still played 60 games trying to win injured ….and reducing his stats since it’s so important to you …


Now imagine if mj would have take a bit easier with some rest like lebron act today in an easier era on top of that !

His last season mj ran at 20-6-3 injured leading his team to a 37-45 season .
But mj sucked in your opinion that year and when I compared Lebron first season ( the season right after vs similar competition),
Lebron is great and no one says Lebron sucks despite bringing his team to a worst record and similar stats as a 40 years old MJ with a better team then MJ ever had with Washington !
And LeBron finish mvp 9 that year !

And mj played all those 82 games half injured anyway and u telling us without 25% of resting like LeBron does for many years now, mj couldn’t be all-nba ???
LMAO this is such busto analysis, par for the course for you.

The pro-Jordan crowd really just sorts by ppg, efficiency be damned.

Michael Jordan had a TS% of .468 and .491 in his Wizards seasons. The league average TS% was .520 and .519 in those seasons. Old Jordan was the definition of an inefficient chucker.

How is that in any way comparable to 2nd year LeBron putting up 27 ppg on an above average .554 TS% vs league average of .529 TS%?

As long as you both put up similar ppg who cares how many possessions you use up right? LMAO.
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 07:26 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bottomset
MJ took all of 94 off, most of 95, all of 99 off etc ..

You don't see how playing 21 consecutive seasons is harder than playing 10, especially when you have as many deep playoff runs as Lebron had

You are also trying to compare Jordan's Wizard year to Lebron as a rookie, I mean come on

You ignore that Lebron has had quite a few injuries over the past 5 years that have been the main reason he's missed games, more than the load management but also want to only look at the healthy Jordan Wizards games



time machine where he doesn't quit twice and plays straight to 40, the funny part would be that it likely would hurt his GOAT status with you guys because it's likely he picks up a finals loss and the mystique of 6-0 goes away(maybe they don't get Rodman and restack roster for the 2nd 3peat etc), it's ****ing hard to play 20 seasons, Lebron is the first player in history to still be dominant in year 20+ you can't just add 50% of Jordan's career worth of games in a hypothetical

Jordan was a quitter
is 46 games pre injury with 25-6-5 has a whole ( 27-6-5 in his last 20 games and even better at the end ) that far off from 55-60 games of all-nba lebron James with the team Lebron had the last couple years compare to what Mj had to work with ?
really ?
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 07:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
was steve nash at 17-7-3 better then MJ at 25-6-5 pre injury for 3rd team for example ?
LOL, just incredible.

Steve Nash (pre-peak in 2002) had a .602 TS% and was one of the best passers in the NBA.

Jordan had a .468 TS%. The league average TS% was .520.

Gee who was better? Seems like a toss-up huh?

Honestly, you talk about people being mean to you but then you keep posting gems like this thinking you're actually making solid points.
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 07:36 AM
"Jordan is a quitter" lol.
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 08:01 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montrealcorp
is 46 games pre injury with 25-6-5 has a whole ( 27-6-5 in his last 20 games and even better at the end ) that far off from 55-60 games of all-nba lebron James with the team Lebron had the last couple years compare to what Mj had to work with ?
really ?
Yes, it's very different because old Jordan was a negative shooter, which you keep ignoring. With diminished athleticism old Jordan was basically hero-balling a bunch of long twos all the time, leading to below-average TS%.

Old LeBron is All-NBA because he still scores very efficiently (above average TS%), helped out by being a solid 3-point shooter. They are not the same.
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 08:20 AM
This is honestly so, so embarassing for the pro-Jordan crowd.

If I was a Jordan guy I would talk about his peak seasons from 88-93 and just pretend his Wizards years never existed. Not try to argue that Wizards Jordan was still a legitimately good player comparable to old LeBron James, or Steve Nash (Jesus that was a brutal comparison).

Michael Jordan LOSES the longevity argument full-stop. Stop trying to argue it because it only makes you look like an idiot for not understanding that being an inefficient volume chucker is not valuable, AT ALL.

Peak Jordan was a GOAT-level talent, stick to that. Wizards Jordan is no better than old Carmelo Anthony.
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
03-10-2024 , 05:20 PM
The 2009 and 2010 Cavs had better defenses than the 1st three-peat Bulls and more scoring options - their 3rd option (Jamison) has over 20k career points and more than Pippen.

Last edited by fallguy; 03-10-2024 at 05:43 PM.
Elon Musk > Wemby > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote

      
m