Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread
View Poll Results: GOAT?
labron
182 30.43%
MJ (Michael or Maple)
319 53.34%
Therapist
8 1.34%
George Mikan
5 0.84%
Shaq Attaq
21 3.51%
Wilt the Stilt (100 pts yo)
13 2.17%
Timmy "Big Fundamentals" Duncan
20 3.34%
"Roger Murdock"
3 0.50%
Enchanted AIDS Wang (er, HIV+?)
9 1.51%
Larry Legend (+ HM to Bill Russell's laugh)
18 3.01%

05-28-2017 , 11:03 AM
lol I searched for who was favorite for 93 Finals and a 2+2 post came up...

http://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/46...vorite-787816/
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 12:52 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fidstar-poker
I would have been surprised if Bulls v Phx was a landslide favorites to the Bulls.


I'm surprised that Gerb iLL hasn't made the argument that the league was better back in the day because the USA Dream Team use to tear up the opposition, now the USA struggle to win international games! Talked about the game dropping off!
Jordan is a 2x Olympic gold medalist, who exerted his will the most as the man on each team.

LeBron got a bronze medal the first time out, as a non factor. Must be this new fangled euro/asian talent pool.

Seems like that Jordan guy won a lot, did you know he had a game winner for an NCAA trophy too?
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 01:06 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gerb iLL
Jordan is a 2x Olympic gold medalist, who exerted his will the most as the man on each team.

LeBron got a bronze medal the first time out, as a non factor. Must be this new fangled euro/asian talent pool.
You do know that they win both gold medals even if MJ hadn't of turned up, right?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gerb iLL
Seems like that Jordan guy won a lot, did you know he had a game winner for an NCAA trophy too?
You mean in the game he was the 3rd best player on the court?
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 01:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fidstar-poker
You do know that they win both gold medals even if MJ hadn't of turned up, right?



You mean in the game he was the 3rd best player on the court?
Doesn't matter if he was the last man on the bench, hitting a jumper with a championship on the line isn't anything to sniff at.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 01:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gerb iLL
Doesn't matter if he was the last man on the bench, hitting a jumper with a championship on the line isn't anything to sniff at.
of course not.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 02:15 PM
LeBron was also NBA ready at 18 years old. Jordan wasn't good enough.

LeBron was also the better high school player than Jordan.

This should be included in greatest of all time basketball player. Being picked #1 should also be counted as well. Jordan didn't eviscerate the college level enough to be picked #1.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 02:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
LeBron was also NBA ready at 18 years old. Jordan wasn't good enough.

LeBron was also the better high school player than Jordan.

This should be included in greatest of all time basketball player. Being picked #1 should also be counted as well. Jordan didn't eviscerate the college level enough to be picked #1.
Then you have to count MJs ncaa title.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 02:24 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
LeBron was also NBA ready at 18 years old. Jordan wasn't good enough.

LeBron was also the better high school player than Jordan.
LeBron is physical God.

Could you actually go to the NBA straight from highschool in MJ's day? I honestly don't know.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
This should be included in greatest of all time basketball player. Being picked #1 should also be counted as well. Jordan didn't eviscerate the college level enough to be picked #1.
No it shouldn't.

Being pick number 1 is irrelevant in GOAT discussions.

And college play is only a very very minor thing.

Also, MJ was seen as probably the best player in that draft (at worst 2nd best). I mean he won college player of the year the year he was drafted. It's just big men were drafted back then. Had the same draft happened today, he probably goes number 1. And LeBron (while in a loaded draft) didn't have anyone as great as Hakeem to be drafted against.

But as I said, where you were drafted is irrelevant. And college career is very very minor in the scheme of things.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 03:00 PM
Looks like it was possible to get drafted out of HS during that time it just wasn't common place.

