Quote:
Originally Posted by capone0
this is your sides' argument to a T. jfc you guys are dumb. MJ lead some of the best teams all time--yet his teammates all suck ass. Lebron lead very good teams--I only think this year his teammates have sucked since the the Heat/Cavs teams he's joined. it's almost as if you don't read your own sides arguments. Rodman is some how trash. Pippen was lucky to play with MJ. Like I don't believe either of those arguments.
lol no that's u. Do you actually need me to find one of the 4 billion posts (that's an exaggeration no need to freak) that say LeBron wins series and it's all him but when he loses it's because his teammates sucked? That's literally like half the posts from your side.
Rodman and Pippen were both good obv. Pippen was indeed lucky to play with Jordan and that's partly why he turned into the player he became.
Wade and Bosh were both in their 20's when the joined superbronsquad. Both players tanked statistically. Hmm I wonder if that's due to LeBron's play style. Can't say that about Jordan. Pippen became Pippen under Jordan.
Superbronsquad underperformed relative to talent. But LeBron got his $TAT$. Yet somehow only two rings. Every good player who plays with Bron goes down statistically. Hmm I wonder if his play leads to good stats for himself but those stats don't correlate with wins as well (unlike Jordan with 6 rings). Let's see 3 rings in 15 years. Loss to Mavs. Yeah that sounds about right.
Quote:
Lebron had some really great teams. Who hasn't said this?
Well definitely quite a few Slappies. One directly stated LeBron has played with trash his whole career. Several others say or imply Wade and Bosh were not good anymore on the handpicked super team. Like lol for days.
Quote:
Have they been the best teams or has he had the best teammates all time? Nope. They've been flawed through injury or team construction or coaching. In the pantheon of all great squads, I don't think the Cavs or Heat are on top of them by any means but they're all quite good. Wade and Bosh were both sick teammates and great 2nd and 3rd options. So were Pippen and Rodman/Grant, all sick teammates. Kyrie was great and Love was great at times--and Kyrie was especially good in the 2016 finals with that being said based on the current league construction such as the Warriors your big 3 and the rest of your team needs to be outstanding to beat teams as good as the Warriors or even the Spurs. I think both sides have been arguing that guys on the Cavs are good but they definitely have been outclassed at times by the Warriors.
Yeah both Jordan and LeBron played with good talent and were on good teams. Fortunately for the Jordan side, MJ was able to translate playing with good talent on good teams to 6 rings. LeBron less than that.
Quote:
You win in the NBA because typically you have the best team.
Yep.
Quote:
Sometimes you do with the GOAT depending on who's yours is--the 6 final teams for the Bulls, or sometimes you don't--i.e. the great Jordan of the 80s that had no rings.
Yep. He went up against some all-time Celtics and Pistons teams. Cavs and Hawks had good teams too.
Quote:
Similarly, sometimes the Cavs/Heat had the best team and sometimes they didn't. Lebron has been consistently good not only in the regular season but the playoffs since the 2012 season yet he's only won a few times--why is that? I would say sometimes it's been injuries to his teammates. Other times its been because other teams are better.
And other times it's been because LeBron has under performed. Maybe because his play style puts up good $TAT$ but doesn't always correlate to expected wins. This may be why Jordan has 6 rings, and LeBron has 3. It also may be why Jordan is running 2 rings above expectation but LeBron slightly below.
Quote:
Again the issue is sometimes it has nothing to do with the GOAT--their respective teams weren't good enough at times and sometimes it has a lot to do with them but also their teammates. The Bulls kept winning despite MJ fading (meaning he wasn't nearly as GOATly but still quite good) near the tail end of the 2nd 3 peat. Do you think if Lebron fades on the Cavs team they have a better shot at winning? Hell no, they have to face the ****ing Warriors with KD.
And sometimes it does have to with with the GOAT. Sometimes the GOAT can't bring it home in the big moments. Sometimes he may put up big numbers but at the sacrifice of overall team success, leading to fewer rings than expected. Sometimes there are players that put up similar or slightly better stats, and their team OVERperforms expectations (there was a guy who played for the Bulls in the 80's and 90's who did this).
This is why team success matters because statistics cannot perfectly represent contributions to wins and championships.