Quote:
Originally Posted by loosekanen
re: Pulisic physicality. Certainly I won't argue that he's not physical and that he'd have issues with the Otamendis and the Xhakas of the world. He's still just 19, though, and I would argue that the next part of his development may be in learning how to use skill and tactical acumen to compete against those guys. If he's indeed plateaud which: I mean, he's 19 so probably not and even if he has he's still our best player, then there is likely to be more gleaned from being challenged tactically and in a different league than continuing to run forward with Dortmund.
I still love the idea of him moving to the PL but I'd still prefer it be with a mid table team. I would love to see him with Yedlinny at Newcastle, for instance, a team that goes forward but would also be not so flush with talent that he would have trouble cracking the 11.
Xhaka is absolute trash. Pulisic would destroy him.
But that's the point. He needs to play against the best in the world at some point. What do you think teams in CONCACAF are going to do to him? Kick the **** out of him just like they are doing.
A move to Newcastle is a massive step down from Dortmund. Newcastle situation is actually pretty dire except for having an elite manager. Zero chance they'd ever spend for Pulisic anyway so it's a moot point. Michael Owen is STILL their record signing.
Eventually he is going to have to make the move. I've no problems with him staying in Germany another year, and it's probably best for his development, but after that it's time to move up a level. I think Klopp would be absolutely perfect for him. And with a deep team who is competing on all fronts, he will still get plenty of games without being overly relied on or burnt out, and grow into a role over the next 5 years at a legitimate top club itw