Quote:
Originally Posted by MediaPA
Ok, I'll bite. It sounds like you blame his decisions for the personnel that will be available against Mexico. How so? It looked like a line up attempting to get a positive result that failed due to defensive shortcomings from everything I've read.
I didn't watch the match, but I'm guessing this refers to Altidore (yellow in a 3-1 game in extra time - brilliant, even if possibly undeserved), Bradley (yeah, he can control that), Besler (eh, whatever), Cameron (no clue, but he was going to play this game regardless).
Tactically he was irresponsible early imo. Or our players were against his wishes. One or the other. The Orozco start was an unmitigated disaster. Cameron at RB with Mix (positive) or Beckerman (defensive) would have been preferable I believe.
As it is, I've been a proponent of him going back to the bucket at this point. And this game would have lined up well for it. Starting Beckerman and Jones in front of a more staid back 4 with Orozco on the bench would have left us much better prepared to start the match. Landon and Clint slotted behind Aron and EJ would have been my preferred lineup in the top 2-2 if Jozy wasn't all the way fit. As it was, once we're down 2-1 I feel like you need to keep Jozy on the bench until Tuesday. the EV of trying to scrape 1 point on the road does not exceed the EV of trying to grab a 2 point win difference at home at that point. Plus he's coming off an injury. Just rest him.
The key was the first few minutes of the match. Their aggression should have been countered early. The first goal was a great set piece (again, we give up vs set pieces. frustrating.) But that second goal was really rough to watch Beasley try and mark 3 dudes in the box against a counter cross.
As I said, I'm no torch bearer or a demand-excellencer. I feel like we're ahead of where I thought we'd be. I just feel that sometimes we're tactically unprepared at the start of matches. I'm tired of watching us go down early, have been for a decade. And while I applaud his efforts to turn us into a more positive side, and for the most part I find them effective, I think sometimes discretion is the better part of valor. Yesterday was one of those instances.