Quote:
In the early years of the NBA draft, a player had to finish his four-year college eligibility to be eligible for selection. Reggie Harding, who had graduated from high school but did not enroll in a college, became the first player drafted out of high school when the Detroit Pistons selected him in the fourth round of the 1962 draft.[3] However, the NBA rules at that time prohibited a high school player to play in the league until one year after his high school class graduated.[4][5] Thus, he spent a year playing in a minor basketball league before he was drafted again in the 1963 draft by the Pistons.[6] He finally entered the league in the 1963–64 season and played four seasons in the NBA and American Basketball Association (ABA).[7]

In 1971, the U.S. Supreme Court decision Haywood v. National Basketball Association ruled, 7–2 against the National Basketball Association's requirement that a player must wait four years after high school graduation (which in most cases was spent playing in college) before turning professional. This ruling allowed players to enter the NBA Draft without four years of college, provided they could give evidence of hardship to the NBA office.[8]

In 1974, the NBA's rival, the ABA, drafted high school star Moses Malone. He was immediately signed by the Utah Stars and became the first player to go directly from high school basketball to a professional league.[9] He became an instant success, averaging 18 points and 14 rebounds per game in his rookie season. He played in the ABA until the ABA–NBA merger in 1976. He then played 19 successful seasons with 7 NBA teams. He won the NBA championship, along with the Finals Most Valuable Player Award, with the Philadelphia 76ers in 1983. His other achievements include 3 Most Valuable Player Awards, 12 consecutive All-Star Game selections, 8 All-NBA Team selections and 6 rebounding titles. He has been inducted to the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame and was also named in the 50 Greatest Players in NBA History list announced at the league's 50th anniversary in 1996.[10]

A year later, two high school players, Darryl Dawkins and Bill Willoughby, applied for hardship and were declared eligible to be selected in the 1975 draft.[11] They had applied and gave evidence of financial hardship to the league, which granted them the right to start earning their living by starting their professional careers earlier.[8] Dawkins was selected 5th by the Philadelphia 76ers while Willoughby was selected 19th by the Atlanta Hawks. Dawkins played 14 seasons and averaged 12 points and 6 rebounds per game. Willoughby played 8 seasons with 6 different teams and averaged only 6 points per game. Neither player reached the level of success that was expected. It is argued that they could have been better players if they had college basketball experience before entering the NBA.[12][13][14]

After Dawkins and Willoughby, no high schoolers were drafted for 14 years, though several players entered the league without playing college basketball. One notable player, Shawn Kemp, enrolled in college but never played any games due to personal problems. In 1989, a year after his high school graduation, he was drafted by the Seattle SuperSonics.[15] He played 14 seasons in the NBA and was selected to 6 All-Star Games and 3 All-NBA Teams.[16]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NBA_high_school_draftees

KG started the straight outta HS era in 1995.

Harding 1962
Dawkins/Willoughby 1975
KG-1995

44 were taken out of HS all time (including 2 the last few years who had pro-grad work).

Guys of note:

Great Ones: KG/Kobe/Lebron/Amare/Dwight/Dawkins/McGrady
Good: Lewis/Chandler/Al Jeff/ByDUMB/Josh Smith
LOL: Curry/Swift
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 03:06 PM
1983 draft wow:

Hakeem
MJ
Barkley
Stockton

Perkins/Thorpe/Willis

2003

Bron
Wade
Melo
Bosh

West/Korver/Hinrich

4 top 25 players all time including 3 top 15 on most peoples' lists in 1983. 2003 is pretty incredible as well and eventhough they have a similar # of likely HOFers; other than Bron, Wade is probably in the 20-30 range; Bosh/Melo are likely not top 100 players of all time.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 03:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fidstar-poker
LeBron is physical God.

Could you actually go to the NBA straight from highschool in MJ's day? I honestly don't know.



No it shouldn't.

Being pick number 1 is irrelevant in GOAT discussions.

And college play is only a very very minor thing.

Also, MJ was seen as probably the best player in that draft (at worst 2nd best). I mean he won college player of the year the year he was drafted. It's just big men were drafted back then. Had the same draft happened today, he probably goes number 1. And LeBron (while in a loaded draft) didn't have anyone as great as Hakeem to be drafted against.

But as I said, where you were drafted is irrelevant. And college career is very very minor in the scheme of things.
Moses Malone skipped college in 1974.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 03:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by capone0
1983 draft wow:

Hakeem
MJ
Barkley
Stockton

Perkins/Thorpe/Willis

2003

Bron
Wade
Melo
Bosh

West/Korver/Hinrich

4 top 25 players all time including 3 top 15 on most peoples' lists in 1983. 2003 is pretty incredible as well and eventhough they have a similar # of likely HOFers; other than Bron, Wade is probably in the 20-30 range; Bosh/Melo are likely not top 100 players of all time.
They're both def top 100 if you don't adjust for era. I mean, Mitch Richmond is a HoFer.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 03:43 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by capone0
1983 draft wow:

Hakeem
MJ
Barkley
Stockton

Perkins/Thorpe/Willis

2003

Bron
Wade
Melo
Bosh

West/Korver/Hinrich

4 top 25 players all time including 3 top 15 on most peoples' lists in 1983. 2003 is pretty incredible as well and eventhough they have a similar # of likely HOFers; other than Bron, Wade is probably in the 20-30 range; Bosh/Melo are likely not top 100 players of all time.
84 draft is great as they would make a great team.

Hakeem
MJ
Barkley
Stockton

Only spot left is for a SF, and Perk could play there I guess.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 04:43 PM
Great team indeed , 3 players in line up of 1992 dream team and Hakeem was of course good enough to
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 06:20 PM
Mitch Richmond is a boss. Used to rip up NBA live 95 with him.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 06:41 PM
RT,

Focusing on the hall of famers Jordan and LeBron faced in the finals seems pretty disingenuous considering lebrons only real competition in the finals. I'd be curious to better understand the whole picture in that regard. I haven't verified but this is interesting:



Jordan obviously played against much better competition since his road to the finals was so much more difficult. The truth is LeBron has only faced real competition about 7 times. Pistons and Celtics teams were past their prime and LeBron still found a way to quit/lose. Also more context needs to be added to the hall of famers discussion each player has been played. Like LeBron faced a thunder team that was way to young, the spurs core was passed their primes, and an injured warriors team last year.

I think it's interesting in the finals two of the times he won he barely did so with a lot of positive variance and hall of famers bailing him out. Of the 4 losses none of them were competitive at all. A classic skull ****ing 4 times in a row. Role players like deshawn Stevenson, Danny green, Jason Terry, iggy, etc all did very well because they were facing LeBron in the clutch.



To your point tho if LeBron goes into God mode against a healthy warriors team that added is, that is probably more impressive than anything Jordan has done.

Last edited by AcTiOnJaCsOn; 05-28-2017 at 06:54 PM.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 06:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by VincentVega
Mitch Richmond is a boss. Used to rip up NBA live 95 with him.


NBA Live 95 was the best.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 07:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
Dude. You have lebron and kobe as close. You are by far the most wrong poster itt.

Even gerb aj and woody dont go that far.

You dont get to critique smarter posters arguments.


No offense bro but you lose a lot of credibility making arguments when you try and say LeBron faced better competition than Jordan. You're not really in a position to act righteous or holier than thou.

Cowardly jumping from super team to super team in an extremely weak east should be correctly accounted for. Having a losing record against the few times he had to face a great team is important considering the path to the finals is a cakewalk.

Also didnt you mention kyrie was simply good but not a star? Kyrie haters are really something. Please let me know if I am mis representing what you said at all.

You're right though I'd have bron >>> Kobe even if Kobe has a lot more alpha of a personality and is way more fierce of a competitor.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 07:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by VincentVega
Mitch Richmond is a boss. Used to rip up NBA live 95 with him.
dan majerle ftw
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 07:17 PM
check another box for MJ

Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 07:18 PM
playing blackjack over other vegas games i mean. not the insecurity
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 07:26 PM
Just impossible to be the GOAT when you're always an underdog
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 07:32 PM
some reddit kid did the math, and assuming $100 bet size you'd be down $33 betting for lebron in the finals and up 12 betting against him. would love to see preseason data as well and then obviously the stats on jordan
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 07:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wooders0n
Just impossible to be the GOAT when you're always an underdog
Not at all, it just means that player has a heavier work load.
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote
05-28-2017 , 07:36 PM
Has Lebron faced any HoFer's in the East other than Bostons big 3?
Wemby > Antman > Jordan > Lebron GOAT Super AIDS Containment Thread Quote

      
m